skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: The Born Versus Heisenberg Quantum-Vacuum Controversy and Beyond
Photon-photon collisions, as one of the fundamental processes in quantum physics, have attracted a lot of attention. However, most effort has been focused on photons energetic enough to create particle-antiparticle pairs. The low energy limit—e.g., optical photons—has attracted less attention because of their extremely low collision cross section. By optical photons we mean UV, visible and infrared, although the cutting edge of extreme lasers is in the near infrared. The Schwinger critical field for pair generation seems not possible, at least directly, with the current laser technology. This often is considered as a problem, but we view this as an asset; the near impossibility of pair production via photon-photon scattering in the infrared is a perfect scenario to study virtual pairs that characterize Dirac’s quantum vacuum. Moreover, it is remarkable that this scenario of photon-photon collisions was already studied in the 1930s by two of the fathers of Quantum Mechanics, among others, at the dawn of this theory. In their respective papers, however, Born and Heisenberg arrived to different conclusions regarding the birefringence of vacuum. This controversy is still an open question that will be solved soon, we hope, with upcoming experiments. Here, we discuss a possible photon-photon collision experiment with extreme lasers, and will show that it can provide measurable effects, allowing fundamental information about the essence of Quantum Electrodynamics and its Lagrangian to be extracted. A possible experimental scenario with two ultra-intense pulses for detecting photon-photon scattering is analyzed. This would need a high-precision measurement, with control of temporal and spatial jitter, and noise. We conclude that such an experiment is barely feasible at $$10^{23}$$ W/cm$^2$ (today’s intensity record) and very promising at 1$$0^{24}$$ W/cm$^2$.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2308905
PAR ID:
10598680
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Editor(s):
Yamanouchi, K; DiMauro, L F; Hill_III, W T
Publisher / Repository:
Springer Nature Switzerland
Date Published:
Edition / Version:
1
Volume:
151
ISBN:
978-3-031-55463-6
Page Range / eLocation ID:
161 to 195
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, New Journal of Physics)
    Abstract In this paper we will show that photon–photon collision experiments using extreme lasers can provide measurable effects giving fundamental information about the essence of QED, its Lagrangian. A possible scenario with two counterpropagating ultra-intense lasers for an experiment to detect scattering between optical photons is analyzed. We discuss the importance of the pulse widths and waists, the best scenario for overlapping the beams and signal detection, as well as ways to distinguish the signal from the noise. This would need a high-precision measurement, with control of temporal jitter and noise. We conclude that such experiment is barely feasible at 1023 W cm−2and very promising at 1024 W cm−2. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; ; (, APL Photonics)
    We report photon pairs and heralded single photons generated at 1310 nm wavelengths using silicon photonics technology, demonstrating that comparable performance could be achieved when a silicon microring resonator was pumped either by a desktop laser instrument or by an electrically injected, room-temperature hybrid silicon laser. Measurements showed that 130 kilo-coincidence-counts per second pair rates could be generated, with coincidences-to-accidentals ratio approximately 100 at about 0.34 mW optical pump power and anti-bunching upon heralding with second-order intensity correlation g(2)(0) = 0.06 at about 0.9 mW optical pump power. These results suggest that hybrid silicon lasers, which are ultra-compact and wafer-scale manufacturable, could be used in place of packaged, stand-alone lasers for generating photon pairs at data communication wavelengths and enable large-scale, cost-effective manufacturing of integrated sources for quantum communications and computing. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; (, Physical Review D)
    Minkowski vacuum is empty from the perspective of Unruh-Minkowski photons, however, in the Rindler picture, it is filled with entangled pairs of Rindler photons. A ground-state atom uniformly accelerated through Minkowski vacuum can become excited by absorbing a Rindler photon (Unruh effect) or, in the alternative description, by emitting an Unruh-Minkowski photon (Unruh-Wald effect). We find an exact solution for the quantum evolution of a long chain of harmonic oscillators accelerated through Minkowski vacuum and for two chains accelerated in the opposite directions. We show how entanglement of Rindler photons present in Minkowski vacuum is transferred to the oscillators moving in causally disconnected regions. We also show that in the Unruh-Minkowski photon picture the process can be interpreted as if initial correlations between collective oscillator modes are transferred to the generated Unruh-Minkowski photons. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; et al (, Physics of Plasmas)
    Stimulated photon–photon scattering is a predicted consequence of quantum electrodynamics that has yet to be measured directly. Measuring the cross section for stimulated photon–photon scattering is the aim of a flagship experiment for NSF OPAL, a proposed laser user facility with two, 25-PW beamlines. We present optimized experimental designs for achieving this challenging and canonical measurement. A family of experimental geometries is identified that satisfies the momentum- and energy-matching conditions for two selected laser frequency options. Numerical models predict a maximum signal exceeding 1000 scattered photons per shot at the experimental conditions envisaged at NSF OPAL. Experimental requirements on collision geometry, polarization, cotiming and copointing, background suppression, and diagnostic technologies are investigated numerically. These results confirm that a beam cotiming shorter than the pulse duration and control of the copointing on a scale smaller than the shortest laser wavelength are needed to robustly scatter photons on a per-shot basis. Finally, we assess the bounds that a successful execution of this experiment may place on the mass scale of Born–Infeld nonlinear electrodynamics beyond the standard model of physics. 
    more » « less
  5. (, Optics Express)
    If a boundary between two static media is moving with a constant superluminal velocity, or there is a sudden change of the refractive index with time, this yields generation of entangled pairs of photons out of vacuum propagating in the opposite directions. Here we show that during this process, entanglement of Minkowski vacuum is transferred to the entanglement of the generated photon pairs. If initially an electromagnetic pulse is present in the medium the photon generation is stimulated into the pulse mode, and since photons are created as entangled pairs the counter-propagating photon partners produce a pulse moving in the opposite direction, which is known as time reflection. Thus, time reflection occurs due to stimulated generation of the entangled photon pairs out of entangled vacuum and no photons in the original pulse are in fact being reflected. This is different from the mechanism of light reflection from spatial inhomogeneities for which no photons are generated. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email