An official website of the United States government
Simulating storage cache hierarchies enables effi- cient exploration of their configuration space, including diverse topologies, parameters and policies, and devices with varied performance characteristics, while avoiding expensive physical experiments. Miss Ratio Curves (MRCs) efficiently characterize the performance of a cache over a range of cache sizes. These useful tools reveal “key points” for cache simulation, such as knees in the curve that immediately follow sharp cliffs. Unfortunately, there are no automated techniques for efficiently finding key points in MRCs, and the cross-application of existing knee-detection algorithms yields inaccurate results. We present a multi-stage framework that identifies key points in any MRC, for both stack-based (e.g., LRU) and more sophisticated eviction algorithms (e.g., ARC). Our approach quickly locates candidates using efficient hash-based sampling, curve simplification, knee detection, and novel post-processing filters. We introduce Z-Method, a new multi-knee detection algorithm that employs statistical outlier detection to choose promising points robustly and efficiently. We evaluate our framework against seven other knee-detection algorithms, using both ARC and LRU MRCs from 106 diverse real-world workloads, and apply it to identify key points in multi-tier MRCs. Compared to naïve approaches, our framework reduces the total number of points needed to accurately identify the best two-tier cache hierarchies by an average factor of approximately 5.5x for ARC and 7.7x for LRU.
more »
« less
Accelerating multi-tier storage cache simulations using knee detection
Storage cache hierarchies include diverse topologies, assorted parameters and policies, and devices with varied performance characteristics. Simulation enables efficient exploration of their configuration space while avoiding expensive physical experiments. Miss Ratio Curves (MRCs) efficiently characterize the performance of a cache over a range of cache sizes, revealing ‘‘key points’’ for cache simulation, such as knees in the curve that immediately follow sharp cliffs. Unfortunately, there are no automated techniques for efficiently finding key points in MRCs, and the cross-application of existing knee-detection algorithms yields inaccurate results. We present a multi-stage framework that identifies key points in any MRC, for both stack- based (e.g., LRU) and more sophisticated eviction algorithms (e.g., ARC). Our approach quickly locates candidates using efficient hash-based sampling, curve simplification, knee detection, and novel post-processing filters. We introduce Z-Method, a new multi-knee detection algorithm that employs statistical outlier detection to choose promising points robustly and efficiently. We evaluated our framework against seven other knee-detection algorithms, identifying key points in multi-tier MRCs with both ARC and LRU policies for 106 diverse real-world workloads. Compared to naïve approaches, our framework reduced the total number of points needed to accurately identify the best two-tier cache hierarchies by an average factor of approximately 5.5x for ARC and 7.7x for LRU. We also show how our framework can be used to seed the initial population for evolutionary algorithms. We ran 32,616 experiments requiring over three million cache simulations, on 151 samples, from three datasets, using a diverse set of population initialization techniques, evolutionary algorithms, knee-detection algorithms, cache replacement algorithms, and stopping criteria. Our results showed an overall acceleration rate of 34% across all configurations.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10525127
- Publisher / Repository:
- Elsevier
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Performance Evaluation
- Volume:
- 164
- Issue:
- C
- ISSN:
- 0166-5316
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 102410
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Multi-tier caching Miss ratio curve Knee detection Cache simulation Evolutionary algorithms
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Modern cache hierarchies are tangled webs of complexity. Multiple tiers of heterogeneous physical and virtual devices, with many configurable parameters, all contend to optimally serve swarms of requests between local and remote applications. The challenge of effectively designing these systems is exacerbated by continuous advances in hardware, firmware, innovation in cache eviction algorithms, and evolving workloads and access patterns. This rapidly expanding configuration space has made it costly and time-consuming to physically experiment with numerous cache configurations for even a single stable workload. Current cache evaluation techniques (e.g., Miss Ratio Curves) are short-sighted: they analyze only a single tier of cache, focus primarily on performance, and fail to examine the critical relationships between metrics like throughput and monetary cost. Publicly available I/O cache simulators are also