Attention:The NSF Public Access Repository (PAR) system and access will be unavailable from 11:00 PM ET on Thursday, October 15th until 12:00 AM ET on Friday, October 16th due to maintenance. We apologize for the inconvenience.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: Invasive species invoke a lifetime of trophic change in native stream fishes
Abstract Trophic interactions operate across the lifetime of an individual organism, yet our understanding of these processes is largely limited to a single life stage or moment in time. Management and conservation implications of this knowledge gap are particularly important, given the mounting number, spread, and ecological impacts of invasive species. Biotracers, such as carbon and nitrogen stable isotopes of animal muscle, are commonly used to characterize the trophic ecology of an individual but fail to capture intraindividual variation and ontogenetic dietary shifts. However, recent work suggests that eye lenses may facilitate the reconstruction of individual lifetime trophic trajectories for fishes, including the chronology of past trophic positions of and carbon flow to consumers. By combining stable isotope analysis of fish eye lens tissue with aging techniques (otolith growth measurements), this study is the first to ask how the lifetime trophic niches of individuals vary within different community contexts. The results provide evidence for asymmetric competition causing differing trajectories in lifetime trophic niches for native and nonnative fishes along an invasion gradient in Burro Creek, Arizona, USA. Native roundtail chub, Sonora sucker, and desert sucker all displayed a coordinated displacement of lifetime trophic trajectories to a lower trophic level and reliance on aquatic, rather than terrestrial, resources as indicated by a shift to lower δ13C and δ15N in mixed, relative to native‐only, communities. By contrast, the trophic trajectories of nonnative green sunfish and bullhead species remained consistent between native and nonnative dominated communities. The presence of nonnative species led to a significantly greater decrease in δ13C through ontogeny for roundtail chub, a species of conservation concern in Arizona. These results demonstrate the prolonged trophic impact of nonnative fishes on native fishes beyond a single life stage. Displacement of ontogenetic dietary shifts by native fishes through interactions with nonnative species may lead to reduced fish growth and fitness, with implications at the population and ecosystem levels. Stable isotope analysis of fish eye lens tissue offers new opportunities to study the lifetime chronology of individual feeding habits and allows for exploration of the impacts of invasive species and environmental change throughout ontogeny.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1922004
PAR ID:
10629661
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Ecosphere
Volume:
16
Issue:
6
ISSN:
2150-8925
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; (, PLOS One)
    Palsson, Arnar (Ed.)
    Ontogenetic niche shifts in fishes are nearly universal but remain poorly understood in many species despite being fundamentally important for the persistence, management, and conservation of fish populations, including those of vulnerable salmonids. Eye lens stable isotope analysis has proven useful in studying ontogeny in some marine species but has rarely been applied in freshwater fishes. We conducted among the first applications of eye lens stable isotope analysis in two salmonids, Arctic Charr (Salvelinus alpinus) and Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis), in four North American lakes at the southern extent of the range of Arctic Charr (Maine, USA). Our goal was to determine if ontogenetic patterns varied between individuals and populations in ways that relate to differential vulnerability. Like studies in marine systems, we found patterns in lens isotopic values that agree with expected ontogenetic patterns to reach known adult trophic niches. Within lakes and individuals examined in this study, Arctic Charr appeared more dependent on pelagic resources than co-occurring Brook Trout through life. Using Bayesian hierarchical linear regressions, we found evidence that ontogenetic shifts in trophic position (measured by δ15N) of Arctic Charr may vary among lakes. Arctic Charr in some populations increased in trophic position through life (population lifetime δ15N posterior mean slope estimate = 1.01) while others showed no substantial changes (population lifetime δ15N posterior mean slope = 0.05), which may relate to differences in habitat and fish assemblage among our study lakes. Our study suggests that individual life stages and populations of salmonids are likely to respond to climate variability (e.g., basal resource shifts) differentially, which could warrant population and life-stage-specific management. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; (, U.S. Geological Survey)
    Abstract: Ontogenetic niche shifts are almost universal in fishes and many other organisms and are thus often important to factor in conservation planning. However, some aspects of ontogeny, such as trophic shifts, remain poorly understood in many fishes. Eye lens stable isotope analysis has proven a powerful tool in understanding the ontogeny of some marine species, but few studies have applied this method to freshwater fishes. We conducted the first use of eye lens stable isotope analysis of Arctic Charr (Salvelinus alpinus), a climate-sensitive salmonid, and co-occurring Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) in four temperate North American lakes at the southern extent of the range of Arctic Charr in Maine, USA. Akin to studies in marine systems, we document patterns in the sizes and isotopic values of the lens structure that agree with expected ontogenetic patterns. Using Bayesian linear regressions, we found that the trophic ontogeny as measured by δ15N of Arctic Charr varied among lakes. Through examining individual lifetime trophic histories (δ15N and δ13C), we found that some Arctic Charr populations increase in trophic position through life while (population lifetime δ15N posterior mean slope = 1.12) others show no substantial change (population lifetime δ15N posterior mean slope = -0.06). Our study demonstrates a useful method of whole-life trophic investigation in fishes that minimizes destructive sampling. The file "CharrEyeLensData.csv" includes δ15N and δ13C isotope values and morphological measurements from individual eye lens layers of Arctic Charr and Brook Trout. The file "CharrEyeLens_SIABaseline_Data.csv" includes δ15N and δ13C isotope values of littoral and pelagic resources from the study lakes. The file "CharrEyeLens_RegressionScript.csv" provides a reproducible analytical method for comparing lifetime trophic experience between populations. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; (, Ecosphere)
