This study introduces a novel theoretical model for upscaling colloid transport from the grain scale to the Darcy scale under both favorable and unfavorable conditions. The model integrates colloid interception history, where an interception occurs when colloids enter the near-surface zone within 200 nm of a collector, to capture the traditional exponential retention profile, as well as the anomalous, non-exponential behaviors observed under unfavorable conditions. The development of this theoretical model is based on a two-stage framework: first, upscaling from the grain scale to the single-interception scale, followed by upscaling from the single-interception scale to the Darcy scale. The initial stage addresses the distribution of colloids corresponding to a given interception order. The second stage focuses on the distribution of colloids across multiple interception orders. The key innovation of this work is the inclusion of the colloid removal process, where a fraction, denoted by $$\alpha$$, is removed at each encountered interception, rather than with each grain passed, as specified by classical colloid filtration theory. Our model accounts for scenarios under unfavorable conditions wherein if $$\alpha$$ remains constant, the distribution is exponential, albeit shallower relative to favorable conditions. Additionally, the model considers cases where $$\alpha$$ varies with interceptions, leading to multi-exponential and nonmonotonic retention profile shapes. In both scenarios, the proposed theoretical model offers a mathematical representation of colloid retention profiles under favorable and unfavorable conditions, including those exhibiting anomalous shapes.
more »
« less
Effects of Initial Injection Condition on Colloid Retention
Abstract This study investigates the impact of initial injection conditions on colloid transport and retention in porous media. Employing both uniform and flux‐weighted distributions for the initial colloid locations, the research explores diverse flow scenarios, ranging from simple Poiseuille flow to more complex geometries. The results underscore the pivotal role the injection mode plays on the shape of colloid retention profiles (RPs), particularly those that display anomalous non‐exponential decay with distance. Broadly, uniform injection yields multi‐exponential profiles, while flux‐weighted injection can lead to nonmonotonic profiles in certain conditions. The study identifies preferential flow paths as a key factor in producing nonmonotonic RPs. Notably, variations in fluid velocity, colloid size, and ionic strength affect attachment rates near the inlet but do not significantly alter the qualitative transition between multi‐exponential and nonmonotonic profiles. The study emphasizes that the chosen injection mode dictates retention profile shapes, highlighting its crucial role in porous media colloid transport. These insights provide a possible partial explanation of previously observed anomalous transport behaviors, urging consideration of injection conditions in interpretations of experiments, where they can be difficult to accurately control and measure with high precision.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10532102
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Geophysical Union
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Water Resources Research
- Volume:
- 60
- Issue:
- 6
- ISSN:
- 0043-1397
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract This work investigates the role that pore structure plays in colloid retention across scales with a novel methodology based on image analysis. Experiments were designed to quantify–with robust statistics–the contribution from commonly proposed retention sites toward colloid immobilization. Specific retention sites include solid‐water interface, air‐water interface, air‐water‐solid triple point, grain‐to‐grain contacts, and thin films. Variable conditions for pore‐water content, velocity, and chemistry were tested in a model glass bead porous medium with silver microspheres. Concentration signals from effluent breakthrough and spatial profiles of retained particles from micro X‐ray Computed Tomography were used to compute mass balances and enumerate pore‐scale regions of interest in three dimensions. At the Darcy‐scale, retained colloids follow non‐monotonic deposition profiles, which implicates effects from flow‐stagnation zones. The spatial distribution of immobilized colloids along the porous medium depth was analyzed by retention site, revealing depth‐independent partitioning of colloids. At the pore‐scale, dominance and overall saturation of all retention sites considered indicated that the solid‐water interface and wedge‐shaped regions associated with flow‐stagnation (grain‐to‐grain contacts in saturated and air‐water‐solid triple points in unsaturated conditions) are the greatest contributors toward retention under the tested conditions. At the interface‐scale, xDLVO energy profiles were in agreement with pore‐scale observations. Our calculations suggest favorable interactions for colloids and solid‐water interfaces and for weak flocculation (e.g., at flow‐stagnation zones), but unfavorable interactions between colloids and air‐water interfaces. Overall, we demonstrate that pore‐structure plays a critical role in colloid immobilization and that Darcy‐, pore‐ and interface‐scales are consistent when the pore structure is taken into account.more » « less
-
