An official website of the United States government
Abstract Permafrost thaw is hypothesized to increase riverbank erosion rates, which threatens Arctic communities and infrastructure. However, existing erosion models have not been tested against controlled flume experiments with open‐channel flow past an erodible, hydraulically rough permafrost bank. We conducted temperature‐controlled flume experiments where turbulent water eroded laterally into riverbanks consisting of sand and pore ice. The experiments were designed to produce ablation‐limited erosion such that any thawed sediment was quickly transported away from the bank. Bank erosion rates increased linearly with water temperature, decreased with pore ice content, and were insensitive to changes in bank temperature, consistent with theory. However, erosion rates were approximately a factor of three greater than expected. The heightened erosion rates were due to a greater coefficient of heat transfer from the turbulent water to the permafrost bank caused by bank grain roughness. A revised ablation‐limited bank erosion model with a heat transfer coefficient that includes bank roughness matched our experimental results well. Results indicate that bank erosion along Arctic rivers can accelerate under scenarios of warming river water temperatures for cases where the cadence of bank erosion is set by pore‐ice melting rather than sediment entrainment.
more »
« less
Supporting data for "Frozen flume experiments indicate rapid permafrost riverbank erosion depends on bank roughness"
This dataset contains supporting files detailing five frozen flume experiments conducted at the Caltech Earth Surface Dynamics Laboratory to investigate rates of ablation-limited permafrost riverbank erosion under controlled conditions. Water flowed past a bank of saturated, frozen sand and ice and gradually eroded the bank by thawing pore ice and immediately entraining sand and washing it downstream. Experiments were scaled for flow hydraulics and heat transfer allowing comparisons between our results and natural permafrost riverbanks. For each experiment, we measured the initial and final sand bank topography using a Keyence laser scanner, water surface slope at 3-min intervals throughout the experiment using a Massa sonar scanner, bank erosion using 10-sec overhead timelapse imagery taken by an overhead camera, water and bank temperature using thermistors frozen into the sand bank and sampling at 2 Hz, and water discharge using an in-line flow meter. We include calibration data for the carriage (engineered by the Saint Anthony Falls Laboratory) used to make sonar and laser topography measurements. We also include calibration data for temperature sensors, water discharge measurements, and images of a regular grid placed in the flume to align overhead camera images with the carriage datum. Grain size analysis for the channel bed (gravel) was produced using a pebble count and bank sand was measured using a Camsizer X2. In addition to the five frozen experiments, we include sonar scans of water surface slope and Keyence scans of bed and bank topography for calibration experiments ran with an immobile gravel bank and bed.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2031532
- PAR ID:
- 10578745
- Publisher / Repository:
- Environmental System Science Data Infrastructure for a Virtual Ecosystem; Incorporating the Hydrological Controls on Carbon Cycling in Floodplain Ecosystems into Earth System Models (ESMs)
- Date Published:
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- 54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES EARTH SCIENCE > CRYOSPHERE > FROZEN GROUND EARTH SCIENCE > LAND SURFACE > EROSION/SEDIMENTATION EARTH SCIENCE > TERRESTRIAL HYDROSPHERE > SURFACE WATER EARTH SCIENCE > LAND SURFACE > SOILS > SOIL MOISTURE/WATER CONTENT EARTH SCIENCE > LAND SURFACE > TOPOGRAPHY > TERRAIN ELEVATION EARTH SCIENCE > TERRESTRIAL HYDROSPHERE > SURFACE WATER > SURFACE WATER PROCESSES/MEASUREMENTS > DISCHARGE/FLOW > AVERAGE FLOW EARTH SCIENCE > TERRESTRIAL HYDROSPHERE > WATER QUALITY/WATER CHEMISTRY > WATER CHARACTERISTICS > WATER TEMPERATURE EARTH SCIENCE > LAND SURFACE > FROZEN GROUND > SOIL TEMPERATURE
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Location:
- Caltech Earth Surface Dynamics Laboratory
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
A broadly accepted paradigm is that vegetation reduces coastal dune erosion. However, we show that during an extreme storm event, vegetation surprisingly accelerates erosion. In 104-m-long beach-dune profile experiments conducted within a flume, we discovered that while vegetation initially creates a physical barrier to wave energy, it also (i) decreases wave run-up, which creates discontinuities in erosion and accretion patterns across the dune slope, (ii) increases water penetration into the sediment bed, which induces its fluidization and destabilization, and (iii) reflects wave energy, accelerating scarp formation. Once a discontinuous scarp forms, the erosion accelerates further. These findings fundamentally alter the current understanding of how natural and vegetated features may provide protection during extreme events.more » « less
-
