An official website of the United States government
Abstract Studying how genetic variation is structured across space, and how it relates to divergence in phenotypic traits relevant to reproductive isolation, is important for our overall understanding of the speciation process. We used reduced-representation genomic data (ddRAD-seq) to examine patterns of genetic variation across the full distribution of an Andean warbler species complex (Myioborus ornatus–melanocephalus), which includes a known hybrid zone between two strikingly different plumage forms. Genetic structure largely reflects geographic variation in head plumage, some of which corresponds to major topographic barriers in the Andes. We also found evidence of isolation by distance shaping genetic patterns across the group’s broad latitudinal range. We found thatchrysopsandbairdi, two taxa with marked plumage differences that have a known hybrid zone, were characterized by low overall genetic divergence. Based on our cline analyses of both plumage and genomic hybrid indices, this hybrid zone extends for approximately 250 km, where advanced generation hybrids are likely most common. We also identified a slight difference in the centers of the plumage and genomic clines, potentially suggesting the asymmetric introgression ofchrysops-like plumage traits. By studying genetic variation in a phenotypically complex group distributed across a topographically complex area, which includes a hybrid zone, we were able to show how both geographic features and potentially sexually selected plumage traits may play a role in species formation in tropical mountains
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on August 15, 2026
Diversification and divergence in Myioborus warblers: insights into evolutionary relationships and plumage genetics
Genomic data can provide valuable insights into the evolutionary history of rapidly diversifying groups and the genetic basis of phenotypic differences among lineages. We used whole-genome sequencing of the warbler genus Myioborus to investigate dynamics of its recent diversification in Neotropical mountains. We found that mitochondrial and UCE phylogenies are mostly, but not fully, concordant, and we found phylogenetic support for a pattern of north-to-south and low-to-high elevation colonization in the genus. Within the ornatus-melanocephalus complex, which showed topological incongruence between our phylogenies, we found that genetic structure generally coincides with geographic variation in plumage, although three subspecies with striking plumage differences exhibit low mitochondrial divergence. The hybridizing taxa M. o. chrysops and M. m. bairdi show very shallow genomic differentiation, with marked peaks of divergence. Most of these are shared with other parulid warbler pairs, pointing to broad genomic features, like recombination rate, as the processes shaping these regions. However, other highly differentiated regions were unique to Myioborus, including one containing the gene CCDC91, which is associated with melanin-based plumage differences in several other birds. Lastly, we found higher levels of differentiation on the Z chromosome relative to autosomes, including two putative chromosomal inversions. Together, these results highlight the interplay of deep ancestral divergence, recent hybridization, and shared genomic architecture in shaping the evolution of phenotypic and genomic diversity within Myioborus.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2232929
- PAR ID:
- 10646419
- Publisher / Repository:
- bioRxiv
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Mérot, Claire; Morlon, Hélène (Ed.)Abstract The Rufous-collared Sparrow (Zonotrichia capensis) shows phenotypic variation throughout its distribution. In particular, the Patagonian subspecies Z. c. australis is strikingly distinct from all other subspecies, lacking the black crown stripes that characterize the species, with a uniformly grey head and overall paler plumage. We sequenced whole genomes of 18 individuals (9 Z. c. australis and 9 from other subspecies from northern Argentina) to explore the genomic basis of these color differences and to investigate how they may have evolved. We detected a single ~465-kb divergence peak on chromosome 5 that contrasted with a background of low genomic differentiation and contains the suppression of tumorigenicity 5 (ST5) gene. ST5 regulates RAB9A, which is required for melanosome biogenesis and melanocyte pigmentation in mammals, making it a strong candidate gene for the melanic plumage polymorphism within Z. capensis. This genomic island of differentiation may have emerged because of selection acting on allopatric populations or against gene flow on populations in physical and genetic contact. Mitochondrial DNA indicated that Z. c. australis diverged from other subspecies ~400,000 years ago, suggesting a putative role of Pleistocene glaciations. Phenotypic differences are consistent with Gloger’s rule, which predicts lighter-colored individuals in colder and drier climates like that of Patagonia.more » « less
-
