An official website of the United States government
Urban expansion and the increasing frequency and intensity of extreme precipitation events bring new challenges to stormwater collection systems. One underrecognized issue is the occurrence of transient flow conditions that lead to adverse multiphase flow interactions (AMFI): essentially, the formation, collapse, and uncontrolled release of air pockets within stormwater system flows. While the fundamental physics of AMFI have been evaluated in laboratory experiments and idealized modeling studies, much less is known about their development in real or simulated stormwater networks, and about the roles played by rainfall and network properties. A necessary precursor to AMFI is the development of pressurized flow conditions within a network. The goal of this study is to understand how spatiotemporal rainfall variability affects the occurrence of pressurized conditions in a stormwater drainage network in the Richmond district of San Francisco, California. High-resolution bias-corrected radar rainfall fields for 24 recent storms were used as the independent variable of EPA-SWMM simulations. Model analyses indicate that the incidence of pressurized flow increases with storm intensity and is more sensitive to rainfall temporal variability than spatial variability. This research provides a reference for analyzing AMFI precursors in other networks and may have important implications for the improvement of stormwater infrastructures.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on January 1, 2026
Evaluating SWMM Modeling Performance for Rapid Flows on Tunnels with Geometric Discontinuities
The EPA’s StormWater Management Model (SWMM) has been applied across the globe for citywide stormwater modeling due to its robustness and versatility. Recent research indicated that SWMM, with proper setup, can be applied in the description of more dynamic flow conditions, such as rapid inflow conditions. However, stormwater systems often have geometric discontinuities that can pose challenges to SWMM model accuracy, and this issue is poorly explored in the current literature. The present work evaluates the performance of SWMM 5 in the context of a real-world stormwater tunnel with a geometric discontinuity. Various combinations of spatiotemporal discretization are systematically evaluated along with four pressurization algorithms, and results are benchmarked with another hydraulic model using tunnel inflow simulations. Results indicated that the pressurization algorithm has an important effect on SWMM’s accuracy in conditions of sudden diameter changes. From the tested pressurization algorithms, the original Preissmann slot algorithm was the option that yielded more representative results for a wider range of spatiotemporal discretizations. Regarding spatiotemporal discretization options, intermediate discretization, and time steps that lead to Courant numbers equal to one performed best. Interestingly, the traditional SWMM’s link-node approach also presented numerical instabilities despite having low continuity errors. Results indicated that although SWMM can be effective in simulating rapid inflow conditions in tunnels, situations with drastic geometric changes need to be carefully evaluated so that modeling results are representative.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2048607
- PAR ID:
- 10636809
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Society of Civil Engineers
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Hydraulic Engineering
- Volume:
- 151
- Issue:
- 1
- ISSN:
- 0733-9429
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The City of Columbus, Ohio is implementing a tunnel system to reduce the number of episodes of combined sewer overflows into the Scioto River. The tunnel systems provide relief to the existing Olentangy Scioto Interceptor Sewer. Two new tunnels being implemented are the OSIS Augmentation and Relief Sewer (OARS), in service since July 2017, and the Lower Olentangy Tunnel (LOT) that is planned to be in service in 2025. The performance of these tunnels in respect to high inflow conditions was investigated with the use of the HAST mixed flow model and the OpenFOAM CFD model to determine the magnitude of surges, the possibility of air pocket entrapment, air–water surging, and the consequences of uncontrolled air pocket releases through shafts. Inflows into the systems were obtained from a calibrated collection system SWMM model. Modeling results quantified surging in the tunnel dropshafts and their mitigation from built-in surge control chambers. HAST simulations also pointed to locations where air pockets could form. These results were used in OpenFOAM to determine the effects of uncontrolled air release through the shaft that links the two tunnels. It was shown that proper ventilation at the shaft will mitigate the growth of air phase pressure to damaging levels.more » « less
-
Green roof systems (GRs) provide a promising stormwater management strategy in highly urbanized areas when limited open space is available. Hydrological modeling can predict the ability of GRs to reduce runoff. This paper reviews three popular types of GR models with varying complexities, including water balance models, the U.S. EPA's Stormwater Management Model (SWMM), and Hydrus-1D. Developments and practical applications of these models are discussed, by detailing model parameter estimates, performance evaluations and application scopes. These three models are capable of replicating GR outflow. Water balance models have the smallest number of parameters (≤7) to estimate. Hydrus-1D requires substantial parameterization effort for soil hydraulic properties but can simulate unsaturated soil water flow processes. Although SWMM has a large number of parameters (>10), it can simulate water transport through the entire GR profile. In addition, SWMM GR models can be easily incorporated into SWMM's stormwater model framework, so it is widely used to simulate the watershed-scale effects of GR implementations. Four research gaps limiting GR model applications are identified and discussed: drainage mat flow simulations, soil characterization, evapotranspiration estimates, and scale effects of GRs. The literature documents promising results in GR simulations for rainfall events, however, a critical need remains for long-term monitoring and modeling of full-scale GR systems to allow interpretation of both internal (substrate) and external (meteorological characteristics) system effects on stormwater management.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)As climate change alters precipitation patterns, stakeholders will need to understand how performance of green stormwater infrastructure (GSI) could change in response. As an alternative to using on-site monitoring, which may not always feasible, we propose that changes in performance could be tracked using annual rainfall measures (e.g., maximum daily rainfall per year). We estimated performance of GSI in 17 U.S. cities using rainfall measures by establishing linear relationships with specific performance metrics (e.g., frequency of discharge). Prediction accuracy was evaluated in 2 cities for the period 2020 to 2060 by comparing performance predicted from rainfall trends from regional climate models (RCMs) with simulated performance in SWMM using the same RCMs as input. Findings suggest that tracking rainfall measures can provide insight into the hydrologic performance of green infrastructure by predicting the direction of change, as well as, the magnitude within 25% to 50% percent change.more » « less
-
A combined sewer system (CSS) collects rainwater runoff, domestic sewage, and industrial wastewater in the same pipe. The volume of wastewater can sometimes exceed the system capacity during heavy rainfall events. When this occurs, untreated stormwater and wastewater discharge directly to nearby streams, rivers, and other water bodies. This would threaten public health and the environment, contributing to drinking water contamination and other concerns. Minimizing sewer overflows requires an optimization method that can provide an optimal sequence of decision variables at control gates. Conventional strategies use classical optimization algorithms, such as genetic algorithms and pattern search, to find the optimal sequence of decision variables. However, these conventional frameworks are very time-consuming, and it is almost impossible to achieve near real-time optimal control. This paper presents a faster optimization framework by using a new optimal control tool: reinforcement learning. The environment (flow modeler) used in this paper is the numerical model: Environmental Protection Agency’s Storm Water Management Model (EPA SWMM) to ensure the accuracy of environment response. The reward function is constructed based on the calculated water depth and overflow rate from SWMM. The process keeps minimizing the reward function to obtain the optimal flow release sequence at each controlled orifice gate. The combined sewer system (CSS) of the Puritan-Fenkell 7-mile facility in Detroit, MI, is chosen as the case study.more » « less
