An official website of the United States government
Coastal dunes are globally recognized as natural features that can be important adaptation approaches for climate change along urban and natural shores. We evaluated the recovery of coastal dunes on an intensively groomed urban beach in southern California over a six-year period after grooming was discontinued. Restoration actions were minimal and included installation of three sides of perimeter sand fencing, cessation of mechanical grooming and driving, and the addition of seeds of native dune plants. To track recovery, we conducted physical and biological surveys of the restoration site and an adjacent control site (groomed beach) using metrics including sand accretion, elevation, foredune and hummock formation, vegetation recovery, and wildlife use. Sediment accretion, elevation, and geomorphic complexity increased over time in the restoration site, largely in association with sand fencing and dune vegetation. A foredune ridge (maximum elevation increase of 0.9 m) and vegetated hummocks developed, along with a general increase in elevation across the restoration site (0.3 m). After six years, an estimated total volume of approximately 1,730 m3of sand had accreted in the restoration site and 540 m3of sand had accreted in the foredune ridge. Over the same period, more than a meter of sediment (vertical elevation change) accumulated along the perimeter sand fencing. Groomed control areas remained flat and uniform. The total cover of vegetation in the restoration site increased over time to a maximum of approximately 7% cover by the sixth year. No vegetation was observed on the groomed control site. Native plant species formed distinct zones across the restoration site beginning by the second year and increasing over time, with dune forming species aggregating closest to the ocean in association with the incipient foredune ridge. Ecological functions observed in the restoration area included presence of dune invertebrates, shorebird roosting, and use by a breeding federally threatened shorebird, the western snowy plover (Charadrius nivosus nivosus). Our findings on geomorphic and ecological responses of a pilot dune restoration on a heavily groomed urban beach provide new insights on the opportunities and expectations for restoring dunes as nature-based solutions for climate adaptation on urban shorelines.
more »
« less
Method for controlling invasive Ammophila arenaria in coastal dunes alters restoration trajectory
Coastal dune restoration often focuses on weed removal to reestablish native vegetation communities. Point Reyes National Seashore (PRNS) initiated large‐scale dune restoration after becoming concerned about loss of dune and rare species habitat from spread of non‐nativeAmmophila arenaria(European beachgrass). Two projects removed beachgrass from 146 ha of heavily invaded dunes using either mechanical removal or herbicide treatment. PRNS conducted pre‐ and post‐restoration vegetation monitoring for 10 years post‐implementation, evaluating success in (1) eradicating beachgrass and (2) reestablishing vegetation communities similar to native dunes in cover, diversity, and species composition. Both methods eradicated beachgrass with annual retreatment. However, they were less successful in rebuilding vegetation communities with comparable native species cover and/or richness. Mechanical removal areas remained largely barren expanses of sand that struggled to support native plants except for a rare perennial, Tidestrom's lupine (Lupinus tidestromii). Tidestrom's lupine and other rare plants now number in the hundreds of thousands. Conversely, herbicide‐treated backdunes were dominated by standing dead beachgrass that resisted decomposition even after 7 years, which hampered native and rare plant establishment. Delayed decomposition was less of an issue in herbicide‐treated foredunes, because sand overwash buried necromass. Restored areas also contended with subsequent invasion by secondary plant invaders. By 2021, only older herbicide‐treated backdunes, and to a lesser extent, mechanical backdunes, showed signs of convergence with native dunes. Successful convergence may be hindered by lingering physical and microbial legacy effects of beachgrass invasion and treatment method. Adaptive restoration may be needed to counter effects and improve project success.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2022055
- PAR ID:
- 10537388
- Publisher / Repository:
- John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Restoration Ecology
- Volume:
- 31
- Issue:
- 7
- ISSN:
- 1061-2971
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The U.S. Pacific Northwest (PWN) coastal dunes are mainly colonized by two non-native beachgrass species (i.e., Ammophila arenaria and A. breviligulata) and a native dune grass (Leymus mollis) that capture sand and build dunes of different morphology. Recently, a hybrid beachgrass was discovered with unknown consequences for dune evolution. We set up a common garden experiment including seven treatments and two control plots to understand the effect of native and non-native plant species on sand accretion and dune morphological evolution. After 1.6 years, sand volume increased the most in the non-native species plots with levels at least twice as high for A. arenaria as compared to the other plots. The hybrid species had moderate sand accretion but a survival rate of 1.4 and 2.1 times higher than its parent species and native species, respectively. These results provide new insights for U.S. PNW coastal dune management.more » « less
-
