skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: CASE HISTORY-BASED VALIDATION OF NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF BACKWARD EROSION PIPING USING THE BOIS BRULE LEVEE BREACH
Backward erosion piping (BEP) is a major risk factor for both dams and levees. A significant amount of work has been performed to examine the likelihood of initiation of BEP through examination of critical gradients for sand boil formation and the development of semi-empirical approaches to assess the likelihood of erosion continuing and progressing to a breach. Recently, numerical analyses have been developed to model the BEP process and these tools offer a means to incorporate more complex geometries and soil conditions than can be assessed within the semi-empirical approaches. These simulation methods have been primarily applied to laboratory tests and physical models with uniform properties, but there is a need to validate these models using case histories and explore how variability in stratigraphy and properties influences the BEP process. This study will apply numerical approaches for simulating BEP to the case history of the Bois Brule levee breach that occurred during flooding in July 1993. This paper first describes the Bois Brule levee and observations during flooding. Numerical simulations of piping progression are used to explore the effect of reasonable variations in properties and stratigraphy on the likelihood of failure and the sensitivity of the results to the river level at the time of failure. The paper highlights challenges in modeling BEP and provides guidance on which factors have the largest impact of the results.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2047402
PAR ID:
10519289
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
United States Society on Dams
Date Published:
Format(s):
Medium: X
Location:
Seattle, WA
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; (, Geo-Congress 2023)
    Rathje, Ellen; Montoya, Brina M.; Wayne, Mark H. (Ed.)
    Soil piping is the gradual and progressive erosion of soil grains, causing a void (open pipe) to form as water flows through the soil. In dam engineering, this type of internal erosion is often referred to as concentrated leak erosion and has been a cause of failure at multiple dams. Soil piping has also been observed in many landslides and contributes significantly to soil degradation in hillslopes and agricultural areas. Despite these many important impacts, there is still limited understanding of how soil pipes develop and progress and what factors control pipe stability. One of the significant challenges with analyzing soil piping, or concentrated leak erosion, is that it typically occurs in the vadose zone, where unsaturated conditions are present. However, most studies examining internal erosion have focused on saturated conditions, and few studies have examined the role unsaturated hydraulic properties (i.e., air entry value, matric suction, etc.) may play in the likelihood of internal erosion. Consequently, this study aims to explore the mechanisms controlling the erosion rate within soil pipes from the perspective of unsaturated soil mechanics. Bench-scale experiments were performed to examine the formation and progression of an eroded pipe in a small slope constructed at different water contents. Soil samples were also tested to measure its unsaturated hydraulic properties. The results show that the likelihood of pipe formation varies with the moisture content and, therefore, suction in the soil, as does the potential for pipe collapse. This demonstrates that unsaturated soil properties are key to understanding the formation and progression of piping in slopes. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; (, Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface)
    Abstract Natural levees form through sediment delivery from channels, dispersal onto floodplains, and storage at channel margins. When levees breach, they release water and sediment onto the floodplain, occasionally causing river avulsions. Despite their significance, levee growth remains poorly understood, and no existing models capture the dynamic channel‐levee evolution systems. A common assumption is that levee and channel bed aggradation rates are coupled or equal; however, this cannot be true because levees do not accumulate everywhere along aggrading channel belts. Using a one‐dimensional numerical model, we investigate levee growth decoupled from channel bed aggradation under flood scenarios wherein the flooded level: (a) exceeds the levee crest height (i.e., front loading); or (b) is lower than the levee crest partially inundating distal levee deposits (i.e., back loading). Front loading events initially aggrade the levee crest, which confines the channel, increases bankfull depth, and reduces flooding. During confinement, levee growth restricts flooding, and minor back loading events are more common. Over this period, the channel bed aggrades until bankfull depth decreases sufficiently to trigger larger floods. This channel‐releasing process increases flood likelihood and enhances overbank accumulation, promoting front loading and re‐confining the channel. Our findings suggest aggradational channels may experience confined‐release phases characterized by episodic levee growth and fluctuating bankfull depth. Rapid in‐channel aggradation increases flood frequency and variability with more confined‐release cycles. These results imply that river avulsions and associated floods might preferentially occur when the channel bed aggrades faster than adjacent levees, whereby the channel becomes shallower and destabilized. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; (, Géotechnique)
    Backward erosion piping (BEP) has been recognised as a major cause of failures in water-retaining structures. However, the fundamental mechanisms controlling the phenomenon are not well understood. This research applies the theory of rate processes to develop a constitutive relationship between energy density of the seepage flow and the erosion rate of soils during the evolution of BEP. The resulting equation is used to analyse four datasets of previously reported experimental observations. The mechanical parameters estimated through the proposed model fall into the ranges of values that were reported in the literature. To validate the proposed approach, the constitutive model was incorporated into a multiphase numerical framework to simulate evolution of BEP in embankment soil and compared with reported experimental observations. The numerical framework with the proposed constitutive model is shown to be capable of reproducing both the observed evolution of local hydraulic gradients and pipe progression in the structure. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; (, Geotechnical Frontiers 2025)
    There are growing concerns regarding the increase in flood risk due to climate change and land use/land cover changes. In light of these changes, levees play an increasingly critical role in safeguarding communities, infrastructure, and the natural environment. However, the average age of levees in the United States is 60 years, with the majority operating under marginal conditions. The most common failure mode of earthen levees is breach due to overtopping. Existing methodologies evaluate the site-specific probability of levee overtopping and do not provide a holistic view of flood risk across a wider area. Here we present a regional-scale overtopping model for levees using a data-driven overtopping model that uses five variables: (1) levee construction classification, (2) overtopping depth, (3) overtopping duration, (4) erosion resistance classification, and (5) duration of levee loading before overtopping. The overtopping model is applied to levee systems in Wilton, California. The probability of breach due to overtopping is presented for three distinct scenarios (overtopping duration) during a 50-year flood event. The results show the probability of breach for the Wilton Levee ranges from 0.32 to 0.91 for overtopping durations of 6 hours and between 6 to 24 hours. For durations exceeding 24 hours, the probability of breach increases to a range of 0.73 to 0.98. The proposed framework offers a viable tool for performing regional-scale levee risk assessment, offering broader implications for enhancing preparedness, response, and recovery strategies in the face of escalating flood risks. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; (, International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics)
    ABSTRACT Backward erosion piping (BEP) is a leading internal erosion mechanism for flood protection system failures. A model capable of predicting critical hydraulic conditions for BEP initiation at multiple scales while also incorporating soil variability is a pressing need. This study formulates and validates a novel multiscale probabilistic BEP initiation framework with incorporation of soil variability. The framework is based on a grain‐scale probabilistic model and the weakest link theory, and the theory of rate processes. The multiscale framework proposed herein is validated through a wide range of available experimental data from independent sources, encompassing tests performed at multiple scales. Following calibration with small‐scale experimental data, the model demonstrates accurate prediction of critical hydraulic gradients at larger scales (3–6 orders of magnitude difference), including the ability to capture the grain size dependence of BEP initiation and providing uncertainty estimates. A systematic analysis is performed to uncover the effects of different soil properties on multiscale critical hydraulic conditions. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email