In this Letter, we report that the fourth-order interatomic force constants (4th-IFCs) are significantly sensitive to the energy surface roughness of exchange-correlation (XC) functionals in density functional theory calculations. This sensitivity, which is insignificant for the second- (2nd-) and third-order (3rd-) IFCs, varies for different functionals in different materials and can cause misprediction of thermal conductivity by several times of magnitude. As a result, when calculating the 4th-IFCs using the finite difference method, the atomic displacement needs to be taken large enough to overcome the energy surface roughness, in order to accurately predict phonon lifetime and thermal conductivity. We demonstrate this phenomenon on a benchmark material (Si), a high-thermal conductivity material (BAs), and a low thermal conductivity material (NaCl). For Si, we find that the LDA, PBE, and PBEsol XC functionals are all smooth to the 2nd- and 3rd-IFCs but all rough to the 4th-IFCs. This roughness can lead to a prediction of nearly one order of magnitude lower thermal conductivity. For BAs, all three functionals are smooth to the 2nd- and 3rd-IFCs, and only the PBEsol XC functional is rough for the 4th-IFCs, which leads to a 40% underestimation of thermal conductivity. For NaCl, all functionals are smooth to the 2nd- and 3rd-IFCs but rough to the 4th-IFCs, leading to a 70% underprediction of thermal conductivity at room temperature. With these observations, we provide general guidance on the calculation of 4th-IFCs for an accurate thermal conductivity prediction.
more »
« less
Hierarchy of Exchange-Correlation Functionals in Computing Lattice Thermal Conductivities of Rocksalt and Zincblende Semiconductors
Lattice thermal conductivity (κL) is a crucial characteristic of crystalline solids with significant implications for thermal management, energy conversion, and thermal barrier coating. The advancement of computational tools based on density functional theory (DFT) has enabled the effective utilization of phonon quasi-particle-based approaches to unravel the underlying physics of various crystalline systems. While the higher order of anharmonicity is commonly used for explaining extraordinary heat transfer behaviors in crystals, the impact of exchange-correlation (XC) functionals in DFT on describing anharmonicity has been largely overlooked. The XC functional is essential for determining the accuracy of DFT in describing interactions among electrons/ions in solids and molecules. However, most XC functionals in solid-state physics are primarily focused on computing the properties that only require small atomic displacements from the equilibrium (within the harmonic approximation), such as harmonic phonons and elastic constants, while anharmonicity involves larger atomic displacements. Therefore, it is more challenging for XC functionals to accurately describe atomic interactions at the anharmonicity level. In this study, we systematically investigate the room-temperature κL of 16 binary compounds with rocksalt and zincblende structures using var- ious XC functionals such as local density approximation (LDA), Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE), revised PBE for solid and surface (PBEsol), optimized B86b functional (optB86b), revised Tao-Perdew-Staroverov-Scuseria (revTPSS), strongly constrained and appropriately normed functional (SCAN), regularized SCAN (rSCAN) and regularized-restored SCAN (r2SCAN) in combination with different perturbation orders, including phonon within harmonic approximation (HA) plus three- phonon scattering (HA+3ph), phonon calculated using self-consistent phonon theory (SCPH) plus three-phonon scattering (SCPH+3ph), and SCPH phonon plus three- and four-phonon scattering (SCPH+3,4ph). Our results show that the XC functional exhibits strong entanglement with perturbation order and the mean relative absolute error (MRAE) of the computed κL is strongly influenced by both the XC functional and perturbation order, leading to error cancellation or amplification. The minimal (maximal) MRAE is achieved with revTPSS (rSCAN) at the HA+3ph level, SCAN (r2SCAN) at the SCPH+3ph level, and PBEsol (rSCAN) at the SCPH+3,4ph level. Among these functionals, PBEsol exhibits the highest accuracy at the highest perturbation order. The SCAN- related functionals demonstrate moderate accuracy but are suffer from numerical instability and high computational costs. Furthermore, the different impacts of quartic anharmonicity on κL in rocksalt and zincblende structures are identified by all XC functionals, attributed to the distinct lattice anharmonicity in these two structures. These findings serve as a valuable reference for selecting appropriate functionals for describing anharmonic phonons and offer insights into high-order force constant calculations that could facilitate the development of more accurate XC functionals for solid materials.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2317008
