An official website of the United States government
Abstract Membrane proteins play critical roles in disease and in the disposition of many pharmaceuticals. A prime example is P-glycoprotein (Pgp) which moves a diverse range of drugs across membranes and out of the cell before a therapeutic payload can be delivered. Conventional structural biology methods have provided a valuable framework for comprehending the complex conformational changes underlying Pgp function, which also includes ATPase activity, but the lack of real-time information hinders understanding. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a single-molecule technique that is well-suited for studying active membrane proteins in bilayers and is poised to advance the field beyond static snapshots. After verifying Pgp activity in surface-support bilayers, we used kymograph analysis in conjunction with AFM imaging and simulations to study structural transitions at the 100 ms timescale. Though kymographs are frequently employed to boost temporal resolution, the limitations of the method have not been well characterized, especially for sparse non-crystalline distributions of pharmaceutically relevant membrane proteins like Pgp. Common experimental challenges are analyzed, including protein orientation, instrument noise, and drift. Surprisingly, a lateral drift of 75% of the protein dimension leads to only a 12% probability of erroneous state transition detection; average dwell time error achieves a maximum value of 6%. Rotational drift of proteins like Pgp, with azimuthally-dependent maximum heights, can lead to artifactual transitions. Torsional constraints can alleviate this potential pitfall. Confidence in detected transitions can be increased by adding conformation-altering ligands such as non-hydrolysable analogs. Overall, the data indicate that AFM kymographs are a viable method to access conformational dynamics for Pgp, but generalizations of the method should be made with caution.
more »
« less
Atomic force microscope kymograph analysis: A case study of two membrane proteins
Kymograph analysis is employed across the biological atomic force microscopy (AFM) community to boost temporal resolution. The method is well suited for revealing protein dynamics at the single molecule level in near-native conditions. Yet, kymograph analysis comes with limitations that depend on several factors including protein geometry and instrumental drift. This work focuses on conformational dynamics of difficult-to-study sparse distributions of membrane proteins. We compare and contrast AFM kymograph analysis for two proteins, one of which (SecDF) exhibits conformational dynamics primarily in the vertical direction (normal to the membrane surface) and the other (Pgp) exhibits a combination of lateral dynamics and vertical motion. Common experimental issues are analyzed including translational and rotational drift. Conformational transition detection is evaluated via kymograph simulations followed by state detection algorithms. We find that kymograph analysis is largely robust to lateral drift. Displacement of the AFM line scan trajectory away from the protein center of mass by a few nanometers, roughly half of the molecule diameter, does not significantly affect transition detection nor generate undue dwell time errors. On the other hand, for proteins like Pgp that exhibit significant azimuthal maximum height dependence, rotational drift can potentially produce artifactual transitions. Measuring the height of a membrane protein protrusion is generally superior to measurement of width, confirming intuition based on vertical resolution superiority. In low signal-to-noise scenarios, common state detection algorithms struggle with transition detection as opposed to infinite hidden Markov models. AFM kymography represents a valuable addition to the membrane biophysics toolkit; continued hardware and software improvements are poised to expand the method’s impact in the field.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2122027
- PAR ID:
- 10522339
- Publisher / Repository:
- Elsevier
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Methods
- Volume:
- 223
- Issue:
- C
- ISSN:
- 1046-2023
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 83 to 94
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) can create images of biomolecules under near-native conditions but suffers from limited lateral resolution due to the finite AFM tip size and recording frequency. The recently developed Localization Atomic Force Microscopy or LAFM (Heath et al., Nature 594, 385 (2021)) enhances lateral resolution by reconstructing peak positions in AFM image stacks, but it is less effective for flexible proteins with multiple conformations. Here we introduce an unsupervised deep learning algorithm that simultaneously registers and clusters images by protein conformation, thus making LAFM applicable to more flexible proteins. Using simulated AFM images from molecular dynamics simulations of the SecYEG translocon as a model membrane protein system, we demonstrate improved resolution for individual protein conformations. This work represents a step towards a more general LAFM algorithm that can handle biological macromolecules with multiple distinct conformational states such as SecYEG. Author summaryAtomic Force Microscopy (AFM) enables high-resolution imaging of biomolecules under near-native conditions but faces lateral resolution limits due to the finite AFM tip size and recording frequency. The recently developed Localization Atomic Force Microscopy (LAFM) method addresses this by reconstructing peak positions from AFM image stacks, achieving almost atomic resolution for rigid proteins like bacteriorhodopsin (Heath et al., Nature 594, 385 (2021)). However, flexible membrane proteins with dynamic conformations, such as the SecYEG translocon, which exhibits large and highly mobile cytoplasmic loops, lead to non-physical smearing in standard LAFM reconstructions. Here, we present a computational framework combining unsupervised deep clustering and LAFM to enhance the lateral resolution of AFM images of flexible membrane proteins. Our neural network algorithm (i) groups AFM images into conformationally homogeneous clusters and (ii) registers images within each cluster. Applying LAFM separately to these clusters minimizes smearing artifacts, yielding high-resolution reconstructions for distinct conformations. We validate this approach using synthetic AFM images generated from all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of SecYEG in a solvated POPE lipid bilayer. This advancement extends LAFM’s utility to encompass conformationally diverse membrane proteins.more » « less