lacking: they can only simulate a fixed or limited number of cache tiers, are missing key features, or offer limited analyses. It is our position that best practices in cache analysis should include the evaluation of multi-tier configurations, coupled with more comprehensive metrics that reveal critical design trade-offs, especially monetary costs. We are developing an n-level I/O cache simulator that is general enough to model any cache hierarchy, captures many metrics, provides a robust set of analysis features, and is easily extendable to facilitate experimental research or production level provisioning. To demonstrate the value of our proposed metrics and simulator, we extended an existing cache simulator (PyMimircache). We present several interesting and counter-intuitive results in this paper.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Modern cache hierarchies are tangled webs of complexity. Multiple tiers of heterogeneous physical and virtual devices, with many configurable parameters, all contend to optimally serve swarms of requests between local and remote applications. The challenge of effectively designing these systems is exacerbated by continuous advances in hardware, firmware, innovation in cache eviction algorithms, and evolving workloads and access patterns. This rapidly expanding configuration space has made it costly and time-consuming to physically experiment with numerous cache configurations for even a single stable workload. Current cache evaluation techniques (e.g., Miss Ratio Curves) are short-sighted: they analyze only a single tier of cache, focus primarily on performance, and fail to examine the critical relationships between metrics like throughput and monetary cost. Publicly available I/O cache simulators are also lacking: they can only simulate a fixed or limited number of cache tiers, are missing key features, or offer limited analyses. It is our position that best practices in cache analysis should include the evaluation of multi-tier configurations, coupled with more comprehensive metrics that reveal critical design trade-offs, especially monetary costs. We are developing an n-level I/O cache simulator that is general enough to model any cache hierarchy, captures many metrics, provides a robust set of analysis features, and is easily extendable to facilitate experimental research or production level provisioning. To demonstrate the value of our proposed metrics and simulator, we extended an existing cache simulator (PyMimircache). We present several interesting and counter-intuitive results in this paper.more » « less
-
Velegrakis, Y.; Zeinalipour-Yazti, D.; Chrysanthis, P.K.; Guerra, F. (Ed.)Distributed caches are widely deployed to serve social networks and web applications at billion-user scales. This paper presents Cache-on-Track (CoT), a decentralized, elastic, and predictive caching framework for cloud environments. CoT proposes a new cache replacement policy specifically tailored for small front-end caches that serve skewed workloads with small update percentage. Small front-end caches are mainly used to mitigate the load-imbalance across servers in the distributed caching layer. Front-end servers use a heavy hitter tracking algorithm to continuously track the top-k hot keys. CoT dynamically caches the top-C hot keys out of the tracked keys. CoT’s main advantage over other replacement policies is its ability to dynamically adapt its tracker and cache sizes in response to workload distribution changes. Our experiments show that CoT’s replacement policy consistently outperforms the hit-rates of LRU, LFU, and ARC for the same cache size on different skewed workloads. Also, CoT slightly outperforms the hit-rate of LRU-2 when both policies are configured with the same tracking (history) size. CoT achieves server size load-balance with 50% to 93.75% less front-end cache in comparison to other replacement policies. Finally, experiments show that CoT’s resizing algorithm successfully auto-configures the tracker and cache sizes to achieve back-end load-balance in the presence of workload distribution changes.more » « less
-
Identifying knee and elbow points in performance curves is a critical task in various domains, including machine learning and system design. These points represent optimal trade-offs between cost and performance, facilitating efficient decision-making and resource allocation. However, accurately determining the knees and elbows in curves poses a significant challenge. To address this challenge, we introduce Kneeliverse, an open-source library dedicated to knee/elbow point detection. Kneeliverse incorporates a suite of well-established knee-detection algorithms, including Menger, L-method, Kneedle, and DFDT. Additionally, Kneeliverse extends these algorithms to detect multiple knees and elbows in complex curves, employing a recursive approach. Kneeliverse further includes Z-Method, a recently developed algorithm specifically designed for multi-knee detection.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.peva.2024.102410
