An official website of the United States government
Abstract Variations in speleothem calcium isotope ratios (δ44Ca) are thought to be uniquely controlled by prior carbonate precipitation (PCP) above a drip site and, when calibrated with modern data, show promise as a semi‐quantitative proxy for paleorainfall. However, few monitoring studies have focused on δ44Ca in modern cave systems. We present a multi‐year comparative study of δ44Ca, carbon isotopes (δ13C), and trace elemental ratios from cave drip waters, modern calcite, and host rocks from two cave systems in California—White Moon Cave (WMC) and Lake Shasta Caverns (LSC). Drip water and calcite δ44Ca from both caves indicate PCP‐driven enrichment, and we used a simple Rayleigh fractionation model to quantify PCP variability over the monitoring period. Modern calcite trace element and δ44Ca data positively correlate at WMC, but not at LSC, indicating a shared PCP control on these proxies at WMC but not at LSC. At both WMC and LSC, we observe an inverse relationship between PCP and rainfall amounts, though this relationship is variable across individual drip sites. Our modeled data suggest that WMC experiences ∼20% more PCP than LSC, consistent with the fact that WMC receives less annual rainfall. This work supports speleothem δ44Ca as an independent constraint on PCP that can aid in the interpretation of other hydrologically sensitive proxies and provide quantitative estimates of paleorainfall. Additional, long‐term monitoring studies from a variety of climate settings will be key for understanding δ44Ca variability in cave systems more fully and better constraining the relationship between PCP and rainfall.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on November 1, 2025
Cave monitoring in the Peruvian Andes reveals monsoon climate preserved in speleothem calcite
Speleothem paleoclimate records from the Peruvian Andes have been interpreted to reflect the strength of the South American monsoon. While these interpretations have been verified through comparison with other regional and global climate records, the mechanics of the cave environment that facilitate the preservation of this signal with such consistency remain unstudied. Here, we present four years of environmental data from Huagapo and Pacupahuain cave, and one year from Antipayarguna cave. The data reveal that the cave environment is very stable with little to no change in temperature and 100% relative humidity year-round. This stability in cave air is juxtaposed with the monsoonal drip water pulse that increases drip rates over 40 times on average across all seven monitored drip sites. Compared to the amount-weighted precipitation average δ18Oprecip value, the cave drip water δ18ODW values are evaporatively 18O enriched during infiltration through the soil/epikarst. As the monsoonal precipitation pulse fades and drip rates decrease, changes in the drip water chemistry (trace elements Mg/Ca and Sr/Ca, dissolved inorganic carbon δ13CDW, and δ18ODW values) indicate that prior calcite precipi- tation (PCP) drives the trace element and δ13CDW variability. The δ13Cc and δ18Oc values of farmed slide calcite are highly variable. However, high drip rate and lower cave air pCO2 during the monsoon combine to increase calcite precipitation rates. This causes speleothem records from these caves to be weighted toward annual monsoon conditions. Calcite isotope values from actively growing stalagmite tops support this finding. These results suggest that speleothems from these caves are sensitive to changes in monsoon precipitation amount, because it determines the duration of the monsoon drip water pulse, and therein, the extent of dry season PCP. Further, these data indicate that heterogeneity in the dolomitic limestone massif causes offsets between the carbon isotopes and trace metal concentrations between the caves, highlighting the need to normalize these datasets when chronology-stacking these proxies.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2102996
- PAR ID:
- 10615229
- Editor(s):
- NA
- Publisher / Repository:
- Elsevier
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Chemical Geology
- Volume:
- 667
- Issue:
- C
- ISSN:
- 0009-2541
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 122315
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- South American summer monsoon Karst cave Hydrogeochemistry Stable isotopes Calcite
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
