skip to main content


Title: Incoherence and fibering of many free-by-free groups
A group is called free-by-free if it is the semi-direct product of two finitely generated free groups. A group is coherent if any finitely generated subgroup is finitely presented, and incoherent otherwise. In this paper, the authors provide evidence towards the conjecture (due independently to the authors and Dani Wise) that every free-by-free group is incoherent. To do this, they give a homological condition which lets them conclude that the free-by-free group has a finite index subgroup which surjects onto ℤ with finitely generated kernel; standard arguments imply that this kernel cannot be finitely presented. As an important special case, they show that if the free-by-free group is hyperbolic and virtually special, then it is incoherent.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2005353
PAR ID:
10554957
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Publisher / Repository:
Annales de l'Institut Fourier
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Annales de l'Institut Fourier
Volume:
72
Issue:
6
ISSN:
1777-5310
Page Range / eLocation ID:
2385 to 2397
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Let $K$ be a commutative Noetherian ring with identity, let $A$ be a $K$-algebra and let $B$ be a subalgebra of $A$ such that $A/B$ is finitely generated as a $K$-module. The main result of the paper is that $A$ is finitely presented (resp. finitely generated) if and only if $B$ is finitely presented (resp. finitely generated). As corollaries, we obtain: a subring of finite index in a finitely presented ring is finitely presented; a subalgebra of finite co-dimension in a finitely presented algebra over a field is finitely presented (already shown by Voden in 2009). We also discuss the role of the Noetherian assumption on $K$ and show that for finite generation it can be replaced by a weaker condition that the module $A/B$ be finitely presented. Finally, we demonstrate that the results do not readily extend to non-associative algebras, by exhibiting an ideal of co-dimension $1$ of the free Lie algebra of rank 2 which is not finitely generated as a Lie algebra.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract The f -invariant is an isomorphism invariant of free-group measure-preserving actions introduced by Lewis Bowen, who first used it to show that two finite-entropy Bernoulli shifts over a finitely generated free group can be isomorphic only if their base measures have the same Shannon entropy. Bowen also showed that the f -invariant is a variant of sofic entropy; in particular, it is the exponential growth rate of the expected number of good models over a uniform random homomorphism. In this paper we present an analogous formula for the relative f -invariant and use it to prove a formula for the exponential growth rate of the expected number of good models over a random sofic approximation which is a type of stochastic block model. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    A representation of a finitely generated group into the projective general linear group is called convex co‐compact if it has finite kernel and its image acts convex co‐compactly on a properly convex domain in real projective space. We prove that the fundamental group of a closed irreducible orientable 3‐manifold can admit such a representation only when the manifold is geometric (with Euclidean, Hyperbolic or Euclidean Hyperbolic geometry) or when every component in the geometric decomposition is hyperbolic. In each case, we describe the structure of such examples.

     
    more » « less
  4. We bound the size of fibers of word maps in finite and residually finite groups, and derive various applications. Our main result shows that, for any word $1 \ne w \in F_d$ there exists $\e > 0$ such that if $\Gamma$ is a residually finite group with infinitely many non-isomorphic non-abelian upper composition factors, then all fibers of the word map $w:\Gamma^d \rightarrow \Gamma$ have Hausdorff dimension at most $d -\e$. We conclude that profinite groups $G := \hat\Gamma$, $\Gamma$ as above, satisfy no probabilistic identity, and therefore they are \emph{randomly free}, namely, for any $d \ge 1$, the probability that randomly chosen elements $g_1, \ldots , g_d \in G$ freely generate a free subgroup (isomorphic to $F_d$) is $1$. This solves an open problem from \cite{DPSS}. Additional applications and related results are also established. For example, combining our results with recent results of Bors, we conclude that a profinite group in which the set of elements of finite odd order has positive measure has an open prosolvable subgroup. This may be regarded as a probabilistic version of the Feit-Thompson theorem. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Abstract We establish several finiteness properties of groups defined by algebraic difference equations. One of our main results is that a subgroup of the general linear group defined by possibly infinitely many algebraic difference equations in the matrix entries can indeed be defined by finitely many such equations. As an application, we show that the difference ideal of all difference algebraic relations among the solutions of a linear differential equation is finitely generated. 
    more » « less