An official website of the United States government
Models which address both the Hubble and S8 tensions with the same mechanism generically cause a pre-recombination suppression of the small scale matter power spectrum. Here we focus on two such models. Both models introduce a self-interacting dark radiation fluid scattering with dark matter, which has a step in its abundance around some transition redshift. In one model, the interaction is weak and with all of the dark matter whereas in the other it is strong but with only a fraction of the dark matter. The weakly interacting case is able to address both tensions simultaneously and provide a good fit to a the Planck measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the Pantheon Type Ia supernovae, and a combination of low and high redshift baryon acoustic oscillation data, whereas the strongly interacting model cannot significantly ease both tensions simultaneously. The addition of high-resolution cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements (ACT DR4 and SPT-3G) slightly limits both model's ability to address the Hubble tension. The use of the effective field theory of large-scale structures analysis of BOSS DR12 LRG and eBOSS DR16 QSO data additionally limits their ability to address the S8 tension. We explore how these models respond to these data sets in detail in order to draw general conclusions about what is required for a mechanism to address both tensions. We find that in order to fit the CMB data the time dependence of the suppression of the matter power spectrum plays a central role.
more »
« less
Hubble tension and gravitational self-interaction
Abstract One of the most important problems vexing the ΛCDM cosmological model is the Hubble tension. It arises from the fact that measurements of the present value of the Hubble parameter performed with low-redshift quantities, e.g. the Type IA supernova, tend to yield larger values than measurements from quantities originating at high-redshift, e.g. fits of cosmic microwave background radiation. It is becoming likely that the discrepancy, currently standing at 5σ, is not due to systematic errors in the measurements. Here we explore whether the self-interaction of gravitational fields in General Relativity, which are traditionally neglected when studying the evolution of the Universe, can contribute to explaining the tension. We find that with field self-interaction accounted for, both low- and high-redshift data aresimultaneouslywell-fitted, thereby showing that gravitational self-interaction yield consistentH0values when inferred from SnIA and cosmic microwave background observations. Crucially, this is achieved without introducing additional parameters.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1847771
- PAR ID:
- 10517329
- Publisher / Repository:
- IOP Publishing
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Physica Scripta
- Volume:
- 99
- Issue:
- 7
- ISSN:
- 0031-8949
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: Article No. 075043
- Size(s):
- Article No. 075043
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Context. Persistent tension between low-redshift observations and the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB), in terms of two fundamental distance scales set by the sound horizon r d and the Hubble constant H 0 , suggests new physics beyond the Standard Model, departures from concordance cosmology, or residual systematics. Aims. The role of different probe combinations must be assessed, as well as of different physical models that can alter the expansion history of the Universe and the inferred cosmological parameters. Methods. We examined recently updated distance calibrations from Cepheids, gravitational lensing time-delay observations, and the tip of the red giant branch. Calibrating the baryon acoustic oscillations and type Ia supernovae with combinations of the distance indicators, we obtained a joint and self-consistent measurement of H 0 and r d at low redshift, independent of cosmological models and CMB inference. In an attempt to alleviate the tension between late-time and CMB-based measurements, we considered four extensions of the standard ΛCDM model. Results. The sound horizon from our different measurements is r d = (137 ± 3 stat. ± 2 syst. ) Mpc based on absolute distance calibration from gravitational lensing and the cosmic distance ladder. Depending on the adopted distance indicators, the combined tension in H 0 and r d ranges between 2.3 and 5.1 σ , and it is independent of changes to the low-redshift expansion history. We find that modifications of ΛCDM that change the physics after recombination fail to provide a solution to the problem, for the reason that they only resolve the tension in H 0 , while the tension in r d remains unchanged. Pre-recombination extensions (with early dark energy or the effective number of neutrinos N eff = 3.24 ± 0.16) are allowed by the data, unless the calibration from Cepheids is included. Conclusions. Results from time-delay lenses are consistent with those from distance-ladder calibrations and point to a discrepancy between absolute distance scales measured from the CMB (assuming the standard cosmological model) and late-time observations. New proposals to resolve this tension should be examined with respect to reconciling not only the Hubble constant but also the sound horizon derived from the CMB and other cosmological probes.more » « less
-
The enduring tension between local and distant measurements H0 remains unresolved. It was recently pointed out that cosmic microwave background (CMB) and large-scale structure (LSS) observables are invariant under a uniform rescaling of the gravitational free-fall rates of all species present and the Thomson scattering rate between photons and electrons. We show that a unique variation of the fine-structure constant α and the electron mass m_e can leverage this scaling transformation to reconcile the CMB and LSS data with a broad spectrum of Hubble constant values, encompassing those inferred from local measurements. Importantly, this study demonstrates that the constraints on the variation of fundamental constants imposed by the specific recombination history are not as stringent as previously assumed. Our work highlights the critical role of the Thomson scattering rate in the existing Hubble tension and offers a distinct avenue of exploration for particle model builders.more » « less
-
Abstract The Hubble-Lemaître tension is currently one of the most important questions in cosmology. Most of the focus so far has been on reconciling the Hubble constant value inferred from detailed cosmic microwave background measurement with that from the local distance ladder. This emphasis on one number — namely H 0 — misses the fact that the tension fundamentally arises from disagreements of distance measurements. To be successful, a proposed cosmological model must accurately fit these distances rather than simply infer a given value of H 0 .Using the newly developed likelihood package ` distanceladder ', which integrates the local distance ladder into MontePython , we show that focusing on H 0 at the expense of distances can lead to the spurious detection of new physics in models which change late-time cosmology. As such, we encourage the observational cosmology community to make their actual distance measurements broadly available to model builders instead of simply quoting their derived Hubble constant values.more » « less
-
Abstract Recently, it was pointed out that invoking a large value of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) optical depth,τCMB = 0.09, could help resolve tensions between Dark Energy Survey Instrument DR2 baryon acoustic oscillation data and the CMB. This is larger than the value ofτCMB = 0.058 measured from the Planck low-ℓpolarization data. Traditionally,τCMBis thought of as a constraint on reionization’s midpoint. However, recent observations and modeling of the Lyαforest of high-zquasars at 5 < z < 6 have tightly constrained the timing of the last 10%–20% of reionization, adding nuance to this interpretation. Here, we point out that fixing reionization’s endpoint, in accordance with the latest Lyαforest constraints, rendersτCMBa sensitive probe of the duration of reionization, as well as its midpoint. We compare low and high values ofτCMBto upper limits on the patchy kinematic Sunyaev–Zel'dovich (pkSZ) effect, another CMB observable that constrains reionization’s duration, and find that a value ofτCMB = 0.09 is in ≈2σtension with existing limits on the pkSZ from the South Pole Telescope (SPT). The strength of this tension is sensitive to the choices involved in modeling the other CMB foregrounds in the SPT measurement, and in the modeling of the pkSZ signal itself.more » « less
