skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


This content will become publicly available on March 13, 2026

Title: Temporal and spatial equivalence in demographic responses of emperor penguins ( Aptenodytes forsteri ) to environmental change
Abstract Population ecology and biogeography applications often necessitate the transfer of models across spatial and/or temporal dimensions to make predictions outside the bounds of the data used for model fitting. However, ecological data are often spatiotemporally unbalanced such that the spatial or the temporal dimension tends to contain more data than the other. This unbalance frequently leads model transfers to become substitutions, which are predictions to a different dimension than the predictive model was built on. Despite the prevalence of substitutions in ecology, studies validating their performance and their underlying assumptions are scarce.Here, we present a case study demonstrating both space‐for‐time and time‐for‐space substitutions (TFSS) using emperor penguins (Aptenodytes forsteri) as the focal species. Using an abundance‐based species distribution model (aSDM) of adult emperor penguins in attendance during spring across 50 colonies, we predict long‐term annual fluctuations in fledgling abundance and breeding success at a single colony, Pointe Géologie. Subsequently, we construct statistical models from time series of extended counts on Pointe Géologie to predict average colony abundance distribution across 50 colonies.Our analysis reveals that the distance to nearest open water (NOW) exhibits the strongest association with both temporal and spatial data. Space‐for‐time substitution performance of the aSDM, as measured by the Pearson correlation coefficient, was 0.63 and 0.56 when predicting breeding success and fledgling abundance time series, respectively. Linear regression of fledgling abundance on NOW yields similar TFSS performance when predicting the abundance distribution of emperor penguin colonies with a correlation coefficient of 0.58.We posit that such space–time equivalence arises because: (1) emperor penguin colonies conform to their existing fundamental niche; (2) there is not yet any environmental novelty when comparing the spatial versus temporal variation of distance to the nearest open water; and (3) models of more specific components of life histories, such as fledgling abundance, rather than total population abundance, are more transferable. Identifying these conditions empirically can enhance the qualitative validation of substitutions in cases where direct validation data are lacking.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2037561
PAR ID:
10577313
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley-Blackwell
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Animal Ecology
Volume:
94
Issue:
5
ISSN:
0021-8790
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 932-942
Size(s):
p. 932-942
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Adélie penguins (Pygoscelis adeliae) are bioindicators for the rapidly changing Antarctic environment, making understanding their population dynamics and behavior of high research priority. However, collecting detailed population data throughout the breeding season on many colonies is difficult due to Antarctica’s harsh conditions and remote location. The colonial breeding ecology of Adélie penguins has led to the evolution of a highly vocal species with individualized calls, making them well-suited for passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) with autonomous recording. PAM units can potentially provide an easily deployable and scalable way to collect fine-scale data on population estimates and breeding phenology. Here I present a framework for using acoustic indices to monitor phenology of dense penguin colonies even under high wind conditions. I evaluate the relationship between acoustic indices such as RMS amplitude and penguin colony size between distinct breeding stages (incubation, guard, crèche, and fledge) on Torgersen and Humble Islands in the West Antarctic Peninsula with an automated pipeline implemented in R. Using PAM to interpret penguin vocalizations for population size and breeding phenology estimates could lead to the development of a real-time remote monitoring system over a large spatial footprint, revealing Adélie penguin responses to climate change. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract ContextThe interaction between topography and wind influences snow cover patterns, which can determine the distribution of species reliant on snow-free habitats. Past studies suggest snow accumulation creates suboptimal breeding habitats for Adélie penguins, leading to colony extinctions. However, evidence linking snow cover to landscape features is lacking. ObjectivesWe aimed to model landscape-driven snow cover patterns, identify long-term weather changes, and determine the impact of geomorphology and snow conditions on penguin colony persistence. MethodsWe combined remotely sensed imagery, digital surface models, and > 30 years of weather data with penguin population monitoring from 1975 to 2022 near Palmer Station, west Antarctic Peninsula. Using a multi-model approach, we identified landscape factors driving snow distribution on two islands. Historic and current penguin sub-colony perimeters were used to understand habitat selection, optimal habitat features, and factors associated with extinctions. ResultsDecadal and long-term trends in wind and snow conditions were detected. Snow accumulated on lower elevations and south-facing slopes driven by the north-northeasterly winds while Adélie penguins occupied higher elevations and more north-facing slopes. On Torgersen Island, sub-colonies on south aspects have gone extinct, and only five of the 23 historic sub-colonies remain active, containing 7% of the 1975 population. Adélie penguins will likely be extinct on this island in < 25 years. ConclusionsAdélie penguin populations are in decline throughout the west Antarctic Peninsula with multiple climate and human impacts likely driving Adélie penguins towards extinction in this region. We demonstrate precipitation has detrimental effects on penguins, an often overlooked yet crucial factor for bird studies. 
