An official website of the United States government
Assessment of earthquake-induced liquefaction is an important topic in geotechnical engineering due to the significant potential for damage to infrastructure. Some of the most significant infrastructure damage occurs due to differential settlement of the ground, including due to liquefaction. Postliquefaction deformations commonly are assessed using one-dimensional empirical models, which inherently assume laterally homogeneous soil layers. Numerical models offer the potential to examine the effects of ground motion variability and spatially variable soil properties on liquefaction-induced deformations. This study explored the postliquefaction reconsolidation settlement for a site in Hollywood, South Carolina, which was characterized using a three-dimensional (3D) geostatistical model and simulated using the numerical platform FLAC and constitutive model PM4Sand. The effects of ground motion characteristics on mean and maximum differential settlements were investigated. The physical mechanisms associated with postliquefaction responses such as excess pore pressures, shear strains, and volumetric strains also were examined. The efficacy of uniform models assuming representative percentile soil properties to represent the stochastic mean settlement was investigated. The inherent inability of uniform models to capture differential settlements and therefore the need for using stochastic models is discussed.
more »
« less
USING THE MATERIAL POINT METHOD TO EXAMINE POST-EARTHQUAKE STABILITY OF SLOPES AND EMBANKMENT DAMS
Earthquake-related failure modes for embankment dams are commonly evaluated through numerical simulations using finite element or finite difference approaches. This is especially true for liquefaction triggering or cyclic softening of fine-grained materials where advanced constitutive models are used to capture the dynamic response of the dam and the nonlinear behavior of the soil. Both liquefaction and cyclic softening can lead to significant strength loss, which can lead to large deformations within the dam, but these numerical tools often cannot capture these large deformations due to excessive mesh distortion and subsequent numerical errors. This leads to significant uncertainties in estimating potential crest settlement, which is often a critical value for risk assessments of dams. Hybrid numerical methods like the material point method (MPM) offer a promising alternative to model large deformations, but their application to dams is still limited and relatively little validation has been done on using MPM for post-earthquake stability analyses. This study focuses on applying MPM simulations to evaluate the post-earthquake stability of a hypothetical embankment dam and to examine potential deformations of a flowslide that occurred in Palu, Indonesia in 2018. The MPM program Anura3D is used for the analyses with modifications to allow for assigning residual strengths. The results from the Palu flowslide are compared with observations from the field to show that the MPM analyses are able to capture the extent of the slide, but underpredict the measured displacements in the central portion of the flowslide. The analyses for the embankment dam are compared with post-earthquake stability results from finite difference analyses using FLAC. The MPM analyses are able to capture the full deformation of the flowslide, while the FLAC analyses are halted due to excessive mesh deformation. These results demonstrate the potential of MPM to be used as a complement to existing numerical tools for evaluating the seismic response of dams, but additional work is needed to validate this approach using case histories with both large and small deformations.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2047402
- PAR ID:
- 10519291
- Publisher / Repository:
- United States Society on Dams
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Location:
- Seattle, WA
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquake sequence produced extensive liquefaction-induced ground deformations and ongoing flooding along the shoreline of the Mediterranean port city of İskenderun, Türkiye. This study compiles field observations and analyses from cross-disciplinary perspectives to investigate whether earthquake-induced liquefaction was a significant factor for increasing the flood hazard in İskenderun. Geotechnical reconnaissance observations following the earthquakes included seaward lateral spreading, settlement beneath buildings, and failures of coastal infrastructure. Three presented lateral spreading case histories indicate consistent ground deformation patterns with areas of reclaimed land. Persistent scatterer interferometry (PSI) measurements from synthetic aperture radar (SAR) imagery identify a noticeably greater rate of pre- and post-earthquake subsidence within the İskenderun coastal and urban areas relative to the surrounding regions. The PSI measurements also indicate subsidence rates accelerated following the earthquakes and were typically highest near the observed liquefaction manifestations. These evaluations suggest that while the liquefaction of coastal reclaimed fill caused significant ground deformations in the shoreline area, ongoing subsidence of İskenderun and other factors likely also exacerbated the flood hazard. Insights from this work suggest the importance of evaluating multi-hazard liquefaction and flood consequences for enhancing the resilience of coastal cities.more » « less