Restoration of coastal dunes following tropical storm events often requires renourishment of sand substrate dredged from offshore sources, although dredging has well‐described negative ecological impacts and high economic costs. As a potential solution, recycled glass sand (cullet) made from crushed glass bottles has been proposed as a potential replacement for dredging. However, glass sand substrates may have limited ability to provide support to coastal plant communities due to the absence of native soil microbial communities. To explore the potential use of glass sand as a substrate for dune plants in the Northern Gulf of Mexico, we compared the growth of Sea oats (Uniola paniculata), Beach morning‐glory (Ipomoea imperati), and Railroad vine (I. pes‐caprae) in glass sand to growth in live beach sand. To determine if inoculation of glass sand with native soil microbial communities improved survival, growth, and biomass production, we also tested plant growth in glass sand with native microbial amendments. Overall, we found no difference in the survival of the three dune species across three soil treatments and weak differences in plant growth and biomass production across our soil substrates. Our results suggest that glass sand substrates may be a viable option for coastal dune restoration, with limited differences between live beach sand, glass sand, and glass sand inoculated with native soil microbes. Restoration and replenishment of coastal dunes using glass sand as a substrate following tropical storms or sea‐level rise may allow coastal managers to reduce the economic and ecological damage associated with offshore sediment dredging.more » « less
-
Vegetation plays a crucial role in coastal dune building. Species‐specific plant characteristics can modulate sediment transport and dune shape, but this factor is absent in most dune building numerical models. Here, we develop a new approach to implement species‐specific vegetation characteristics into a process‐based aeolian sediment transport model. Using a three‐step approach, we incorporated the morphological differences of three dune grass species dominant in the US Pacific Northwest coast (European beachgrassAmmophila arenaria, American beachgrassA. breviligulata, and American dune grassLeymus mollis) into the model AeoLiS. First, we projected the tiller frontal area of each grass species onto a high resolution grid and then re‐scaled the grid to account for the associated vegetation cover for each species. Next, we calibrated the bed shear stress in the numerical model to replicate the actual sand capture efficiency of each species, as measured in a previously published wind tunnel experiment. Simulations were then performed to model sand bedform development within the grass canopies with the same shoot densities for all species and with more realistic average field densities. The species‐specific model shows a significant improvement over the standard model by (a) accurately simulating the sand capture efficiency from the wind tunnel experiment for the grass species and (b) simulating bedform morphology representative of each species' characteristic bedform morphology using realistic field vegetation density. This novel approach to dune modeling will improve spatial and temporal predictions of dune morphologic development and coastal vulnerability under local vegetation conditions and variations in sand delivery.more » « less
-
Zhou, Jun (Ed.)IntroductionClimate change has increased the need for forest restoration, but low planting success and limited availability of planting materials hamper these efforts. Invasive plants and their soil legacies can further reduce restoration success. Thus, strategies that optimize restoration are crucial. Assisted migration and inoculation with native microbial symbiont communities have great potential to increase restoration success. However, assisted migrants can still show reduced survival compared to local provenances depending on transfer distance. Inoculation with mycorrhizal fungi, effective if well-matched to plants and site conditions, can have neutral to negative results with poor pairings. Few studies have examined the interaction between these two strategies in realistic field environments where native plants experience the combined effects of soil legacies left by invasive plants and the drought conditions that result from a warming, drying climate. MethodsWe planted two ecotypes (local climate and warmer climate) ofPopulus fremontii(Fremont cottonwoods), in soils with and without legacies of invasion byTamarixspp. (tamarisk), and with and without addition of native mycorrhizal fungi and other soil biota from the warmer climate. ResultsFour main results emerged. 1) First year survival in soil legacies left behind after tamarisk invasion and removal was less than one tenth of survival in soil without a tamarisk legacy. 2) Actively restoring soil communities after tamarisk removal tripled first year cottonwood survival for both ecotypes, but only improved survival of the warmer, assisted migrant ecotype trees in year two. 3) Actively restoring soil communities in areas without a tamarisk history reduced first year survival for both ecotypes, but improved survival of the warmer, assisted migrant ecotype trees in year two. 4) By the second year, inoculated assisted migrants survived at five times the rate of inoculated trees from the local ecotype. DiscussionResults emphasize the detrimental effects of soil legacies left after tamarisk invasion and removal, the efficacy of assisted migration and restoring soil communities alongside plants, and the need to thoughtfully optimize pairings between plants, fungi, and site conditions.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13951
