Search for: All records

We present the serendipitous discovery of an overdensity of submillimeter galaxies in the field of SDSS J0909-0108, a massive z ∼ 0.7 post-starburst galaxy from the SQuIGGLE survey. Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations at 870 μm and 2mm reveal six galaxies within a 35" region with flux ratios consistent with emission from dust. Given the rarity of 870 μm sources and the small field-of-view of ALMA, we speculate that some of these sources are physically associated. None of the sources are at the same redshift as the post-starburst, and four do not have spectroscopic redshifts. We suggest that follow-up optical and/or ALMA observations be carried out to measure redshifts for the galaxies in this potential protocluster environment. 

Many poststarburst galaxies at z ∼ 0.7 have been shown to retain substantial molecular gas reservoirs yet host low ongoing star formation, suggesting that the remaining gas may be inefficient at forming stars during the early postburst phase. We present new Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array CO(5-4) observations of nine gas-rich poststarburst galaxies at z ~ 0.7 from the Studying Quenching in Intermediate-z Galaxies: Gas, anguLar momentum, and Evolution (SQuIGGLE) survey, providing a view of the molecular gas excitation in these systems. Combined with existing CO(2-1) data, we detect CO(5─4) in eight out of nine targets and find that most have moderate CO excitation with r52 = L'CO(5−4)/L'CO(2−1) ~ 0.1−0.3 . These systems show no clear trend between r52 and either total or surface-density of star formation. Specifically, all objects have ΣSFR ∼ 0.01─1 M⊙ yr−1 kpc−2, consistent with compact, modest star formation, even when allowing for buried activity, as these galaxies decline from their peak. One object, J1448+1010, which has clear optical, mid-infrared, and radio indicators of an active galactic nucleus, is an outlier with r52 ~ 0.6; its elevated excitation likely requires significant nonstellar heating, with a contribution from potentially obscured star formation. Together, most gas-rich SQuIGGLE poststarbursts have moderately excited molecular gas alongside little to modest star-forming activity, indicating that the remaining gas hosts relatively suppressed star formation efficiencies instead of strong buried starburst activity. 

The quenching of star formation is a crucial phase in galaxy evolution. Although feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN) has been proposed as a key driver of this transition, the lack of strong AGN in nearby quenching galaxies raises questions about its effectiveness. In this study, we investigate AGN activity in post-starburst galaxies (PSBs), star-forming galaxies (SFGs), and quiescent galaxies (QGs) at z < 0.2, using multiwavelength data from eROSITA Final Equatorial Depth Survey (X-ray), Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (mid-infrared), and Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty cm (radio). We assess AGN incidence and strength across different stages and apply stacking techniques to undetected galaxies to recover average AGN properties. Comparisons between observed luminosity and that expected from star formation (L_obs / L_SF) show that PSBs are consistent with star formation dominating their radio and X-ray emission. Although PSBs exhibit a mid-infrared (MIR) AGN incidence rate twice that of SFGs, their estimated AGN luminosities are small compared to those of MIR AGN in the literature. PSBs overall do not display significantly enhanced AGN emission relative to mass- and redshift-matched SFGs and QGs. While the presence of obscured, low-luminosity AGN in PSBs cannot be excluded, such AGN, if present, could be fueled by residual gas from the preceding starburst and may not play a dominant role in quenching. Our findings suggest that the role of AGN in quenching at low redshift is more subtle than violently removing the gas—the feedback is likely more “preventive” than “ejective.” 

