An official website of the United States government
Instabilities of fluid flows often generate turbulence. Using extensive direct numerical simulations, we study two-dimensional turbulence driven by a wavenumber-localised instability superposed on stochastic forcing, in contrast to previous studies of state-independent forcing. As the contribution of the instability forcing, measured by a parameter $$\gamma$$ , increases, the system undergoes two transitions. For $$\gamma$$ below a first threshold, a regular large-scale vortex condensate forms. Above this threshold, shielded vortices (SVs) emerge within the condensate. At a second, larger value of $$\gamma$$ , the condensate breaks down, and a gas of weakly interacting vortices with broken symmetry spontaneously emerges, characterised by preponderance of vortices of one sign only and suppressed inverse energy cascade. The latter transition is shown to depend on the damping mechanism. The number density of SVs in the broken symmetry state slowly increases via a random nucleation process. Bistability is observed between the condensate and mixed SV-condensate states. Our findings provide new evidence for a strong dependence of two-dimensional turbulence phenomenology on the forcing.
more »
« less
From a vortex gas to a vortex crystal in instability-driven two-dimensional turbulence
We study structure formation in two-dimensional turbulence driven by an external force, interpolating between linear instability forcing and random stirring, subject to nonlinear damping. Using extensive direct numerical simulations, we uncover a rich parameter space featuring four distinct branches of stationary solutions: large-scale vortices, hybrid states with embedded shielded vortices (SVs) of either sign, and two states composed of many similar SVs. Of the latter, the first is a dense vortex gas where all SVs have the same sign and diffuse across the domain. The second is a hexagonal vortex crystal forming from this gas when the linear instability is sufficiently weak. These solutions coexist stably over a wide parameter range. The late-time evolution of the system from small-amplitude initial conditions is nearly self-similar, involving three phases: initial inverse cascade, random nucleation of SVs from turbulence and, once a critical number of vortices is reached, a phase of explosive nucleation of SVs, leading to a statistically stationary state. The vortex gas is continued in the forcing parameter, revealing a sharp transition towards the crystal state as the forcing strength decreases. This transition is analysed in terms of the diffusivity of individual vortices using ideas from statistical physics. The crystal can also decay via an inverse cascade resulting from the breakdown of shielding or insufficient nonlinear damping acting on SVs. Our study highlights the importance of the forcing details in two-dimensional turbulence and reveals the presence of non-trivial SV states in this system, specifically the emergence and melting of a vortex crystal.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10527067
- Publisher / Repository:
- Cambridge University Press
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Volume:
- 984
- ISSN:
- 0022-1120
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
At high Reynolds number, the interaction between two vortex tubes leads to intense velocity gradients, which are at the heart of fluid turbulence. This vorticity amplification comes about through two different instability mechanisms of the initial vortex tubes, assumed anti-parallel and with a mirror plane of symmetry. At moderate Reynolds number, the tubes destabilize via a Crow instability, with the nonlinear development leading to strong flattening of the cores into thin sheets. These sheets then break down into filaments which can repeat the process. At higher Reynolds number, the instability proceeds via the elliptical instability, producing vortex tubes that are perpendicular to the original tube directions. In this work, we demonstrate that these same transition between Crow and Elliptical instability occurs at moderate Reynolds number when we vary the initial angle between two straight vortex tubes. We demonstrate that when the angle between the two tubes is close to =2, the interaction between tubes leads to the formation of thin vortex sheets. The subsequent breakdown of these sheets involves a twisting of the paired sheets, followed by the appearance of a localized cloud of small scale vortex structures. At smaller values of the angle between the two tubes, the breakdown mechanism changes to an elliptic cascade-like mechanism. Whereas the interaction of two vortices depends on the initial condition, the rapid formation of fine-scales vortex structures appears to be a robust feature, possibly universal at very high Reynolds numbers.more » « less
-
We introduce a new reduction of the motion of three point vortices in a two-dimensional ideal fluid. This proceeds in two stages: a change of variables to Jacobi coordinates and then a Nambu reduction. The new coordinates demonstrate that the dynamics evolve on a two-dimensional manifold whose topology depends on the sign of a parameter κ2 that arises in the reduction. For κ2>0, the phase space is spherical, while for κ2<0, the dynamics are confined to the upper sheet of a two-sheeted hyperboloid. We contrast this reduction with earlier reduced systems derived by Gröbli, Aref, and others in which the dynamics are determined from the pairwise distances between the vortices. The new coordinate system overcomes two related shortcomings of Gröbli's reduction that have made understanding the dynamics difficult: their lack of a standard phase plane and their singularity at all configurations in which the vortices are collinear. We apply this to two canonical problems. We first discuss the dynamics of three identical vortices and then consider the scattering of a propagating dipole by a stationary vortex. We show that the points dividing direct and exchange scattering solutions correspond to the locations of the invariant manifolds of equilibria of the reduced equations and relate changes in the scattering diagram as the circulation of one vortex is varied to bifurcations of these equilibria.more » « less
-
Vortex crystals are quasiregular arrays of like-signed vortices in solid-body rotation embedded within a uniform background of weaker vorticity. Vortex crystals are observed at the poles of Jupiter and in laboratory experiments with magnetized electron plasmas in axisymmetric geometries. We show that vortex crystals form from the free evolution of randomly excited two-dimensional turbulence on an idealized polar cap. Once formed, the crystals are long lived and survive until the end of the simulations (300 crystal-rotation periods). We identify a fundamental length scale, L γ = ( U / γ ) 1 / 3 , characterizing the size of the crystal in terms of the mean-square velocity U of the fluid and the polar parameter γ = f p / a p 2 , with f p the Coriolis parameter at the pole and a p the polar radius of the planet.more » « less
-
Stationary longitudinal vortical rolls emerge in katabatic and anabatic Prandtl slope flows at shallow slopes as a result of an instability when the imposed surface buoyancy flux relative to the background stratification is sufficiently large. Here, we identify the self-pairing of these longitudinal rolls as a unique flow structure. The topology of the counter-rotating vortex pair bears a striking resemblance to speaker-wires and their interaction with each other is a precursor to further destabilization and breakdown of the flow field into smaller structures. On its own, a speaker-wire vortex retains its unique topology without any vortex reconnection or breakup. For a fixed slope angle $$\alpha =3^{\circ }$$ and at a constant Prandtl number, we analyse the saturated state of speaker-wire vortices and perform a bi-global linear stability analysis based on their stationary state. We establish the existence of both fundamental and subharmonic secondary instabilities depending on the circulation and transverse wavelength of the base state of speaker-wire vortices. The dominance of subharmonic modes relative to the fundamental mode helps to explain the relative stability of a single vortex pair compared to the vortex dynamics in the presence of two or an even number of pairs. These instability modes are essential for the bending and merging of multiple speaker-wire vortices, which break up and lead to more dynamically unstable states, eventually paving the way for transition towards turbulence. This process is demonstrated via three-dimensional flow simulations with which we are able to track the nonlinear temporal evolution of these instabilities.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2024.162