-
This paper presents numerical liquefaction simulations of a hypothetical sand in cyclic direct simple shear tests for four different constitutive models. The four models are PM4Sand in FLAC, UBCSand in FLAC, Pressure Dependent Multi Yield 02 (PDMY02) in OpenSees, and the Manzari-Dafalias04 model in OpenSees. Parameters published by others for various sands were used for this work to avoid possible introduction of our bias into the calibration process. The material properties were determined by others for different uniformly graded sands, all with a relative density of approximately 50%. The simulations do not pertain to one sand or one set of laboratory data, so therefore, there is no right or wrong answer. Instead, the goal of this paper is compare a consistent set of results that show the implementations of each model behave as expected, and to illustrate basic differences in behavior of the different models. Cyclic strength curves (cyclic stress as a function of number of cycles) illustrate the behavior of the models over a range of cyclic stresses. Each model displays pore pressure build up, softening, and cyclic contraction-dilation cycles associated with cyclic mobility. Two of the models soften to a point, but then stabilize in a repeated hysteresis loop with no additional growth in the cyclic strain amplitude after some number of cycles.more » « less
-
Abstract Bedrock landsliding, including the formation of landslide dams, is a predominant geomorphic process in steep landscapes. Clarifying the importance of hydrologic and seismic mechanisms for triggering deep‐seated landslides remains an ongoing effort, and formulation of geomorphic metrics that predict dam preservation is crucial for quantifying secondary landslide hazards. Here, we identify >200 landslide‐dammed lakes in western Oregon and utilize dendrochronology and enhanced14C dating (“wiggle matching”) of “ghost forests” to establish slope failure timing at 20 sites. Our dated landslide dataset reveals bedrock landsliding has been common since the last Cascadia Subduction Zone earthquake in January 1700 AD. Our study does not reveal landslides that date to 1700 AD. Rather, we observe temporal clustering ofat leastfour landslides in the winter of 1889/1890 AD, coincident with a series of atmospheric rivers that generated one of the largest regionally recorded floods. We use topographic and field analyses to assess the relation between dam preservation and topographic characteristics of the impounded valleys. In contrast to previous studies, we do not observe systematic scaling between dam size and upstream drainage area, though dam stability indices for our sites correspond with “stable” dams elsewhere. Notably, we observe that dams are preferentially preserved at drainage areas of ∼1.5 to 13 km2and valley widths of ∼25 to 80 m, which may reflect the reduced downstream influence of debris flows and the accumulation of mature conifer trees upstream from landslide‐dammed lake outlets. We suggest that wood accumulation upstream of landslide dams tempers large stream discharges, thus inhibiting dam incision.more » « less
-
Non-linear dynamic analyses (NDAs) are widely used in engineering practice to evaluate the seismic performance of geotechnical structures affected by liquefaction or cyclic softening. The quality of results from an NDA study depends on several technical and nontechnical factors. Validation, wherein a numerical prediction is compared to its physical counterpart, can assess the ability of an NDA to capture the various metrics of the response and potentially provide guidance toward improving the prediction. This study investigates select methodologies and validation metrics commonly used in signal processing problems to assess their effectiveness in capturing discrepancies between experimental and simulation results for a specific response of interest. Three simple problems are initially evaluated to analyze the metrics’ capabilities and identify necessary modifications. Then, the metrics are applied to nine sets of experimental and simulation time series, focusing on one response of interest (pore water pressure). It is found that cross-correlation successfully captures the lag in the initiation of liquefaction triggering, while Russell’s error metric captures magnitude and phase discrepancies.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
