An official website of the United States government
Wildfire severity is increasing in the western United States. Simultaneously, many recognize that fire is a natural process and advocate for learning to live with fire. Indeed, the naturalness of fire can be an important reason provided to increase the amount of fire on a landscape. However, “naturalness” can be interpreted in incommensurate ways, such as the historic range of variability of a system or the absence of human influence. What makes wildfires feel natural or unnatural to the people who experience them, and how naturalness affects reactions to wildfires is underexplored. Using social representations theory, we examine the 2023 Lookout Fire at the H. J. Andrews Experimental Forest (HJA). We use semi-structured interviews (n = 40) to explore how the research community associated with the HJA mentally constructs and uses naturalness to emotionally process and make meaning from the wildfire. We find even in a community with advanced training in ecology, respondents use a variety of metrics to determine naturalness, including ignition source, fire behavior, and pre-fire landscape characteristics and fire history. Respondents consider a variety of factors, and there was not consensus on whether the Lookout Fire was a “natural” fire. In general, respondents who described the fire as more natural were able to come to a state of acceptance and excitement for future research opportunities sooner than respondents who described the fire as largely unnatural. This has important implications for wildfire risk communication for scientists and practitioners who want to restore fire as a natural process. While fires perceived (or framed) as natural may be more readily accepted, fires perceived as unnatural may take longer to process. Fires perceived as human-caused and especially as climate-exacerbated may be the most difficult for people to process after and during the fire, and may have the most resistance for being managed for purposes other than full suppression.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on June 1, 2026
The Role of Suppression Performance Information in Judging When to Use a Fire Extinguisher
The ability of a fire extinguisher to suppress fires varies by the rated performance of the unit. Safety guidance in the United States indicates that the occupant should consider the performance rating of the extinguisher when deciding to use it with a fire. The present study investigated whether individuals are aware of the connection between the suppression performance of fire extinguishers and the intensity of fires the unit can extinguish. Across five experiments, participants were presented with fire extinguishers that varied in suppression performance (smaller, medium, and larger) and judged whether the extinguisher could extinguish a developing room fire that increased in intensity. The fire intensity at which they stopped attempting to use the extinguisher (threshold) was calculated. No significant differences in threshold were observed by suppression performance condition when suppression information about the single extinguisher at hand was presented. This included when information was provided about the amount of agent, the distance and duration of discharge, and with the water equivalent the extinguisher was rated. However, when trained on the differences in suppression performance between extinguishers and provided with corresponding containers of water, thresholds did vary by performance rating. We discuss how providing information about variations in suppression performance may be necessary to highlight differences in extinguisher ratings.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2200416
- PAR ID:
- 10620688
- Publisher / Repository:
- MDPI
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Safety
- Volume:
- 11
- Issue:
- 2
- ISSN:
- 2313-576X
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 58
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- decision making human behavior in fire perception-action information processing mental representation
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Neotropical xerophytic forest ecosystems evolved with fires that shaped their resilience to disturbance events. However, it is unknown whether forest resilience to fires persists under a new fire regime influenced by anthropogenic disturbance and climate change. We asked whether there was evidence for a fire severity threshold causing an abrupt transition from a forest to an alternative shrub thicket state in the presence of typical postfire management. We studied a heterogeneous wildfire event to assess medium‐term effects (11 years) of varying fire severity in a xerophytic Caldén forest in central Argentina. We conducted vegetation surveys in patches that were exposed to low (LFS), medium (MFS), and high (HFS) fire severities but had similar prefire woody canopy cover. Satellite images were used to quantify fire severity using a delta Normalized Burning Ratio (dNBR) and to map prefire canopy cover. Postfire total woody canopy cover was higher in low and medium than high severity patches, but the understory woody component was highest in HFS patches. The density of woody plants was over three times higher under HFS than MFS and LFS due to the contribution of small woody plants to the total density. Unlike LFS and MFS patches, the small plants in HFS patches were persistent, multistem shrubs that resulted from the resprouting of top‐killedProsopis caldeniatrees and, more importantly, from young shrubs that probably established after the wildfire. Our results suggest that the Caldén forest is resilient to fires of low to moderate severities but not to high‐severity fires. Fire severities with dNBR values > ~600 triggered an abrupt transition to a shrub thicket state. Postfire grazing and controlled‐fire treatments likely contributed to shrub dominance after high‐severity wildfire. Forest to shrub thicket transitions enable recurring high‐severity fire events. We propose that repeated fires combined with grazing can trap the system in a shrub thicket state. Further studies are needed to determine whether the relationships between fire and vegetation structure examined in this case study represent general mechanisms of irreversible state changes across the Caldenal forest region and whether analogous threshold relationships exist in other fire‐prone woodland ecosystems.more » « less