    more » « less
  3. Unlike in many polar regions, the spatial extent and duration of the sea ice season have increased in the Ross Sea sector of the Southern Ocean during the satellite era. Simultaneously, populations of Adélie penguins, a sea ice obligate, have been stable or increasing in the region. Relationships between Adélie penguin population growth and sea ice concentration (SIC) are complex, with sea ice driving different, sometimes contrasting, demographic patterns. Adélie penguins undergo a complete molt annually, replacing all their feathers while fasting shortly after the breeding season. Unlike most penguin species, a majority of Adélies are thought to molt on sea ice, away from the breeding colonies, which makes this period particularly difficult to study. Here, we evaluate the hypothesis that persistent areas of high SIC provide an important molting habitat for Adélie penguins. We analyzed data from geolocating dive recorders deployed year-round on 195 adult penguins at two colonies in the Ross Sea from 2017 to 2019. We identified molt by detecting extended gaps in postbreeding diving activity and used associated locations to define two key molting areas. Remotely sensed data indicated that SIC during molt was anomalously low during the study and has declined in the primary molt area since 1980. Further, annual return rates of penguins to breeding colonies were positively correlated with SIC in the molt areas over 20 y. Together these results suggest that sea ice conditions during Adélie penguin molt may represent a previously underappreciated annual bottleneck for adult survival. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Emperor penguins (Aptenodytes forsteri) are under increasing environmental pressure. Monitoring colony size and population trends of this Antarctic seabird relies primarily on satellite imagery recorded near the end of the breeding season, when light conditions levels are sufficient to capture images, but colony occupancy is highly variable. To correct population estimates for this variability, we develop a phenological model that can predict the number of breeding pairs and fledging chicks, as well as key phenological events such as arrival, hatching and foraging times, from as few as six data points from a single season. The ability to extrapolate occupancy from sparse data makes the model particularly useful for monitoring remotely sensed animal colonies where ground-based population estimates are rare or unavailable. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract According to the ‘selfish herd’ hypothesis, most seabird species breed colonially so that individuals can decrease their risk of predation by forming compact groups. However, costs and benefits associated with colonial breeding may not be evenly distributed among individuals within a colony. At Adélie penguin colonies, individuals nesting on the periphery of subcolonies (distinct groups of nests) may experience higher rates of nest predation by south polar skuas, and thus the optimal aggregation pattern for Adélie penguins may be within groups that minimize the proportion of edge nests. Nevertheless, some penguins choose to nest solitarily, at significant distances from conspecifics. We tracked 50 of these “solitary-nesting” Adélie penguins at Cape Crozier, a large colony on Ross Island, during the 2021 nesting season and compared their breeding success to individuals nesting within subcolony boundaries. We found that both solitary and subcolony nests successfully raised chicks large enough to join crèches and left unattended by adults. However, chicks from solitary nests exhibited a rate of mortality more than six times higher during the transition from nest brooding/guarding to crèche stage. In the 2022 nesting season, we found that solitary nests which had previously hosted actively breeding penguins were more likely to be re-occupied. Solitary nesting therefore appears to be a less-successful alternative to breeding within subcolonies, but enough individuals could be successful with this approach to maintain the apparently disadvantageous behavior and effectively pioneer previously unused locations, possibly including eventual new colony locations. 
    more » « less