An official website of the United States government
A well-known exception to rising sea surface temperatures (SST) across the globe is the subpolar North Atlantic, where SST has been declining at a rate of 0.39 (± 0.23) K century−1 during the 1900–2017 period. This cold blob has been hypothesized to result from a slowdown of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). Here, observation-based evidence is used to suggest that local atmospheric forcing can also contribute to the century-long cooling trend. Specifically, a 100-year SST trend simulated by an idealized ocean model forced by historical atmospheric forcing over the cold blob region matches 92% (± 77%) of the observed cooling trend. The data-driven simulations suggest that 54% (± 77%) of the observed cooling trend is the direct result of increased heat loss from the ocean induced by the overlying atmosphere, while the remaining 38% is due to strengthened local convection. An analysis of surface wind eddy kinetic energy suggests that the atmosphere-induced cooling may be linked to a northward migration of the jet stream, which exposes the subpolar North Atlantic to intensified storminess.
more »
« less
Disagreement on the North Atlantic Cold Blob Formation Mechanisms among Climate Models
Abstract Despite global warming, the sea surface temperature (SST) in the subpolar North Atlantic has decreased since the 1900s. This local cooling, known as the North Atlantic cold blob, signifies a unique role of the subpolar North Atlantic in uptaking heat and hence impacts downstream weather and climate. However, a lack of observational records and their constraints on climate models leave the North Atlantic cold blob formation mechanism inconclusive. Using simulations from phase 6 of Coupled Model Intercomparison Project, we assess the primary processes driving the North Atlantic cold blob within individual models and whether the mechanisms are consistent across models. We show that 11 out of 32 models, which we call “Cold Blob” models, simulate the subpolar North Atlantic cooling over 1900–2014. Further analyzing the heat budget of the subpolar North Atlantic SST shows that models have distinct mechanisms of cold blob formation. While 4 of the 11 Cold Blob models indicate decreased oceanic heat transport convergence (OHTC) as the key mechanism, another four models suggest changes in radiative processes making predominant contributions. The contribution of OHTC and radiative processes is comparable in the remaining three models. Such a model disagreement on the mechanism of cold blob formation may be associated with simulated base-state Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC) strength, which explains 39% of the intermodel spread in the contribution of OHTC to the simulated cold blob. Models with a stronger base-state AMOC suggest a greater role of OHTC, whereas those with a weaker base-state AMOC indicate that radiative processes are more responsible. This model discrepancy suggests that the cold blob formation mechanism diagnosed from single model should be interpreted with caution. Significance StatementThe mechanisms driving sea surface temperatures over the subpolar North Atlantic to cool since the 1900s remain uncertain due to the lack of direct observations. Here, we use a temperature change decomposition framework to dissect the historical trend of surface temperature simulated in multiple global climate models. The models diverge on whether the subpolar North Atlantic cooling is induced by reduced ocean heat transport convergence or altered radiative processes. Notably, the importance of ocean heat transport convergence is influenced by the simulated base-state strength of Atlantic meridional overturning circulation and the Irminger Sea’s mixed layer depth. This finding cautions against concluding the cooling mechanism from a single model and highlights a need for ongoing observations to constrain AMOC-related climate projection in the subpolar North Atlantic.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2232582
- PAR ID:
- 10527796
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Meteorological Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Climate
- Volume:
- 37
- Issue:
- 16
- ISSN:
- 0894-8755
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 4061-4078
- Size(s):
- p. 4061-4078
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract The ocean’s role in Atlantic Multidecadal Variability (AMV) remains intensely debated. The core issue is whether AMV, as an internal climate mode, is driven by variations in Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) or by atmospheric processes. Climate models exhibit wide diversity in AMOC-AMV linkages, producing temporal correlations between 0.3-0.8, but no robust explanation for these differences exists. Here, using multi-model intercomparison and perturbation experiments, we propose a dynamical mechanism relating the strength of AMOC-AMV linkage in climate models to stratospheric temperature. This mechanism includes (1) tropospheric midlatitude jet response to stratospheric mean-state temperature anomalies in mid-latitudes and (2) resulting ocean