In the past decade, Huagapo and Pacupahuain Caves in the Central Peruvian Andes have become sources of speleothem oxygen isotope (δ18O) paleoclimate records. These studies identify the South American Summer Monsoon (SASM) as the main climate system controlling δ18O variability. While this interpretation is verified through inter-proxy record comparisons on millennial scales, interpretation of the high-resolution variability within these records is limited by a lack of modern proxy calibration studies at these sites. Here we present results from a modern cave monitoring study undertaken to address the controls on the δ18O values of precipitation at these sites and how surface and in-cave processes affect the δ18O value of speleothem calcite. Speleothem calcite δ18O values reflect an integrated signal of atmospheric processes (e.g., rainout, Raleigh distillation, upstream moisture recycling, changes in moisture source), evaporation and mixing during infiltration in the soil and epikarst, and in-cave processes such as degassing and evaporation. In consideration of these factors, we compare isotope trends in precipitation, cave drip water and modern farmed calcite from the two cave sites. We find that precipitationδ18O values during peak monsoon activity (January -February) shows considerable inter-annual variation with averages of -16.7‰ for 2020, -18.5‰ for 2021 and -13.8‰ in 2022. We investigate the source of this variability in regional atmospheric circulation patterns using weather station data and back trajectories. The mean annual precipitation (MAP) from outside Huagapo Cave is δ18O = -15.5+/- 6‰, while seasonal samples of drip water δ18O = -14.5+/- 1‰, are offset from MAP possibly due to evaporation during infiltration. Cave drip waterδ18O has low variability over inter-annual and seasonal timescales indicating homogenization in the epikarst. Using geochemical and sensor data (e.g. cave relative humidity, temperature, and drip rate) as inputs for a karst based forward model, we simulate modern speleothem δ18O to quantitatively assess the combined effects of hydroclimate processes integration to the isotope record.more » « less
-
Recent studies have improved our understanding of how karst hydrology impacts variability in modern cave drip water δ18O values and the resultant calcite δ18O values of speleothem paleoclimate records. Monitoring of cave drip water isotope values reveals that flow path controls the differences in drip site values in many caves worldwide. We present a case study of three caves from the central Peruvian Andes where isotopic differences between sites are informed by monitoring data. Relative humidity at Huagapo and Pacupahuain caves is 100% year-round with no fluctuations, so any isotopic fractionation of waters must occur in the vadose zone or epikarst. Precipitation isotope data from the 2022-2023 year show differences with elevation, where annual mean precipitation at 3600 masl (meters above sea level) is, on average, 2‰ greater than precipitation at 4100 masl. Cave drip water was sampled four times (April, June, and November 2022, and June 2023). Average drip water δ18O values were lowest at the high elevation (4004 masl) cave of Antipayargunan -14.7 ± 2.5‰; similar values were found at the lowest elevation (3600 masl) cave of Huagapo -14.5 ± 1.2‰. Pacupahuain cave had the highest values with an average of -13.9 ± 1.7‰. The higher values at Pacupahuain Cave (3800 masl) may be attributed to higher evaporation due to vadose zone residence time, a lower average recharge elevation for this catchment and/or potential contribution from a sinkhole lake (Lago Gallerina) above the cave. Huagapo Cave is large, and sampling sites over 1 km in distance show that the δ18O value of drip water increases by 0.5‰ with increasing distance from the cave entrance. Drip counting sensor data and a continuous SYP autosampler at Pacupahuain Cave provide a time series showing that drip rate peaks during the monsoon season. More specifically, the data show a maximum of 2 ‰ difference in drip water at the autosampler site between the end of the wet season in May and the middle of the dry season in August – at which point drips cease for six months. Seasonal recharge dominates most drip water sites, while drip counters show evidence for fracture and diffuse flow-dominated drip sites. These data suggest that, similar to other cave sites, flow path is important for intra-cave differences in drip water isotope values. However, we find that karst hydrology plays a more dominant role between caves.more » « less
-