- PAR ID:
- 10534585
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Physical Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Physical review B
- Volume:
- 110
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 2469-9969
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 035205-1-14
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
We introduce a lattice dynamics package which calculates elastic, thermodynamic and thermal transport properties of crystalline materials from data on their force and potential energy as a function of atomic positions. The data can come from density functional theory (DFT) calculations or classical molecular dynamics runs performed in a supercell. First, the model potential parameters, which are anharmonic force constants are extracted from the latter runs. Then, once the anharmonic model is defined, thermal conductivity and equilibrium properties at finite temperatures can be computed using lattice dynamics, Boltzmann transport theories, and a variational principle respectively. In addition, the software calculates the mechanical properties such as elastic tensor, Gruneisen parameters and the thermal expansion coefficient within the quasi-harmonic approximation (QHA). Phonons, elastic constants and thermodynamic properties results applied to the germanium crystal will be illustrated. Using the force constants as a force field, one may also perform molecular dynamics (MD) simulations in order to investigate the combined effects of anharmonicity and defect scattering beyond perturbation theory.more » « less
-
The anharmonicity of the Ruddlesden Popper metal-halide lattice, and its consequences for their electronic and optical properties, are paramount in their basic semiconductor physics. It is thus critical to identify specific anharmonic optical phonons that govern their photophysics. Here, we address the nature of phonon–phonon scattering probabilities of the resonantly excited optical phonons that dress the electronic transitions in these materials. Based on the temperature dependence of the coherent phonon lifetimes, we isolate the dominant anharmonic phonon and quantify its phonon–phonon interaction strength. Intriguingly, we also observe that the anharmonicity is distinct for different phonons, with a few select modes exhibiting temperature-independent coherence lifetimes, indicating their predominantly harmonic nature. However, the population and dephasing dynamics of excitons are dominated by the anharmonic phonon.more » « less
-
Density functional theory (DFT) calculations are performed to compute the lattice constants, formation energies and vacancy formation energies of transition metal nitrides (TMNs) for transition metals (TM) ranging from 3d–5d series. The results obtained using six different DFT exchange and correlation potentials (LDA, AM05, BLYP, PBE, rPBE, and PBEsol) show that the experimental lattice constants are best predicted by rPBE, while the values obtained using AM05, PBE, rPBE and PBEsol lie between the LDA and BLYP calculated values. A linear relationship is observed between the lattice constants and formation energies with the mean radii of TM and the difference in the electronegativity of TM and N in TMNs, respectively. Our calculated vacancy formation energies, in general, show that N-vacancies are more favorable than TM-vacancies in most TMNs. We observe that N-vacancy formation energies are linearly correlated with the calculated bulk formation energies indicating that TMNs with large negative formation energies are less susceptible to the formation of N-vacancies. Thus, our results from this extensive DFT study not only provide a systematic comparison of various DFT functionals in calculating the properties of TMNs but also serve as reference data for the computation-driven experimental design of materials.more » « less
-
M. Lewin, Rupert L. (Ed.)Abstract: Lieb and Oxford (1981) derived rigorous lower bounds, in the form of local functionals of the electron density, on the indirect part of the Coulomb repulsion energy. The greatest lower bound for a given electron number N depends monotonically upon N, and the N→∞ limit is a bound for all N. These bounds have been shown to apply to the exact density functionals for the exchange- and exchange-correlation energies that must be approximated for an accurate and computationally efficient description of atoms, molecules, and solids. A tight bound on the exact exchange energy has been derived therefrom for two-electron ground states, and is conjectured to apply to all spin-unpolarized electronic ground states. Some of these and other exact constraints have been used to construct two generations of non-empirical density functionals beyond the local density approximation: the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) generalized gradient approximation (GGA), and the strongly constrained and appropriately normed (SCAN) meta-GGA.more » « less
An official website of the United States government

