An official website of the United States government
This experimental project investigated the debris accumulation in front of structures during tsunamis (debris damming), which leads to an increase in the forces imposed by tsunami flow on structures. The study was conducted through the construction of a 1:20 geometric scale physical model. Tsunami-like waves were generated over an idealized slope and transported different shapes of multi-debris, representing shipping containers, over the flat test section to measure debris loadings on elevated column structures. The experiment optically measured the debris impact and damming process, along with the corresponding loads on the entire column structure using a Force Balance Plate and separately on an individual column in the front row using a load cell. This unique data set will help to understand the impact of various factors on debris-driven damming loads, including wave characteristics, specimen configurations, and debris shapes. This data will also help to develop and validate numerical models that predict the motion and dynamics of floating debris during extreme coastal events. This project is the outcome of “Collaborative Research: Experimental Quantification of Tsunami-driven Debris Damming on Structures” with collaborators from the University of Hawaii at Manoa, Louisiana State University, and Oregon State University.
more »
« less
Tsunami Debris Damming Drag Forces And Associated Coefficients On Elevated Coastal Structure Columns
Tsunami overland flow induces hydrodynamic loads on coastal structures and may transport various objects located within the inundation zone, which could become debris and exacerbate hydrodynamic loading. In the process of adopting “the first national, consensus-based standard for tsunami resilience” (Chock, 2016) in the form of ASCE 7-16 Chapter 6: Tsunami Loads and Effects, emphasis was placed on evaluating debris transport and impact forces. This is evidenced by the robust body of literature regarding physical model experiments of these processes and thorough design procedures for both load considerations in current structural engineering standards (ASCE, 2022). Debris damming forces, resultant of debris being transported and accumulating against structures, are less thoroughly studied, having only recently begun to transition from steady flow experiments to transient flow conditions representative of coastal inundation events. A recent pair of experiments bridges this gap, comparing debris damming via steady-state, subcritical flow conditions to that caused by a dam-break style hydraulic bore (Stolle et al., 2018). That paper aimed to study debris dam formation, stability, and loading as well as runup of the flow onto idealized structural columns. Another study varied debris quantity, orientation, and arrangement to determine the effect had on damming and impact loads (Shekhar et al., 2020), however neither compared findings to current standards. The experimental work presented herein represents initial findings of a multi-year experimental campaign to better understand the mechanisms that lead to debris damming and increased structural loading. This work builds upon previous studies by using larger scale debris elements, more numerous debris fields, and more trials to better model such a stochastic process as debris damming. Three different incident wave conditions also led to varied hydrodynamics at the column specimen. In later phases, this campaign will also investigate the debris damming consequences of heterogeneous debris, which more accurately represent highly variable debris fields observed in post-event site surveys (Nistor et al., 2017). This paper aims to compare experimental debris dam loading parameters to those in the current ASCE 7-22 standard (ASCE, 2022). Namely, evaluating conservatism of ASCE 7-22 design values for: overall drag force on buildings, minimum closure ratios used in load determination, and empirical rectilinear structure drag coefficients during both debris accumulation and quasi-steady debris damming phases.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10658776
- Publisher / Repository:
- TU Delft Open
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- CoastLab 2024: Physical Modelling in Coastal Engineering and Science
- ISSN:
- 2710-1509
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
During a tsunami or storm surge event, coastal infrastructure and ports are subject to a series of disparate physical hazards that can cause significant damage and loss of life. Among these, debris impact loading during inundation events is chaotic, complex, and thus far minimally understood, especially when considering the accumulation of individual debris into a large debris field. This work provides the results of a comprehensive experimental study of the impact and subsequent damming of chaotic debris fields, including more than 400 individual trials; this scope of this paper describes the experimental design and initial analysis of wave-driven debris-induced loading for select configurations. These data include both the impact phenomena and subsequent damming by debris accumulation and find strong correlation between increasing debris field density and high impact forces. High frequency impact forces and low frequency damming signals are considered via fast Fourier transform methods. Overall trends in wave-induced debris forcing from large debris fields are presented.more » « less
-
The complex dynamics of vertically separated flows pose a significant challenge when it comes to assessing the wind loads on multi-level structures, demanding a nuanced understanding of the intricate interplay between atmospheric conditions and architectural designs. Previous studies and wind loading standards provide insufficient guidance for designing wind pressures on multi-level buildings. The behavior of wind around perpendicularly attached surfaces is not quite similar to that of individual flat roofs or walls. When a body is composed of several surfaces with right or oblique angles, the separated flow from surfaces and their interactions will cause complex flow patterns around each surface. A wind tunnel experimental study was carried out on bluff bodies with attached flat plates and other adjacent bluff bodies with different heights to examine the wind-induced pressures on such complex shapes. Mean and peak pressure coefficients were measured to determine the flow interaction patterns and location of localized peak pressures. The results were compared to the Tokyo Polytechnic University Aerodynamic Database of isolated low-rise buildings without eaves. The research findings indicated that there was a noteworthy disparity between the minimum and maximum values and locations of peak pressures on both the wall and roof surfaces of the models used in this study, as compared to the results obtained by the Tokyo Polytechnic University. Moreover, the study conceivably pointed to the difference between the peak negative and positive pressure coefficient locations with the ASCE 7-22 wind loading zones. The peak suction zones were affected by the combined flows at perpendicular faces, and as a result, different wind load zones were obtained dissimilar to those introduced by ASCE 7-22. Wind loading standards may need to be modified to account for the wind pressures on complex building structures with an emphasis on the location of the peak negative pressure zones.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Inundation from storms like Hurricanes Katrina and Sandy, and the 2011 East Japan tsunami, have caused catastrophic damage to coastal communities. Prediction of surge, wave, and tsunami flow transformation over the built and natural environment is essential in determining survival and failure of near-coast structures. However, unlike earthquake and wind hazards, overland flow event loading and damage often vary strongly at a parcel scale in built-up coastal regions due to the influence of nearby structures and vegetation on hydrodynamic transformation. Additionally, overland flow hydrodynamics and loading are presently treated using a variety of simplified methods (e.g. bare earth method) which introduce significant uncertainty and/or bias. This study describes an extensive series of large-scale experiments to create a comprehensive dataset of detailed hydrodynamics and forces on an array of coastal structures (representing buildings of a community on a barrier island) subject to the variability of storm waves, surge, and tsunami, incorporating the effect of overland flow, 3D flow alteration due to near-structure shielding, vegetation, waterborne debris, and building damage.Recorded Presentation from the vICCE (YouTube Link): https://youtu.be/EDLiEK6b64Emore » « less
-
In current practice, debris-field impact loading for near-water structures is usually derived from (1) infrequent case histories, (2) simplified analytical equations, and (3) practitioner experience. Via advanced numerical simulation of tsunami-driven debris-field impacts at multiple scales and conditions, we are now forging a modeling approach to address a wider range of scenarios. Broadened cases are characterized, with chaotic natures expressed stochastically. The analytical tools have the potential to strengthen the basis of ASCE 7 guidelines and to encompass events not yet described in the code.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.59490/coastlab.2024.732