Abstract We calibrated an acoustic pipe microphone system to monitor bedload flux in a sandy, gravel‐bed ephemeral channel. Ours is a first attempt to test the limit of an acoustic surrogate bedload system in a channel with a high content of sand. Calibrations varied in quality; significant data subsetting was required to achieve R2values >0.75. Several data quality issues had to be addressed: (1) apparent pulses, which occur when a sensor records an impulse from sediment impacting the surrounding substrate rather than directly impacting the sensor, were frequent, especially at higher signal amplifications. (2) The impact sensors were frequently covered by gravel sheets. This prompted the development of a cover detection protocol that rejected part of the impact sensor record when at least one sensor was partially or fully covered. (3) Because of the lack of sensor sensitivity to impacts of sand‐sized particles, which was anticipated, and the considerable sand component of bedload in this channel, a grain size‐limited bedload flux was estimated. This was accomplished by sampling the bedload captured by slot samplers and evaluating the variation of grain size with increasing flow strength. This considerably improved the results when compared to attempts at estimating the flux of the entire distribution of grain sizes. This calibration is a successful first attempt, though the impact sensors required several site‐specific calibration steps. A universal set of equations using impact sensors to estimate bedload transport of fine‐gravel with a large content of sand remains elusive. Notwithstanding, our study demonstrates the utility of impact sensor data, producing relatively low root mean square errors that are independent of measurements of flow strength (i.e. discharge). These tools will be particularly useful in settings that would benefit from new methodologies for estimating bedload transport in sand‐rich gravel‐bed rivers, such as the American desert Southwest.more » « less
-
Abstract Floodplains provide important ecological, hydrological, and geomorphic functions within river corridors. During overbank flows, complex hydrodynamic conditions occur as water exits and re‐enters the channel and interacts with hydraulically rough floodplain vegetation. However, the extent to which floodplain vegetation influences channel‐altering hydrodynamic forces and thus bedform topography and sediment transport is poorly understood. We address this knowledge gap and present the results of flume experiments where we measured bedform topography under varied floodplain vegetation conditions at two overbank flow relative depths. The experiments were conducted in a 1‐m wide meandering compound channel inset in a 15.4 long, 4.9‐m wide basin. The channel bed was a mobile sand‐and‐gravel mixture with a median sediment size of 3.3 mm, and sediment transport occurred only within the channel. We tested bare and vegetated floodplain conditions with 2.7‐cm diameter rigid emergent vegetation elements at spacings of 3.0 and 12.1 units m−2. We performed a moving‐window analysis of topographic surface metrics including skewness, coefficient of variation, and standard deviation, as well as topographic patch analysis of area and contagion to measure changes in bedform heterogeneity as flow depth and vegetation density were varied. Our results show that both greater density vegetation and larger flows can increase bedform topographic heterogeneity. These findings suggest that floodplain vegetation and natural hydrologic regimes that include overbank flows can enhance stream habitat complexity. Designing for the effects of established vegetation conditions and prioritizing floodplain vegetation planting may be useful for river managers striving to achieve successful biomic river restoration.more » « less
-
In June of 2022 an extreme atmospheric river flood caused extensive bank erosion and infrastructure damage in northern Yellowstone National Park (YNP). On the lower Lamar River, peak discharge was 170% of the next highest peak of 1996 (gaged since 1923) and resulted in widespread overbank gravel deposition and channel change. In June 1918, however, flooding on the Lamar system produced similar peak flows, as shown by indirect discharge estimates and tree-ring dating. In 2022, peak discharges and flood effects varied considerably in northern YNP. The upper Lamar River had a peak discharge significantly less than 1918, likely the result of less precipitation and snowmelt in the relatively low elevations of the upper Lamar drainage in the Absaroka Range. The high flows experienced by the lower Lamar River, however, were the result of extreme discharges in tributaries that drain the Beartooth Range where Soda Butte Creek and Pebble Creek had discharges similar or greater than 1918 and discharge on Slough Creek produced extensive mid channel bar deposition greater than 2 m. In western YNP, the Gallatin River experienced little bank erosion or bed material transport, although some reaches showed minor channel scour and gravel bar deposition on glacial outwash substrates. In central YNP, the Gardiner River experienced minimal bank erosion on upper reaches, however, there was extensive bank erosion, landslides, and sediment deposition in the Gardner River Canyon where the steep, confined channel focused stream power along the valley margins. Flood magnitudes differed markedly between the Gallatin and Beartooth drainages despite similar amounts of rainfall and snowmelt. The Gallatin River drainage, dominated by highly fractured and macroporous limestone and extensive thick colluvium with gentler range flanks allows for greater infiltration and reduced peak flows. In contrast, basins in the Beartooth Range drain steeper slopes of low-permeability laharic volcaniclastic rocks, with more exposed bedrock and relief up to 900 m, which promotes rapid runoff and extreme flooding. The frequency and magnitude of rain-on-snow floods is likely increasing in YNP because of anthropogenic warming, as the high-elevation snowpack becomes more susceptible to rapid melting and late spring precipitation shifts from snow to rain.more » « less