Polymer retention from the flow of a polymer solution through porous media results in substantial decrease of the permeability; however, the underlying physics of this effect is unknown. While the polymer retention leads to a decrease in pore volume, here we show that this cannot cause the full reduction in permeability. Instead, to determine the origin of this anomalous decrease in permeability, we use confocal microscopy to measure the pore-level velocities in an index-matched model porous medium.We show that they exhibit an exponential distribution and, upon polymer retention, this distribution is broadened yet retains the same exponential form. Surprisingly, the velocity distributions are scaled by the inverse square root of the permeabilities. We combine experiment and simulation to show these changes result from diversion of flow in the random porous-medium network rather than reduction in pore volume upon polymer retention.more » « less
-
Emergence of Preferential Flow Paths and Intermittent Dynamics in Emulsion Transport in Porous MediaThis dissertation aims to study the underlying physics of anomalous transport of emulsions in porous media and quantify the role of droplet-pore and droplet-droplet interactions in transport in porous media experimentally. The complexities of this problem arise from the network heterogeneity, correlations between the pores across the medium, interfacial properties of the fluids, and the correlations between the pore scale dynamics and system-level transport. This dissertation presents significant advancements in the study of emulsion dynamics within twodimensional porous media through the development of innovative image analysis and tracking methods. These advancements include precise detection and tracking of deformable objects, which is particularly challenging in experiments involving large datasets with thousands of objects and millions of positional updates. Utilizing cutting-edge microfluidic techniques, we developed an integrated experimental setup combining an on-demand drop maker and advanced imaging methods. By precisely controlling emulsion size, concentration, and injection rates, we uncovered critical insights into pore-level dynamics and bulk transport properties. Through the application of variational mode decomposition (VMD), we effectively distinguished between uniform and irregular droplet formations, enhancing the accuracy of our measurements. Our findings demonstrate that emulsions predominantly flow through higher velocity pores, often becoming trapped in smaller pores, which reduces porosity and creates preferential pathways. Introducing slight polydispersity in emulsion sizes further improved transport efficiency by revealing additional pathways. We also explored the effects of device scaling, dye contrast adjustments, and interfacial tension on emulsion behavior, leading to refined detection and tracking algorithms. These advancements provide a robust framework for future studies and have significant implications for applications in soil remediation, drug delivery, and enhanced oil recovery. Additionally, the creation of high-quality datasets from our experiments lays the groundwork for leveraging machine learning techniques to further understand and predict the complex nature of emulsion transport in porous media. This interdisciplinary approach offers the potential to bridge experimental observations and theoretical models, enhancing our ability to manage and optimize fluid dynamics in various applications. This research represents a substantial contribution to the field of microfluidics and multiphase flow, offering new methodologies and insights that will propel future innovations and applications. The results of this research provide the necessary research platform to advance the research on transport of deformable particles in porous media. In addition to the research questions, these understandings will impact industrial processes such as filtration in food industry, sorting in pharmaceutical, drug delivery in medical, enhanced oil recovery, and soil remediation in environmental industries.more » « less
-
Studying the Brownian motion of fibers and semi-flexible filaments in porous media is the key to understanding the transport and mechanical properties in a variety of systems. The motion of semi-flexible filaments in gel-like porous media including polymer networks and cell cytoskeleton has been studied theoretically and experimentally, whereas the motion of these materials in packed-colloid porous media, advanced foams, and rock-like systems has not been thoroughly studied. Here we use video microscopy to directly visualize the reptation and transport of intrinsically fluorescent, semiflexible, semiconducting single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) in the sub-micron pores of packed colloids as fixed obstacles of packed-colloid porous media. By visualizing the filament motion and Brownian diffusion at different locations in the pore structures, we study how the properties of the environment, like the pore shape and pore structure of the porous media, affect SWCNT mobility. These results show that the porous media structure controls SWCNT reorientation during Brownian diffusion. In packed-colloid pores, SWCNTs diffuse along straight pores and bend across pores; conversely, in gel pores, SWCNTs consistently diffuse into curved pores, displaying a faster parallel motion. In both gel and packed-colloid porous media, SWCNT finite stiffness enhances SWCNT rotational diffusion and prevents jamming, allowing for inter-pore diffusion.more » « less