-
Single-molecule force spectroscopy methods, such as AFM and magnetic tweezers, have proved extremely beneficial in elucidating folding pathways for soluble and membrane proteins. To identify factors that determine the force rupture levels in force-induced membrane protein unfolding, we applied our near-atomic-level Upside molecular dynamics package to study the vertical and lateral pulling of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and GlpG, respectively. With our algorithm, we were able to selectively alter the magnitudes of individual interaction terms and identify that, for vertical pulling, hydrogen bond strength had the strongest effect, whereas other non-bonded protein and membrane–protein interactions had only moderate influences, except for the extraction of the last helix where the membrane–protein interactions had a stronger influence. The up–down topology of the transmembrane helices caused helices to be pulled out as pairs. The rate-limiting rupture event often was the loss of H-bonds and the ejection of the first helix, which then propagated tension to the second helix, which rapidly exited the bilayer. The pulling of the charged linkers across the membrane had minimal influence, as did changing the bilayer thickness. For the lateral pulling of GlpG, the rate-limiting rupture corresponded to the separation of the helices within the membrane, with the H-bonds generally being broken only afterward. Beyond providing a detailed picture of the rupture events, our study emphasizes that the pulling mode greatly affects the factors that determine the forces needed to unfold a membrane protein.more » « less
-
Single-molecule force spectroscopy is a powerful tool for studying protein folding. Over the last decade, a key question has emerged: how are changes in intrinsic biomolecular dynamics altered by attachment to μm-scale force probes via flexible linkers? Here, we studied the folding/unfolding of α3D using atomic force microscopy (AFM)–based force spectroscopy. α3D offers an unusual opportunity as a prior single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) study showed α3D’s configurational diffusion constant within the context of Kramers theory varies with pH. The resulting pH dependence provides a test for AFM-based force spectroscopy’s ability to track intrinsic changes in protein folding dynamics. Experimentally, however, α3D is challenging. It unfolds at low force (<15 pN) and exhibits fast-folding kinetics. We therefore used focused ion beam–modified cantilevers that combine exceptional force precision, stability, and temporal resolution to detect state occupancies as brief as 1 ms. Notably, equilibrium and nonequilibrium force spectroscopy data recapitulated the pH dependence measured using smFRET, despite differences in destabilization mechanism. We reconstructed a one-dimensional free-energy landscape from dynamic data via an inverse Weierstrass transform. At both neutral and low pH, the resulting constant-force landscapes showed minimal differences (∼0.2 to 0.5kBT) in transition state height. These landscapes were essentially equal to the predicted entropic barrier and symmetric. In contrast, force-dependent rates showed that the distance to the unfolding transition state increased as pH decreased and thereby contributed to the accelerated kinetics at low pH. More broadly, this precise characterization of a fast-folding, mechanically labile protein enables future AFM-based studies of subtle transitions in mechanoresponsive proteins.more » « less
-
Precisely quantifying the energetics that drive the folding of membrane proteins into a lipid bilayer remains challenging. More than 15 years ago, atomic force microscopy (AFM) emerged as a powerful tool to mechanically extract individual membrane proteins from a lipid bilayer. Concurrently, fluctuation theorems, such as the Jarzynski equality, were applied to deduce equilibrium free energies (ΔG0) from non-equilibrium single-molecule force spectroscopy records. The combination of these two advances in single-molecule studies deduced the free-energy of the model membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin in its native lipid bilayer. To elucidate this free-energy landscape at a higher resolution, we applied two recent developments. First, as an input to the reconstruction, we used force-extension curves acquired with a 100-fold higher time resolution and 10-fold higher force precision than traditional AFM studies of membrane proteins. Next, by using an inverse Weierstrass transform and the Jarzynski equality, we removed the free energy associated with the force probe and determined the molecular free-energy landscape of the molecule under study, bacteriorhodopsin. The resulting landscape yielded an average unfolding free energy per amino acid (aa) of 1.0 ± 0.1 kcal/mol, in agreement with past single-molecule studies. Moreover, on a smaller spatial scale, this high-resolution landscape also agreed with an equilibrium measurement of a particular three-aa transition in bacteriorhodopsin that yielded 2.7 kcal/mol/aa, an unexpectedly high value. Hence, while average unfolding ΔG0 per aa is a useful metric, the derived high-resolution landscape details significant local variation from the mean. More generally, we demonstrated that, as anticipated, the inverse Weierstrass transform is an efficient means to reconstruct free-energy landscapes from AFM data.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ymeth.2024.01.013
