An official website of the United States government
Abstract This paper investigates how the core technical processes of the INCOSE model of systems engineering differ from other models of designing used in the domains of mechanical engineering, software engineering and service design. The study is based on fine-grained datasets produced using mappings of the different models onto the function-behaviour-structure (FBS) ontology. By representing every model uniformly, the same statistical analyses can be carried out independently of the domain of the model. Results of correspondence analysis, cumulative occurrence analysis and Markov model analysis show that the INCOSE model differs from the other models in its increased emphasis on requirements and on behaviours derived from structure, in the uniqueness of its verification and validation phases, and in some patterns related to the temporal development and frequency distributions of FBS design issues.
more »
« less
MODELLING THE DESIGN OF MODELS: AN EXAMPLE USING CRISP-DM
Abstract Design is widely understood as a domain-independent notion, comprising any activity concerned with creating artefacts. This paper shows that models can be viewed as artefacts, and that the design of models resembles the design of artefacts in other domains. The function-behaviour-structure (FBS) ontology of design is applied to models, mapping generic characteristics of models derived from literature on modelling onto basic, design-ontological categories. An example of model design, namely the CRISP-DM model for designing data mining models, is analysed and compared with models of designing in other domains (systems engineering, mechanical engineering, software engineering, and service design). The results show that there are fundamental commonalities but also differences, revealing the need for further research in developing a theory of model design.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1762415
- PAR ID:
- 10525632
- Editor(s):
- Editor, A
- Publisher / Repository:
- Design Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the Design Society
- Volume:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 2732-527X
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 2705 to 2714
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- system models, design models
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
ABSTRACT BackgroundEducational technologies typically provide teachers with analytics regarding student proficiency, but few digital tools provide teachers with process‐based information about students' variable problem‐solving strategies as they solve problems. Utilising design thinking and co‐designing with teachers can provide insight to researchers about what educators need to make instructional decisions based on student problem‐solving data. ObjectivesThis case study presents a collaboration where researchers and teachers co‐designed MathFlowLens, a teacher‐facing dashboard that provides analytics and visualisations about students' diverse problem‐solving strategies and behaviours used when solving online math problems in the classroom. MethodsOver several sessions, teachers discussed, mocked up, and were provided with behavioural data and strategy visualisations from students' math problem‐solving that demonstrated the variability of strategic approaches. Throughout this process, the team documented, transcribed, and used these conversations and artefacts to inform the design and development of the teacher tool. Results and ConclusionsTeachers discussed and designed prototypes of data dashboards and provided the research team with ongoing feedback to inform the iteration of the tool development.more » « less
-
PurposeChallenges in teaching the engineering design process (EDP) at the high-school level, such as promoting good documentation practices, are well-documented. While developments in educational artificial intelligence (AI) systems have the potential to assist in addressing these challenges, the open-ended nature of the EDP leads to challenges that often lack the specificity required for actionable AI development. In addition, conventional educational AI systems (e.g. intelligent tutoring systems) primarily target procedural domain tasks with well-defined outcomes and problem-solving strategies, while the EDP involves open-ended problems and multiple correct solutions, making AI intervention timing and appropriateness complex. Design/methodology/approachAuthors conducted a six-week-long Research through Co-Design (RtCD) process (i.e. a co-design process rooted in Research through Design) with two experienced high-school engineering teachers to co-construct actionable insight in the form of AI intervention points (AI-IPs) in engineering education where an AI system can effectively intervene to support them while highlighting their pedagogical practices. FindingsThis paper leveraged the design of task models to iteratively refine our prior understanding of teachers’ experiences with teaching the EDP into three AI-IPs related to documentation, ephemeral interactions between teachers and students and disruptive failures that can serve as a focus for intelligent educational system designs. Originality/valueThis paper discusses the implications of these AI-IPs for designing educational AI systems to support engineering education as well as the importance of leveraging RtCD methodologies to engage teachers in developing intelligent educational systems that align with their needs and afford them control over computational interventions in their classrooms.more » « less
-
Abstract Porous metamaterial units filled with fluid have been used in engineering systems due to their ability to achieve desired properties (e.g., effective thermal conductvity). Designing 3D porous metamaterial units while ensuring complete connectivity of both solid and pore phases presents a significant challenge. In this study, we propose a generative graph neural network-based framework for designing the porous metamaterial units infilled with liquid. Firstly, we propose a graph-based metamaterial unit generation approach to generate porous metamaterial samples with complete connectivity in both solid and pore phases. Secondly, we establish and evaluate three distinct variational graph autoencoder (VGAE)-based generative models to assess their effectiveness in generating an accurate latent space representation of metamaterial structures. By choosing the model with the highest reconstruction accuracy, the property-driven design search is conducted to obtain novel metamaterial unit designs with the targeted properties. A case study on designing liquid-filled metamaterials for thermal conductivity properties is carried out. The effectiveness of the proposed graph neural network-based design approach is evaluated by comparing the performances of the obtained designs with those of existing designs in the training database. Merits and shortcomings of the proposed framework are also discussed.more » « less
-
ABSTRACT Polarization measurements done using Imaging Polarimeters such as the Robotic Polarimeter are very sensitive to the presence of artefacts in images. Artefacts can range from internal reflections in a telescope to satellite trails that could contaminate an area of interest in the image. With the advent of wide-field polarimetry surveys, it is imperative to develop methods that automatically flag artefacts in images. In this paper, we implement a Convolutional Neural Network to identify the most dominant artefacts in the images. We find that our model can successfully classify sources with 98 per cent true positive and 97 per cent true negative rates. Such models, combined with transfer learning, will give us a running start in artefact elimination for near-future surveys like WALOP.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1017/pds.2023.271
