skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


This content will become publicly available on May 27, 2026

Title: A Study Demonstrating That Using Gravitational Offset to Prepare Extraterrestrial Mobility Missions Is Misleading
ABSTRACT Recently, there has been a surge of international interest in extraterrestrial exploration targeting the Moon, Mars, the moons of Mars, and various asteroids. This contribution discusses how current state‐of‐the‐art Earth‐based testing for designing rovers and landers for these missions currently leads to overly optimistic conclusions about the behavior of these devices upon deployment on the targeted celestial bodies. The key misconception is that gravitational offset is necessary during theterramechanicstesting of rover and lander prototypes on Earth. The body of evidence supporting our argument is tied to a small number of studies conducted during parabolic flights and insights derived from newly revised scaling laws. We argue that what has prevented the community from fully diagnosing the problem at hand is the absence of effective physics‐based models capable of simulating terramechanics under low‐gravity conditions. We developed such a physics‐based simulator and utilized it to gauge the mobility of early prototypes of the Volatiles Investigating Polar Exploration Rover. This contribution discusses the results generated by this simulator, how they correlate with physical test results from the NASA‐Glenn SLOPE lab, and the fallacy of the gravitational offset in rover and lander testing. The simulator, which is open‐source and publicly available, also supports studies for in situ resource utilization activities, for example, digging, bulldozing, and berming, in low‐gravity environments.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2209791
PAR ID:
10611079
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ;
Corporate Creator(s):
Editor(s):
NA
Publisher / Repository:
Springer
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Field Robotics
ISSN:
1556-4959
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Life on Earth evolved under a specific set of environmental conditions, including consistent gravitational and magnetic fields. However, planned human missions to Mars in the coming decades will expose terrestrial organisms to radically different conditions, with Martian gravity being approximately 38% of Earth's and a significantly reduced magnetic field. Understanding the combined effects of these factors is crucial, as they may impact biological systems that evolved under different conditions. In this study, we investigated the effects of simulated Martian gravity and hypomagnetic fields on the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans across six generations. We used an integrated experimental setup consisting of clinostats to mimic the reduced Martian gravity, and Merritt coil magnetic cages to model the decreased Martian magnetic fields. We assessed behavioral, morphological, and physiological responses of C. elegans. High-throughput automated assays revealed significant reductions in motor output and morphological dimensions for animals in the Mars treatment compared to matched earth-like controls. We assessed neurological function by means of chemotaxis assays and found a progressive decline in performance for worms raised under the Martian paradigm compared to Earth controls. Our results show that worms grown under Martian-like conditions exhibit progressive physiological alterations across generations, suggesting that the unique environment of Mars might pose challenges to biological function and adaptation. These findings contribute to understanding how living organisms may respond to the combined effects of reduced gravity and hypomagnetic fields, providing insights relevant for future human exploration and potential colonization of Mars. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Low-gravity environment can have a profound impact on the behaviors of biological systems, the dynamics of fluids, and the growth of materials. Systematic research on the effects of gravity is crucial for advancing our knowledge and for the success of space missions. Due to the high cost and the limitations in the payload size and mass in typical spaceflight missions, ground-based low-gravity simulators have become indispensable for preparing spaceflight experiments and for serving as stand-alone research platforms. Among various simulator systems, the magnetic levitation-based simulator (MLS) has received long-lasting interest due to its easily adjustable gravity and practically unlimited operation time. However, a recognized issue with MLSs is their highly non-uniform force field. For a solenoid MLS, the functional volumeV1%, where the net force results in an acceleration <1% of the Earth’s gravityg, is typically a few microliters (μL) or less. In this work, we report an innovative MLS design that integrates a superconducting magnet with a gradient-field Maxwell coil. Through an optimization analysis, we show that an unprecedentedV1%of over 4000 μL can be achieved in a compact coil with a diameter of 8 cm. We also discuss how such an MLS can be made using existing high-Tc-superconducting materials. When the current in this MLS is reduced to emulate the gravity on Mars (gM = 0.38g), a functional volume where the gravity varies within a few percent ofgMcan exceed 20,000 μL. Our design may break new ground for future low-gravity research. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Mission-critical exploration of uncertain environments requires reliable and robust mechanisms for achieving information gain. Typical measures of information gain such as Shannon entropy and KL divergence are unable to distinguish between different bimodal probability distributions or introduce bias toward one mode of a bimodal probability distribution. The use of a standard deviation (SD) metric reduces bias while retaining the ability to distinguish between higher and lower risk distributions. Areas of high SD can be safely explored through observation with an autonomous Mars Helicopter allowing safer and faster path plans for ground-based rovers. First, this study presents a single-agent information-theoretic utility-based path planning method for a highly correlated uncertain environment. Then, an information-theoretic two-stage multiagent rapidly exploring random tree framework is presented, which guides Mars helicopter through regions of high SD to reduce uncertainty for the rover. In a Monte Carlo simulation, we compare our information-theoretic framework with a rover-only approach and a naive approach, in which the helicopter scouts ahead of the rover along its planned path. Finally, the model is demonstrated in a case study on the Jezero region of Mars. Results show that the information-theoretic helicopter improves the travel time for the rover on average when compared with the rover alone or with the helicopter scouting ahead along the rover’s initially planned route. 
    more » « less
  4. This paper presents a design approach for rigid wheels operating in highly variable, deformable terrain to improve the mobility, reliability, and efficiency of an autonomous vehicle driving on snow. The longstanding Bekker-Wong theory of terramechanics is used as the basis for the design changes with the wide range of terrain parameters for snow serving as inputs to the models and bounds for the problem. Modifications to the wheel width and diameter are evaluated based on their impacts to the rover as a system, with their effects on torque and drawbar pull being weighed against the resultant modifications in component sizing, rover weight, and energy use. Other factors, not included in the Bekker-Wong models but studied in single-wheel testbed experiments, such as bulldozing resistance and the observed dynamic effects of slip-sinkage, were also considered in the design decisions for the new wheel. Finally, to test these theories and assess the mobility improvements of the new design in situ, a four-wheeled rover, FrostyBoy, was developed for the new wheels and trialed in unmodified snow. While qualitatively showing an improvement in mobility on the Greenland ice sheet, the tests also uncovered dynamic modes of immobilization, in low cohesion, low stiffness snow that are not accounted for in terramechanics theory and require further investigation for trafficability to be maintained in all snow conditions. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract We quantify the volume and distribution of water, cement, sediments, and fractured rocks within the Martian crust beneath NASA's InSight (Interior Exploration using Seismic Investigations, Geodesy, and Heat Transport mission) lander by using rock physics models to interpret shear wave velocities (Vs) measured from InSight data. The models assume that Mars' crust comprises sediments and fractured rocks whose pores and fractures host variable combinations of gas, liquid water, and mineral cements. MeasuredVsin the upper crust (0–8 km) can be explained by layers of minimally (<2%) cemented sediments and gas‐filled fractured basalts. MeasuredVsin the deeper crust (8–20 km) can be explained by fractured basalts or more felsic igneous rocks (modeled here as 100% plagioclase feldspar) that is unfractured or has up to 23% porosity. Open pores in the deeper crust could host gas, liquid water, and up to 2% cement. ModeledVsare too low for a seismically detectable ice‐saturated cryosphere in the upper crust and temperatures are too high to freeze liquid water in the deeper crust. Notably, withVsalone, we are unable to distinguish between liquid water and gas within the pores. 
    more » « less