Abstract: Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array observations have shown that candidate “post-starburst” galaxies (PSBs) at z~0.6 can retain significant molecular gas reservoirs. These results would imply that—unlike many model predictions—galaxies can shut down their star formation before their cold gas reservoirs are depleted. However, these studies inferred star formation rates (SFRs) either from [OII] line fluxes or from spectral energy distribution (SED) modeling and could have missed large dust-obscured contributions to the SFRs. In this study, we present Keck/NIRES observations of 13 massive (M_* >= 10^11M_⊙) PSBs, which allow us to estimate Hα SFRs in these gas-rich PSBs. We confirm the previously inferred low SFRs for the majority of the sample: 11/13 targets show clear Hα absorption, with minimal infilling indicating dust-corrected SFRs of <4.1Msun/yr. These SFRs are notably low given the large H2 reservoirs (∼(1–5) × 10^10Msun) present in 5/13 of these galaxies, placing them significantly offset from star-forming galaxies on the Kennicutt–Schmidt relation for star-forming galaxies. The [NII]/Hα ratios of all 13 PSBs imply contributions from non-star-forming ionization mechanisms (e.g., active galactic nuclei, shocks, or hot evolved stars) to their Hα emission, suggesting that even these low ongoing SFRs may be overestimated. These low Hα SFRs, dust corrected using Av estimates from SED fitting, confirm that these galaxies are very likely quiescent and, thus, that galaxies can quench before their cold gas reservoirs are fully depleted. 

Observational and theoretical studies have long held that rapid gas consumption in starbursts is responsible for the formation of the most massive quiescent galaxies at high redshift. However, studies of recently quenched “post-starburst” galaxies have discovered that a number of them are surprisingly luminous in CO, challenging this assumption. We present deep Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array CO(2–1) observations of 50 massive (log(M⋆/M⊙)∼11.2) post-starburst galaxies from the SQuIGGLE sample at z ∼ 0.7. We detect a large fraction (27/50) of the galaxies in CO(2–1). We perform new spectral energy distribution (SED) fits incorporating mid- and far-IR photometry to measure the star formation rates (SFRs) and histories that can reproduce both the rest-optical and dust properties of these galaxies. We find that the CO luminosity correlates with the age of the recent starburst, suggesting a gas-removal timescale of ≲150 Myr, an order of magnitude shorter than is implied by their SFRs under standard birth cloud dust assumptions. We find that while allowing for significantly more attenuation in birth clouds can raise SFRs by ∼0.5 dex, for almost all galaxies, it is neither required to fit the observed IR SED, nor is it sufficient to explain the observed depletion trend. Even the combination of significant buried star formation and ULIRG-like α_CO is not enough to explain this decay in CO luminosity. Furthermore, there is no strong evidence to support either of those modifications to the depletion time. Therefore, it remains a distinct possibility that the age–CO luminosity trend should not be interpreted as an evolutionary sequence, and that gas-rich SQuIGGLE galaxies will soon rejuvenate. 

The active suppression of star formation in galaxies is critical for preventing the growth of overly massive systems and explaining the formation of present-day elliptical galaxies. We present a high-resolution, spatially resolved, multiwavelength study of two z ∼ 0.7 massive post-starburst galaxies, SDSS J1448+1010 and SDSS J2258+2313, from the Studying Quenching in Intermediate-z Galaxies: Gas, anguLar momentum, and Evolution (SQuIGGLE) survey, providing new insights into the role of mergers in driving quenching. Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array CO(2–1) observations show that both galaxies removed ∼50% of their molecular gas into extended tidal tails, spanning up to 65 kpc, following recent mergers. Hubble Space Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 imaging and grism spectroscopy show that while SDSS J1448+1010 exhibits Hα emission in its northern tidal tail consistent with ongoing star formation, SDSS J2258+2313 lacks detectable star-forming activity outside the central galaxy. Very Large Array 6 GHz continuum data reveal compact radio emission in SDSS J2258+2313, while SDSS J1448+1010 hosts small radio jets indicative of active galactic nucleus activity. Both galaxies retain substantial molecular gas reservoirs in their central regions, which appear more turbulent than “normal” star-forming galaxies, likely contributing to the observed low star formation rates in the hosts. Despite the similarities in their cold gas content and tidal features, the galaxies are distinct from each other in their star formation, gas–star alignment, and radio morphology, highlighting the complexity of tidal gas removal as a quenching mechanism at intermediate redshifts. 