-
Tropical peatlands are highly vulnerable to anthropogenic alterations. In Costa Rica, riverine peatlands are understudied, and most are not included in protected areas. This study aims to generating information useful to assess the anthropogenic pressure in a riverine peatland in Los Robles Sector (LRS) of Medio Queso Wetland (MQW) complex. Evaluations of impacts of fires on vegetation and surface peat chemistry, and the post-2021 fire, makeup of dominant vegetation changes with the Cyperaceae species Scleria melaleuca replacing Eleocharis interstincta as the dominant species are presented. The topsoil (0–20 cm) total C content was quantified as lower than 300 g kg−1 with no significant statistical differences in total C and N content between soil shortly after the fires or two years later. The species E. interstincta is observed to promote higher C stability during the dry season, and has a more recalcitrant composition of the root system compared to the post 2021-fire dominant S. melaleuca. To reduce the impact on C accumulation, measures to prevent grazing-originated fires, especially when the water table is low, are urgent. Hence, this work aims at proving information that can be a baseline for impacts assessment and to inform conservation measures and policies.more » « less
-
To understand community impacts and needs after the August 2023 Maui wildfires, we conducted a rapid survey-based field investigation two weeks after the incident. During the fires, municipal water customers were warned not to use their water due to potential drinking water contamination. Household displacement and isolation of some impacted areas limited extensive study participation. Households (14) in the affected areas were visited and surveyed about property characteristics, evacuation, water use, and water quality observations. Publicly available test results from Maui County and the University of Hawai'i were also reviewed. Opportunistically, wildfire impacts to agricultural water systems were documented. Half of the households had property damage, and all lost power and used drinking water before being notified that it was potentially contaminated. Nearly all households expressed confusion about allowable water use activities and health risks. Most households noticed water issues after the evacuation order was lifted, and some acquired and used at-home drinking water test kits. None of these kits could find all previously identified fire-related chemicals. Damage to agricultural water systems was similar to damage seen for residential systems. Recommendations to lessen impacts and expedite community response and recovery from wildfires are provided.more » « less
-
Australia has long been recognized as one of the world’s fire hotspots, but the Black Summer of 2019-2020, when 97,000 km2 were scorched across southeastern Australia, and the larger fires of northern Australia’s savanna and desert in 2023, may indicate a shift toward a higher level of fire activity. Placing these events in context requires developing precisely-dated, high resolution records of bushfire through periods with different climate and land use mean states. We reconstructed bushfire activity for the period 1110-2009 CE using polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) in three precisely-dated, fast-growing, and partially overlapping aragonite stalagmites from cave KNI-51, located in the central Australian tropical savanna. PAH molecular weights are tied to combustion temperature (i.e., low molecular weights form in lower temperature fires), and thus our record preserves evidence of both the timing and intensity of bushfire over the majority of the last millennium. Comparisons of burn scar satellite imagery with temporal changes in PAH abundances in recently deposited stalagmite suggest that airfall (smoke and ash) from fires within a 5 km radius is primarily responsible for transmitting PAHs to the land surface over the cave, a finding supported by our recent controlled burn and irrigation experiment. The rapid growth rate of KNI-51 stalagmites (1-2 mm yr-1), coupled with the extremely thin soils above the cave, appear to allow for transmission and preservation of multi-annual paleofire signals. To investigate the effects of external forcing on bushfire activity over the last millennium, we applied linear mixed-effect regression to the PAH data, and also included monsoon rainfall (using oxygen isotope ratios from the same stalagmites), annual surface air temperature (using output from the CESM-Last Millennium Ensemble), antecedent fire (using the same stalagmite PAH record), and timing with respect to the arrival of European pastoralists (EP) and their cattle in the 1880s. The model reveals significant differences prior to and following the arrival of EP. Most notably, prior to the arrival of EP, rainfall was significantly correlated with low and medium intensity fires, but not high intensity ones. After the arrival of EP, the correlation between rainfall and fire activity decreased markedly, and showed no statistically significant correlation to any fire intensity. Similarly, prior to the arrival of EP, antecedent fire activity (determined as the sum of PAH within the previous 5 years) was correlated with all levels of fire intensity, but after EP arrival, only high intensity fires are correlated with such antecedent burning. Our findings thus suggest that fire activity following the arrival of EP in the eastern Kimberley has been distinct from any other extended period of the last nine centuries.more » « less
