An official website of the United States government
Abstract As regional grids increase penetrations of variable renewable electricity (VRE) sources, demand-side management (DSM) presents an opportunity to reduce electricity-related emissions by shifting consumption patterns in a way that leverages the large diurnal fluctuations in the emissions intensity of the electricity fleet. Here we explore residential precooling, a type of DSM designed to shift the timing of air-conditioning (AC) loads from high-demand periods to periods earlier in the day, as a strategy to reduce peak period demand, CO2emissions, and residential electricity costs in the grid operated by the California Independent System Operator (CAISO). CAISO provides an interesting case study because it generally has high solar generation during the day that is replaced by fast-ramping natural gas generators when it drops off suddenly in the early evening. Hence, CAISO moves from a fleet of generators that are primarily clean and cheap to a generation fleet that is disproportionately emissions-intensive and expensive over a short period of time, creating an attractive opportunity for precooling. We use EnergyPlus to simulate 480 distinct precooling schedules for four single-family homes across California’s 16 building climate zones. We find that precooling a house during summer months in the climate zone characterizing Downtown Los Angeles can reduce peak period electricity consumption by 1–4 kWh d−1and cooling-related CO2emissions by as much as 0.3 kg CO2 d−1depending on single-family home design. We report results across climate zone and single-family home design and show that precooling can be used to achieve simultaneous reductions in emissions, residential electricity costs, and peak period electricity consumption for a variety of single-family homes and locations across California.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on November 12, 2025
Analyzing how the timing and magnitude of electricity consumption drive variations in household electricity-associated emissions on a high-VRE grid
Abstract Electrifying the residential sector is critical for national climate change adaptation and mitigation strategies, but increases in electricity demand could drive-up emissions from the power sector. However, the emissions associated with electricity consumption can vary depending on the timing of the demand, especially on grids with high penetrations of variable renewable energy. In this study, we analyze smart meter data from 2019 for over 100 000 homes in Southern California and use hourly average emissions factors from the California Independent System Operator, a high-solar grid, to analyze household CO2emissions across spatial, temporal, and demographic variables. We calculate two metrics, the annual household electricity-associated emissions (annual-HEE), and the household average emissions factor (HAEF). These metrics help to identify appropriate strategies to reduce electricity-associated emissions (i.e. reducing demand vs leveraging demand-side flexibility) which requires consideration of the magnitude and timing of demand. We also isolate the portion of emissions caused by AC, a flexible load, to illustrate how a load with significant variation between customers results in a large range of emissions outcomes. We then evaluate the distribution of annual-HEE and HAEF across households and census tracts and use a multi-variable regression analysis to identify the characteristics of users and patterns of consumption that cause disproportionate annual-HEE. We find that in 2019 the top 20% of households, ranked by annual-HEE, were responsible for more emissions than the bottom 60%. We also find the most emissions-intense households have an HAEF that is 1.7 times higher than the least emissions-intense households, and that this spread increases for the AC load. In this analysis, we focus on Southern California, a demographically and climatically diverse region, but as smart meter records become more accessible, the methods and frameworks can be applied to other regions and grids to better understand the emissions associated with residential electricity consumption.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1845931
- PAR ID:
- 10574309
- Publisher / Repository:
- Environmental Research: Energy
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Environmental Research: Energy
- Volume:
- 1
- Issue:
- 4
- ISSN:
- 2753-3751
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 045010
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Extreme heat events are increasing in frequency and intensity, challenging electricity infrastructure due to growing cooling demand and posing public health risks to urbanites. In order to minimize risks from increasing extreme heat, it is critical to (a) project increases in electricity use with urban warming, and (b) identify neighborhoods that are most vulnerable due in part to a lack of air conditioning (AC) and inability to afford increased energy. Here, we utilize smart meter data from 180 476 households in Southern California to quantify increases in residential electricity use per degree warming for each census tract. We also compute AC penetration rates, finding that air conditioners are less prevalent in poorer census tracts. Utilizing climate change projections for end of century, we show that 55% and 30% of the census tracts identified as most vulnerable are expected to experience more than 16 and 32 extreme heat days per year, respectively.more » « less
-
Abstract High fractions of variable renewable electricity generation have challenged grid management within the balancing authority overseen by the California’s Independent System Operator (CAISO). In the early evening, solar resources tend to diminish as the system approaches peak demand, putting pressure on fast-responding, emissions-intensive natural gas generators. While residential precooling, a strategy intended to shift the timing of air-conditioning usage from peak-demand periods to cheaper off-peak periods, has been touted in the literature as being effective for reducing peak electricity usage and costs, we explore its impact on CO2emissions in regional grids like CAISO that have large disparities in their daytime versus nighttime emissions intensities. Here we use EnergyPlus to simulate precooling in a typical U.S. single-family home in California climate zone 9 to quantify the impact of precooling on peak electricity usage, CO2emissions, and residential utility costs. We find that replacing a constant-setpoint cooling schedule with a precooling schedule can reduce peak period electricity consumption by 57% and residential electricity costs by nearly 13%, while also reducing CO2emissions by 3.5%. These results suggest the traditional benefits of precooling can be achieved with an additional benefit of reducing CO2emissions in grids with high daytime renewable energy penetrations.more » « less
-
Abstract The California Independent System Operator (CAISO) utilizes a system-wide, voluntary demand response (DR) tool, called the Flex Alert program, designed to reduce energy usage during peak hours, particularly on hot summer afternoons when surges in electricity demand threaten to exceed available generation resources. However, the few analyses on the efficacy of CAISO Flex Alerts have produced inconsistent results and do not investigate how participation varies across sectors, regions, population demographics, or time. Evaluating the efficacy of DR tools is difficult as there is no ground truth in terms of what demand would have been in the absence of the DR event. Thus, we first define two metrics that to evaluate how responsive customers were to Flex Alerts, including theFlex Period Response, which estimates how much demand was shifted away from the Flex Alert period, and theRamping Response, which estimates changes in demand during the first hour of the Flex Alert period. We then analyze the hourly load response of the residential sector, based on ∼200 000 unique homes, on 17 Flex Alert days during the period spanning 2015–2020 across the Southern California Edison (SCE) utility’s territory and compare it to total SCE load. We find that the Flex Period Response varied across Flex Alert days for both the residential (−18% to +3%) and total SCE load (−7% to +4%) and is more dependent on but less correlated with temperature for the residential load than total SCE load. We also find that responsiveness varied across subpopulations (e.g. high-income, high-demand customers are more responsive) and census tracts, implying that some households have more load flexibility during Flex Alerts than others. The variability in customer engagement suggests that customer participation in this type of program is not reliable, particularly on extreme heat days, highlighting a shortcoming in unincentivized, voluntary DR programs.more » « less
-
Abstract Efficient energy consumption is crucial for achieving sustainable energy goals in the era of climate change and grid modernization. Thus, it is vital to understand how energy is consumed at finer resolutions such as household in order to plan demand-response events or analyze impacts of weather, electricity prices, electric vehicles, solar, and occupancy schedules on energy consumption. However, availability and access to detailed energy-use data, which would enable detailed studies, has been rare. In this paper, we release a unique, large-scale, digital-twin of residential energy-use dataset for the residential sector across the contiguous United States covering millions of households. The data comprise of hourly energy use profiles for synthetic households, disaggregated into Thermostatically Controlled Loads (TCL) and appliance use. The underlying framework is constructed using a bottom-up approach. Diverse open-source surveys and first principles models are used for end-use modeling. Extensive validation of the synthetic dataset has been conducted through comparisons with reported energy-use data. We present a detailed, open, high resolution, residential energy-use dataset for the United States.more » « less
