An official website of the United States government
Paleosol weathering commonly is characterized by an index of alteration determined from bulk rock elemental abundances. Although a variety of indices exist, they all essentially compare the proportion of immobile major elemental oxides associated with refractory minerals (mainly Al2O3 in phyllosilicate clays) to mobile major elements associated with labile minerals (i.e., CaO, Na2O). Higher proportions of immobile major elemental oxides reflects more intense chemical weathering, which is used to infer warmer, wetter climate conditions. However, bulk rock alteration indices are known to be influenced by variability in particle size, effects of quartz dilution, and authigenic mineralization, which are challenging to account for when destructive analytical approaches are used. We tested a non-destructive method of assessing chemical weathering intensity using automated mineralogy analysis, which relies on SEM BSE imaging and EDS spectrum acquisition with automated matching of whole spectra to reference spectra to generate quantitative mineralogy estimates. Our case study focused on 9 Upper Pennsylvanian Spodosol samples from the Appalachian basin, and the dominant mineralogic group identified by automated mineralogy in all samples were phyllosilicate clays (50-85%). Six samples showed >20% feldspar: however, grain shape analysis indicates often micron-scale clay-sized grains with prismatic crystal habit were assigned a potassium feldspar spectra. This is due to the automated mineralogy algorithm identifying a mixed signal from sub-micron quartz/amorphous silica and illite in the X-ray volume as a feldspar x-ray spectrum. Furthermore, the Chemical Index of Alteration calculated from bulk elemental estimates of automated mineralogy results ranged from ~60-65, and A-CN-K ternary plots indicate samples were influenced by K-metasomatism. Using an algorithm that assigns automated mineral identification on the basis of both whole-spectrum matching and particle morphology attributes (including grain shape/crystal habit and size), we can better constrain mineralogical interpretation of fine-grained sedimentary lithologies. This allows automated mineralogy analysis to be used in a new approach for assessing weathering intensity by analyzing the proportion of mobile versus immobile elements in prismatic grains versus equant grains across a distribution of grain sizes in a way that can mitigate or minimize known limitations to the accuracy of alteration indices (e.g., authigenic skins, K-metasomatism).
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on December 11, 2025
Preliminary insights on evaluating paleosol composition from automated mineralogy analysis
Advancements in automated mineralogy offer an opportunity to develop new approaches to the study of fine-grained sedimentary lithologies including paleosols and pedogenic minerals that hold valuable paleoclimate information. Automated mineralogy is a non-destructive analytical technique that relies on BSE imaging with spectral data to output multimodal hypermaps. Spatial domains are delineated and assigned mineral phases using whole spectrum best matching to reference spectra, providing quantitative sample composition estimates with high throughput data collection. We targeted a Spodosol in the lower part of the Upper Pennsylvanian Casselman Fm. of the Appalachian basin to evaluate the utility of automated mineralogy in determining paleosol composition. During deposition of the lower Casselman Fm., tropical climate during the Late Paleozoic Ice Age began a return to a more humid regime following the Kasimovian–Gzhelian boundary (~304 Ma) warming event. The Spodosol is a composite paleosol approximately 1.4 m thick that displays redoximorphic mottling, small scale (≤ 3 cm) slickensides and weak angular platy ped development. We performed automated mineralogy analysis on 9 paleosol samples, which were formed into 25 mm polished epoxy mounts of disaggregated peds, and generated complete mineralogical maps of the samples. These results indicate that phyllosilicate clays, mainly illite, formed the dominant mineralogic group (50-85%) with lesser amounts of quartz (~5-23%), feldspar (12-30%), carbonate (0-12%) and Fe-oxides (0-9%). Estimates of Al, Ca, Na and K from were used to determine Chemical Index of Alteration, with values ranging from 59-67. These CIA estimates tend to be quite low compared to CIA estimates determined from previous work using bulk elemental abundances by WDS-XRF (CIA >67). Further interrogation of these preliminary results revealed that interphase quartz-illite analyses were assigned a potassium feldspar interpretation. Ultimately we will combine image analysis (e.g., particle shape/habit) with new reference spectra for paleosol interphase matrix material, which together with WDS-XRF and XRD mineralogy calibration can be used to develop a robust methodology for automated mineralogy analysis of paleosols.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2219079
- PAR ID:
- 10617234
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Geophysical Union
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Location:
- Washington, D.C.