surface density changes that alter the spatial structure of deep-water formation in the subpolar North Atlantic and hence AMOC-AMV connection. Specifically, colder stratospheric temperatures produce tighter linkage through the northward jet shifts and a stronger AMOC, with enhanced deep-water formation in the Labrador and Irminger Seas relative to the Nordic Seas. Models with a warm stratospheric bias tend to produce weaker linkage. Perturbation experiments imposing stratospheric cooling at mid to high latitudes within two independent climate models support these conclusions. Furthermore, we find that models with stronger AMOC-AMV linkage predict a stronger North Atlantic “warming hole” and weaker 21st-century Arctic amplification. We conclude that these results have significant implications for climate prediction and projections.more » « less
-
Abstract Sea surface temperature (SST) has been increasing since industrialization with rising greenhouse gases. However, a warming hole exists in the North Atlantic where SST has cooled by 0.4 K/century during 1900–2017. It has been argued that this cooling is due to a slowdown of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and subpolar North Atlantic SST has thus been utilized to estimate AMOC variability. We assess the robustness of subpolar North Atlantic SST as a proxy for AMOC strength under historical forcing, abrupt quadrupling of CO2, and a medium future emissions pathway, finding that AMOC's fingerprint on SST depends upon forcing scenarios. AMOC is important in warming hole development during significant warming periods, although SST may introduce uncertainties for AMOC reconstruction in stabilized regimes due to diverse forcing mechanisms and decadal variability. Our results caution against using SST alone as a proxy for AMOC variability—both on paleoclimatic and contemporary time scales.more » « less
-
Abstract The Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC) plays an important role in climate, transporting heat and salt to the subpolar North Atlantic. The AMOC’s variability is sensitive to atmospheric forcing, especially the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO). Because AMOC observations are short, climate models are a valuable tool to study the AMOC’s variability. Yet, there are known issues with climate models, like uncertainties and systematic biases. To investigate this, preindustrial control experiments from models participating in the phase 6 of Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) are evaluated. There is a large, but correlated, spread in the models’ subpolar gyre mean surface temperature and salinity. By splitting models into groups of either a warm–salty or cold–fresh subpolar gyre, it is shown that warm–salty models have a lower sea ice cover in the Labrador Sea and, hence, enable a larger heat loss during a positive NAO. Stratification in the Labrador Sea is also weaker in warm–salty models, such that the larger NAO-related heat loss can also affect greater depths. As a result, subsurface density anomalies are much stronger in the warm–salty models than in those that tend to be cold and fresh. As these anomalies propagate southward along the western boundary, they establish a zonal density gradient anomaly that promotes a stronger delayed AMOC response to the NAO in the warm–salty models. These findings demonstrate how model mean state errors are linked across variables and affect variability, emphasizing the need for improvement of the subpolar North Atlantic mean states in models.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Abstract Decadal sea surface temperature (SST) fluctuations in the North Atlantic Ocean influence climate over adjacent land areas and are a major source of skill in climate predictions. However, the mechanisms underlying decadal SST variability remain to be fully understood. This study isolates the mechanisms driving North Atlantic SST variability on decadal time scales using low-frequency component analysis, which identifies the spatial and temporal structure of low-frequency variability. Based on observations, large ensemble historical simulations, and preindustrial control simulations, we identify a decadal mode of atmosphere–ocean variability in the North Atlantic with a dominant time scale of 13–18 years. Large-scale atmospheric circulation anomalies drive SST anomalies both through contemporaneous air–sea heat fluxes and through delayed ocean circulation changes, the latter involving both the meridional overturning circulation and the horizontal gyre circulation. The decadal SST anomalies alter the atmospheric meridional temperature gradient, leading to a reversal of the initial atmospheric circulation anomaly. The time scale of variability is consistent with westward propagation of baroclinic Rossby waves across the subtropical North Atlantic. The temporal development and spatial pattern of observed decadal SST variability are consistent with the recent observed cooling in the subpolar North Atlantic. This suggests that the recent cold anomaly in the subpolar North Atlantic is, in part, a result of decadal SST variability.more » « less