ABSTRACT Disentangling the drivers of genomic divergence during speciation is essential to our broader understanding of the generation of biological diversity. Genetic changes accumulate at variable rates across the genome as populations diverge, leading to heterogenous landscapes of genetic differentiation. The ‘islands of differentiation’ that characterise these landscapes harbour genetic signatures of the evolutionary processes that led to their formation, providing insight into the roles of these processes in adaptation and speciation. Here, we study swallows in the genusHirundoto investigate genomic landscapes of differentiation between species spanning a continuum of evolutionary divergence. Genomic differentiation spans a wide range of values (FST= 0.01–0.8) between species, with substantial heterogeneity in genome‐wide patterns. Genomic landscapes are strongly correlated among species (ρ= 0.46–0.99), both at shallow and deep evolutionary timescales, with broad evidence for the role of linked selection together with recombination rate in shaping genomic differentiation. Further dissection of genomic islands reveals patterns consistent with a model of ‘recurrent selection’, wherein differentiation increases due to selection in the same genomic regions in ancestral and descendant populations. Finally, we use measures of the site frequency spectrum to differentiate between alternative forms of selection, providing evidence that genetic hitchhiking due to positive selection has contributed substantially to genomic divergence. Our results demonstrate the pervasive role of recurrent linked selection in shaping genomic divergence despite a history of gene flow and underscore the importance of non‐neutral evolutionary processes in predictive frameworks for genomic divergence in speciation genomics studies.more » « less
-
Payseur, Bret (Ed.)Secondary contact between closely related taxa represents a “moment of truth” for speciation—an opportunity to test the efficacy of reproductive isolation that evolved in allopatry and to identify the genetic, behavioral, and/or ecological barriers that separate species in sympatry. Sex chromosomes are known to rapidly accumulate differences between species, an effect that may be exacerbated for neo-sex chromosomes that are transitioning from autosomal to sex-specific inheritance. Here we report that, in the Solomon Islands, two closely related bird species in the honeyeater family—Myzomela cardinalisandMyzomela tristrami—carry neo-sex chromosomes and have come into recent secondary contact after ~1.1 my of geographic isolation. Hybrids of the two species were first observed in sympatry ~100 years ago. To determine the genetic consequences of hybridization, we use population genomic analyses of individuals sampled in allopatry and in sympatry to characterize gene flow in the contact zone. Using genome-wide estimates of diversity, differentiation, and divergence, we find that the degree and direction of introgression varies dramatically across the genome. For sympatric birds, autosomal introgression is bidirectional, with phenotypic hybrids and phenotypic parentals of both species showing admixed ancestry. In other regions of the genome, however, the story is different. While introgression on the Z/neo-Z-linked sequence is limited, introgression of W/neo-W regions and mitochondrial sequence (mtDNA) is highly asymmetric, moving only from the invadingM.cardinalisto the residentM.tristrami. The recent hybridization between these species has thus enabled gene flow in some genomic regions but the interaction of admixture, asymmetric mate choice, and/or natural selection has led to the variation in the amount and direction of gene flow at sex-linked regions of the genome.more » « less
-
Abstract Incomplete speciation can be leveraged to associate phenotypes with genotypes, thus providing insights into the traits relevant to the reproductive isolation of diverging taxa. We investigate the genetic underpinnings of the phenotypic differences between Sporophila plumbea and Sporophila beltoni. Sporophila beltoni has only recently been described based, most notably, based on differences in bill coloration (yellow vs. black in S. plumbea). Both species are indistinguishable through mtDNA or reduced-representation genomic data, and even whole-genome sequencing revealed low genetic differentiation. Demographic reconstructions attribute this genetic homogeneity to gene flow, despite divergence in the order of millions of generations. We found a narrow hybrid zone in southern Brazil where genetically, yet not phenotypically, admixed individuals appear to be prevalent. Despite the overall low genetic differentiation, we identified 3 narrow peaks along the genome with highly differentiated SNPs. These regions harbor 6 genes, one of which is involved in pigmentation (EDN3) and is a candidate for controlling bill color. Within the outlier peaks, we found signatures of resistance to gene flow, as expected for islands of speciation. Our study shows how genes related to coloration traits are likely involved in generating prezygotic isolation and establishing species boundaries early in speciation.more » « less