Recent observations at low redshift have revealed that some post-starburst galaxies retain significant molecular gas reservoirs despite low ongoing star formation rates, challenging most theoretical predictions that rely on heating or expelling gas reservoirs to shut down star formation. To test whether this finding holds during the peak epoch of quenching, here we present Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array CO(2–1) observations of five spectroscopically confirmed massive post-starburst galaxies at z~ 1.4 from the HeavyMetal survey. While four galaxies are undetected in CO emission, we detect MH2 ∼ 10^9.7 M⊙ of molecular gas in one system. The detected system is a close pair of two massive (M_star = 10^11.1−11.2 M⊙) post-starburst galaxies with no clear tidal features, likely caught in the early stages of a major merger. These results suggest that mergers may be a key factor in retaining molecular gas while simultaneously suppressing star formation in quenched galaxies at high redshift, possibly by driving increased turbulence that decreases star formation efficiency. Our nondetected galaxies have postburst ages >200 Myr, consistent with results at z < 1; however, our gas-rich post-starburst pair is significantly older than typical gas-rich quenched systems at low redshift. Our results highlight the importance of major mergers in shaping the cold gas content of quiescent galaxies during the peak epoch of quenching. 

Abstract We present Atacama Compact Array (ACA) Band-3 observations of the protocluster SPT2349−56, an extreme system hosting >10 ultraluminous infrared galaxies (ULIRGs;L_IR ≳  10¹²L_⊙) in a 200 kpc diameter region atz =  4.3, to study its integrated molecular gas content via CO(4–3) and the long-wavelength dust continuum. The ∼30 hr integration represents one of the longest exposures yet taken on a single pointing with the ACA 7 m. The low-resolution ACA data (21 $\stackrel{\text{″}}{.}$ 0  ×  12 $\stackrel{\text{″}}{.}$ 2) reveal a 75% excess CO(4–3) flux compared to the sum of individual sources detected in higher-resolution Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) data (1 $\stackrel{\text{″}}{.}$ 0  ×  0 $\stackrel{\text{″}}{.}$ 8). Our work also reveals a similar result by tapering the ALMA data to 10″. In contrast, the 3.2 mm dust continuum shows little discrepancy between ACA and ALMA. A single-dish [Cii] spectrum obtained by APEX/FLASH supports the ACA CO(4–3) result, revealing a large excess in [Cii] emission relative to ALMA. The missing flux is unlikely due to undetected faint sources but instead suggests that high-resolution ALMA observations might miss extended and low-surface-brightness gas. Such emission could originate from the circumgalactic medium or the preheated protointracluster medium (proto-ICM). If this molecular gas reservoir replenishes the star formation fuel, the overall depletion timescale will exceed 400 Myr, reducing the requirement for the simultaneous ULIRG activity in SPT2349−56. Our results highlight the role of an extended gas reservoir in sustaining a high star formation rate in SPT2349−56 and potentially establishing the ICM during the transition phase to a mature cluster. 

Abstract We present Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array observations of the [CI] 492 and 806 GHz fine-structure lines in 25 dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs) atz= 4.3 in the core of the SPT2349–56 protocluster. The protocluster galaxies exhibit a median $L_{\left[\text{C}\mathrm{I}\right](2-1)}^{\prime }/L_{\left[\text{C}\mathrm{I}\right](1-0)}^{\prime }$ ratio of 0.94, with an interquartile range of 0.81–1.24. These ratios are markedly different to those observed in DSFGs in the field (across a comparable redshift and 850μm flux density range), where the median is 0.55, with an interquartile range of 0.50–0.76, and we show that this difference is driven by an excess of [Ci](2–1) in the protocluster galaxies for a given 850μm flux density. Assuming local thermal equilibrium, we estimate gas excitation temperatures of $T_{\mathrm{ex}}=59.1_{-6.8}^{+8.1}$ K for our protocluster sample and $T_{\mathrm{ex}}=33.9_{-2.2}^{+2.4}$ K for the field sample. Our main interpretation of this result is that the protocluster galaxies have had their cold gas driven to their cores via close-by interactions within the dense environment, leading to an overall increase in the average gas density and excitation temperature, as well as an elevated [Ci](2–1) luminosity-to-far-infrared-luminosity ratio.