skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


This content will become publicly available on May 1, 2026

Title: A Puzzle About General Covariance and Gauge
We consider two simple criteria for when a physical theory should be said to be ``generally covariant'', and we argue that these criteria are not met by Yang-Mills theory, even on geometric formulations of that theory. The reason, we show, is that the bundles encountered in Yang-Mills theory are not natural bundles; instead, they are gauge-natural. We then show how these observations relate to previous arguments about the significance of solder forms in assessing disanalogies between general relativity and Yang-Mills theory. We conclude by suggesting that general covariance is really about functoriality.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2419967
PAR ID:
10623964
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Publisher / Repository:
University of Chicago Press
Date Published:
Journal Name:
The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
ISSN:
0007-0882
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract We define a natural state space and Markov process associated to the stochastic Yang–Mills heat flow in two dimensions. To accomplish this we first introduce a space of distributional connections for which holonomies along sufficiently regular curves (Wilson loop observables) and the action of an associated group of gauge transformations are both well-defined and satisfy good continuity properties. The desired state space is obtained as the corresponding space of orbits under this group action and is shown to be a Polish space when equipped with a natural Hausdorff metric. To construct the Markov process we show that the stochastic Yang–Mills heat flow takes values in our space of connections and use the “DeTurck trick” of introducing a time dependent gauge transformation to show invariance, in law, of the solution under gauge transformations. Our main tool for solving for the Yang–Mills heat flow is the theory of regularity structures and along the way we also develop a “basis-free” framework for applying the theory of regularity structures in the context of vector-valued noise – this provides a conceptual framework for interpreting several previous constructions and we expect this framework to be of independent interest. 
    more » « less
  2. It was recently argued by Nguyen, Tanizaki and Ünsal that two-dimensional pure Yang–Mills theory is equivalent to (decomposes into) a disjoint union of (invertible) quantum field theories, known as universes. In this paper, we compare this decomposition to the Gross–Taylor expansion of two-dimensional pure [Formula: see text] Yang–Mills theory in the large-[Formula: see text] limit as the string field theory of a sigma model. Specifically, we study the Gross–Taylor expansion of individual Nguyen–Tanizaki–Ünsal universes. These differ from the Gross–Taylor expansion of the full Yang–Mills theory in two ways: a restriction to single instanton degrees, and some additional contributions not present in the expansion of the full Yang–Mills theory. We propose to interpret the restriction to single instanton degrees as implying a constraint, namely that the Gross–Taylor string has a global (higher-form) symmetry with Noether current related to the worldsheet instanton number. We compare two-dimensional pure Maxwell theory as a prototype obeying such a constraint, and also discuss in that case an analogue of the Witten effect arising under two-dimensional theta angle rotation. We also propose a geometric interpretation of the additional terms, in the special case of Yang–Mills theories on 2-spheres. In addition, also for the case of theories on 2-spheres, we propose a reinterpretation of the terms in the Gross–Taylor expansion of the Nguyen–Tanizaki–Ünsal universes, replacing sigma models on branched covers by counting disjoint unions of stacky copies of the target Riemann surface, that makes the Nguyen–Tanizaki–Ünsal decomposition into invertible field theories more nearly manifest. As the Gross–Taylor string is a sigma model coupled to worldsheet gravity, we also briefly outline the tangentially related topic of decomposition in two-dimensional theories coupled to gravity. 
    more » « less
  3. We propose a description of the gluon scattering amplitudes as the inverse Mellin transforms of the conformal correlators of light operators in two-dimensional Liouville theory tensored with WZW-like chiral currents on the celestial sphere. The dimensions of operators are Mellin dual to gluon light cone energies while their positions are determined by the gluon momentum directions. Tree-level approximation in Yang-Mills theory corresponds to the semiclassical limit of Liouville theory. By comparing subleading corrections, we find b^2=(8π^2)^{−1}b_0g^2(M), where b is the Liouville coupling constant, g(M) is the Yang Mills coupling at the renormalization scale M and b_0 is the one-loop coefficient of the Yang-Mills beta function. 
    more » « less
  4. This is the first part of the four-paper sequence, which establishes the Threshold Conjecture and the Soliton Bubbling vs. Scattering Dichotomy for the energy critical hyperbolic Yang-Mills equation in the (4 + 1)-dimensional Minkowski space-time. The primary subject of this paper, however, is another PDE, namely the energy critical Yang-Mills heat flow on the 4-dimensional Euclidean space. Our first goal is to establish sharp criteria for global existence and asymptotic convergence to a flat connection for this system in H1, including the Dichotomy Theorem (i.e., either the above properties hold or a harmonic Yang-Mills connection bubbles off) and the Threshold Theorem (i.e., if the initial energy is less than twice that of the ground state, then the above properties hold). Our second goal is to use the Yang-Mills heat flow in order to define the caloric gauge, which will play a major role in the analysis of the hyperbolic Yang-Mills equation in the subsequent papers. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    A bstract We study two-dimensional celestial conformal field theory describing four- dimensional $$ \mathcal{N} $$ N =1 supergravity/Yang-Mills systems and show that the underlying symmetry is a supersymmetric generalization of BMS symmetry. We construct fermionic conformal primary wave functions and show how they are related via supersymmetry to their bosonic partners. We use soft and collinear theorems of supersymmetric Einstein-Yang- Mills theory to derive the OPEs of the operators associated to massless particles. The bosonic and fermionic soft theorems are shown to form a sequence under supersymmetric Ward identities. In analogy with the energy momentum tensor, the supercurrents are shadow transforms of soft gravitino operators and generate an infinite-dimensional super- symmetry algebra. The algebra of $$ {\mathfrak{sbms}}_4 $$ sbms 4 generators agrees with the expectations based on earlier work on the asymptotic symmetry group of supergravity. We also show that the supertranslation operator can be written as a product of holomorphic and anti-holomorphic supercurrents. 
    more » « less