    Abstract The Trophic Disruption Hypothesis (TDH) predicts that invasive species may cause native species to undergo trophic dispersion (change in trophic‐niche area) and trophic displacement (diet switching), predictably altering food‐web structure and biodiversity. In Everglades National Park, Florida, USA, African Jewelfish (Rubricatochromis letourneuxi) density has recently (2012–2017) undergone a boom‐bust cycle, linked to declines of native taxa and altered aquatic‐community composition that persist after the bust. Everglades restoration efforts seek to restore historic hydrologic conditions that may contribute to food‐web changes unfolding coincidentally with the jewelfish boom. We used complementary datasets of stomach contents and stable isotopes (δ15N and δ13C) to quantify pre‐ and post‐invasion consumer diets, trophic positions, trophic niches, basal energy use (autotrophic vs. heterotrophic), and energy fluxes to test assumptions of the TDH. The direction of change for these metrics from dry season to wet‐season post‐invasion (i.e., effect of adding water) was used as a proxy for the direction of effects from restored water delivery. For trophic shifts attributable to jewelfish invasion, we tested assumptions of the TDH. Comparing pre‐ versus post‐invasion for native consumers, we observed trophic displacement in 42% of species size classes (based on stomach contents), trophic dispersion for 57% of species (based on stable isotopes) and 54% of species size classes (based on stomach contents), and overall greater reliance on autotrophic energy. Altered trophic dynamics were more frequent pre‐ versus post‐invasion than among habitats or between seasons, and the direction of those responses was in the opposite direction of dry‐season to wet‐season differences and/or occurred at a higher frequency. Post‐invasion food‐web structure and function revealed increased relative abundance of mesopredators (including African Jewelfish) and reduced biomass and energy fluxes into and out of small fishes (e.g., Cyprinodontiformes). Our results show that African Jewelfish invasion is linked to altered spatiotemporal trophic dynamics and energy fluxes through declines in native fishes and invertebrates, which indirectly affected trophic relationships at the regional scale in the Everglades. As a result, we suggest extending the TDH to explicitly include the potential for invasive species to alter basal energy use, spatiotemporal trophic dynamics, and energy fluxes. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Nature)
    Abstract Caribbean reefs have experienced major human-driven changes to their coral and fish communities1–4, yet how these changes have affected trophic dynamics remains poorly understood owing to challenges in reconstructing the trophic structure of pre-human-impact reefs. Advances in fossil-bound protein nitrogen isotope (15N/14N) analysis now enable the reconstruction of ancient trophic dynamics5,6, as the15N to 14N ratio reflects an animal’s trophic position7. Here we apply this method to modern and prehistoric (7,000-year-old) fish otoliths (ear stones) and corals from Caribbean Panama and the Dominican Republic, focusing on fishes occupying low to middle trophic levels. We find that although the trophic level typically declined in high-trophic-level fishes over time, it increased or remained unchanged in low-trophic-level fishes, indicating that modern food chains are 60–70% shorter than on the prehistoric reefs in both Panama and the Dominican Republic. Furthermore, across all trophic groups, we observed a marked reduction in dietary variation, with a 20–70% lower trophic range on the modern reefs compared to the prehistoric reefs. This pattern is best explained by less dietary specialization in modern reefs, consistent with less ecological complexity than in prehistoric reefs. These differences document and quantify the trophic simplification that has occurred on modern Caribbean reefs, a change that may increase their vulnerability to ecosystem collapse. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; (, Global Ecology and Biogeography)
    ABSTRACT Scale‐Dependency of Native StatusClassifying populations as native or nonnative requires well‐defined range boundaries for species. While many studies define native status according to large biogeographic realms, natural dispersal barriers often limit species distributions at regional or smaller spatial extents. As such, native/nonnative definitions are inherently scale‐dependent and estimates of community invadedness thus depend on the spatial resolution at which native status is defined. For example, nonnative species can be introduced among realms, among regions within realms, and among ecological provinces within regions (hereafter, simply “provinces”). By explicitly considering the scale‐dependency of native/nonnative status definitions, we can more effectively compare results across studies, more comprehensively evaluate the degree of invasion levels, and more objectively communicate the native status of a species. Location30,034 stream segments, conterminous United States. Time Period2000–2023. Major Taxa StudiedFreshwater fishes. Quantifying Fish Community Invadedness Across<styled-content style='fixed-case'>US</styled-content>StreamsWe illustrate the importance of scale‐dependent native status definitions by quantifying nonnative species richness and relative abundance in stream fish communities across the United States, finding that provincially nonnative species are nearly four times as prevalent as extra‐realm nonnative species, and represented approximately 10% of all individuals in average community surveys. ImplicationsUnrealistically broad native status definitions underestimate community invadedness. Dismissing regionally and provincially nonnative species can have severe ecological consequences, including displacement and hybridisation with native species and the loss of unique communities through biotic homogenisation. These consequences may undermine efforts to maintain and protect distinct local biodiversity and conserve endemic species. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Text Encoded Conversion
  • XML
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email