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Fine-grained sedimentary lithologies can be challenging to characterize but often preserve vital environmental indicators. We used cm-scale outcrop description, bulk geochemistry, and micro- to nano-scale automated mineral identification SEM and characterization analysis to investigate attributes of paleosols in the central Appalachian basin. Paleosols were selected that developed under varying climatic conditions of the latest Pennsylvanian (earliest Permian? Late Paleozoic Ice Age. In the upper Casselman Fm., paleosols exhibit redoximorphic texture (in a suspect spodosol? with cm-scale slickensides and weak ped development, with mineralogy that includes small amounts of gypsum, barite, and pyrite within the predominantly illite matrix. A histosol “underclayˮ in the Casselman shows nodular calcite within an illite matrix that is cross-cut by micro-veins of gypsum. In the overlying Monongahela Fm., within interbedded clastic and carbonate lacustrine deposits is a composite vertisol with large vertic structures and gilgai microtopography. The vertisol contains carbonate nodules in an illite/quartz matrix with disseminated dolomite and rare pyrite. Upward in the Monongahela Fm., lacustrine carbonates of the Benwood Member show evidence for pedogenesis, such as rootlets and auto-brecciation/fracturing, and weak argillan development. These carbonate paleosols show successive upward decrease in illite and quartz content, with carbonate minerals becoming increasingly dolomitic. Microfabrics and mineralogical relationships indicate a primary origin of the dolomite. Status of presenter N/A ⌘K Sign in The integration of soil macro- and micro-morphology along with mineralogy provides more comprehensive climatic and environmental indicators for this succession, and reflects a transition from paleosol interaction with sulfate-rich water toward interaction with more alkaline water over timemore » « less
-
Siliciclastic muds (clay- and silt-sized sediment) concentrate physical and chemical weathering products. However, both rock composition and climate can affect the mineralogy and geochemistry of these sediments. We quantitatively assessed the influence of provenance and climate on muds collected from end-member climates to test, which, if any, of these potential weathering signatures are indicative of climate in fine-grained, fluvial sediments. Granulometry, mineralogy, and geochemistry of the studied muds indicated that provenance and mineral sorting hinder interpretation of (paleo)climate signals. These issues also affect chemical index of alteration (CIA) values, as well as mafic-felsic-weathering (MFW), Al2O3−(CaO* + Na2O)−K2O (A-CN-K), and Al2O3−(CaO* + Na2O + K2O)−(FeOT + MgO) (A-CNK-FM) ternary plots, decreasing their utility as paleoclimate proxies. CaO content is heavily weighted within the calculations, resulting in even felsic-sourced sediment commonly plotting as mafic owing to the relative enrichment in CaO from preferential sorting of Ca-rich minerals into the mud-sized fraction during transport. These results cast doubt on the indiscriminate use of CIA values and ternary plots for interpreting chemical weathering and paleoclimate within muds, particularly from glacial systems. Most notably, the positive correlations between CIA and climatic parameters (mean annual temperature and mean annual precipitation) diminished when sediments that had formed in nonglacial settings were filtered out from the data sets. This implies that CIA may only be applicable when used in nonglacial systems in which the composition of the primary source material is well constrained—such as soil/paleosol profiles. Within this end-member climate data set, CIA was only useful in discriminating hot-humid climates.more » « less
-
Paleocene-Eocene hyperthermals are viewed as some of the best ancient analogs for projected future anthropogenic climate change. In order to fully evaluate the magnitude of these climactic perturbations, however, a more complete understanding of prevailing background conditions is necessary. The Mississippi Embayment, a major southwest-dipping sedimentary basin in the Gulf of Mexico coastal region of North America, contains an extensive record of Paleocene strata deposited prior to the onset of the Paleocene Carbon Isotope Maximum (PCIM), a gradual warming trend upon which the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) was superimposed. In order to evaluate pre-PCIM paleoclimate, we focus on paleosols in the Upper Paleocene Naheola Formation. A continuous section of the Naheola is available in archival core collected by Mississippi Minerals Resources Institute from Tippah County, Mississippi, USA. We performed a suite of initial core description methods, including logging of visual observations (e.g., grain size and Munsell colors), gamma density, magnetic susceptibility, smear slide analysis, and scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (SEM-EDS). Results indicate a > 8-m-thick interval of 5 stacked paleosols associated with 4 lignite seams. The paleosols range in thickness from 0.6 m to 1.9 m, while the lignite seams range in thickness from 0.3 m to 1.3 m. Paleosols are characterized by low chroma matrix colors, mottling, and abundant carbonized roots. The thickest paleosols each exhibit an interval that coarsens and then fines upward; these are likely composite paleosols. Applying SEM-EDS results from all paleosols to the chemical index of alteration minus potash (CIA-K) yields preliminary mean annual precipitation estimates between 1200 and 1300 mm. The oldest paleosol contains abundant kaolinite and future stable isotope analysis will be used to reconstruct paleotemperature. Ongoing work will evaluate the relative influence of each of the five soil-forming factors on Naheola paleosol development and reexamine Paleocene- Eocene hyperthermals within the context of our results. Future work will include pollen analysis to improve chronostratigraphic control and evaluate paleoecological response to the Paleocene- Eocene climate change.more » « less
-
Abstract Extensive regions of yellow and white (“bleached”) sandstones within the terrestrial Jurassic red bed deposits of the Colorado Plateau reflect widespread interaction with subsurface reduced fluids which resulted in the dissolution of iron‐oxide grain coatings. Reduced fluids such as hydrocarbons, CO2, and organic acids have been proposed as bleaching agents. In this study, we characterize an altered section of the Slick Rock member of the Jurassic Entrada Sandstone that exposes bleached sandstone with bitumen‐saturated pore spaces. We observe differences in texture, porosity, mineralogy, and geochemistry between red, pink, yellow, and gray facies. In the bleached yellow facies we observe quartz overgrowths, partially dissolved K‐feldspar, calcite cement, fine‐grained illite, TiO2‐minerals, and pyrite concretions. Clay mineral content is highest at the margins of the bleached section. Fe2O3concentrations are reduced up to 3× from the red to gray facies but enriched up to 50× in iron‐oxide concretions. Metals such as Zn, Pb, and rare‐earth elements are significantly enriched in the concretions. Supported by a batch geochemical model, we conclude the interaction of red sandstones with reduced hydrocarbon‐bearing fluids caused iron‐oxide and K‐feldspar dissolution, and precipitation of quartz, calcite, clay, and pyrite. Localized redistribution of iron into concretions can account for most of the iron removed during bleaching. Pyrite and carbonate stable isotopic data suggest the hydrocarbons were sourced from the Pennsylvanian Paradox Formation. Bitumen in pore spaces and pyrite precipitation formed a reductant trap required to produce Cu, U, and V enrichment in all altered facies by younger, oxidized saline brines.more » « less