In the southwestern United States, California (CA) is one of the most climatically sensitive regions given its low (≤250 mm/year) seasonal precipitation and its inherently variable hydroclimate, subject to large magnitude modulation. To reconstruct past climate change in CA, cave calcite deposits (stalagmites) have been utilized as an archive for environmentally sensitive proxies, such as stable isotope compositions (δ18O, δ13C) and trace element concentrations (e.g., Mg, Ba, Sr). Monitoring the cave and associated surface environments, the chemical evolution of cave drip-water, the calcite precipitated from the drip-water, and the response of these systems to seasonal variability in precipitation and temperature is imperative for interpreting stalagmite proxies. Here we present monitored drip-water and physical parameters at Lilburn Cave, Sequoia Kings Canyon National Park (Southern Sierra Nevada), CA, and measured trace element concentrations (Mg, Sr, Ba, Cu, Fe, Mn) and stable isotopic compositions (δ18O, δ2H) of drip-water and for calcite (δ18O) precipitated on glass substrates over a two-year period (November 2018 to February 2021) to better understand how chemical variability at this site is influenced by local and regional precipitation and temperature variability. Despite large variability in surface temperatures and precipitation amount and source region (North Pacific vs. subtropical Pacific), Lilburn Cave exhibits a constant cave environment year-round. At two of the three sites within the cave, drip-water δ18O and δ2H are influenced seasonally by evaporative enrichment. At a third collection site in the cave, the drip-water δ18O responds solely to precipitation δ18O variability. The Mg/Ca, Ba/Ca, and Sr/Ca ratios are seasonally responsive to prior calcite precipitation at all sites but minimally to water-rock interaction. Lastly, we examine the potential of trace metals (e.g., Mn2+and Cu2+as a geochemical proxy of recharge and find that variability in their concentrations has high potential to denote the onset of the rainy season in the study region. The drip-water composition is recorded in the calcite, demonstrating that stalagmites from Lilburn Cave, and potentially more regionally, could record seasonal variability in weather even during periods of substantially reduced rainfall.more » « less
-
For the past few decades, many researchers have sought to understand how tropical hydroclimate responds to climate change via lakes, marine sediments, and speleothems records. Speleothem δ18O records throughout South America have shown that regional rainfall responds to Northern Hemisphere forcing on the millennial scale. Areas under the influence of the South Atlantic Convergence Zone (SACZ) have also shown a close relationship with local insolation on longer timescales. However, apart from the Cruz et al. (2007) record in Southern Brazil, long-term speleothem records throughout the continent have relied primarily on stable oxygen isotopes and are therefore limited to describing large-scale regional variability in rainfall. As such, many areas in South America still lack long-term records of local hydroclimate, which is critical to understanding how different components of the monsoon system respond to orbital and millennial-scale climate change. One proxy that has gained more attention in recent years is trace metal-to-calcium ratios (TM/Ca). Sr, Mg, and Ba to Ca ratios in speleothems are known in certain situations to respond to the degree of Prior Calcite Precipitation (PCP) above a drip site, a phenomenon directly tied to local aridity. In this study, we have obtained high-resolution TM/Ca measurements to pair with stable isotopes from samples spanning 23 to 66 ka from Huagapo Cave in the Peruvian Andes (11.27°S; 75.79°W). TM/Ca ratios in these samples are strongly correlated (R2>0.89), making them suitable for use as PCP proxies. We see that decreases in δ18O during Heinrich events are accompanied by a drop in TM/Ca. The period defined by the MIS 4/3 transition is accompanied by a simultaneous increase in TM/Ca and δ18O. TM/Ca and δ18O negatively correlate with local insolation for the entire record. Interestingly, the Paraíso Cave record from the Amazon Basin shows no correlation between regional or local hydroclimate and insolation during the last glacial period. The discrepancy between the two records and the close relationship between TM/Ca, δ18O, and local insolation in Huagapo samples, may call for a revised interpretation of Andes speleothem δ18O variability, which was originally thought to reflect rainout over the Amazon Basin.more » « less
