Search for: All records

Award ID contains: 1943082

Note: When clicking on a Digital Object Identifier (DOI) number, you will be taken to an external site maintained by the publisher. Some full text articles may not yet be available without a charge during the embargo (administrative interval).
What is a DOI Number?

Some links on this page may take you to non-federal websites. Their policies may differ from this site.

  1. Abstract Horseshoe crabs are an ancient lineage of aquatic chelicerate arthropods traditionally considered to be “living fossils” exhibiting limited morphological change throughout their evolution. This paradigm is challenged by the divergent morphologies of Paleozoic and Mesozoic xiphosurans in nonmarine environments, which show greater variation of prosomal carapace shape. Marine horseshoe crabs appear to exhibit a more conservative evolutionary history punctuated by marked increases in body size during the Carboniferous and Jurassic. However, interpretation of horseshoe crab evolutionary trends is complicated by uncertainty over whether the smaller Paleozoic species represent adults or juveniles. Here, we describe a diminutive 445-million-year-old horseshoe crab, Lunataspis gundersoni sp. nov., preserving details of ovarian structures in the prosoma. Unique among Xiphosura, the new species possesses an unusually prolongated prosoma, indicating early morphological variation within the group. However, the female reproductive system appears identical to that of extant Tachypleinae. Critically, the presence of eggs demonstrates that the specimens are adults and that horseshoe crabs were significantly smaller in size during the Paleozoic. Lunataspis gundersoni displays a mixture of divergent external and conserved internal anatomy that reveals mosaic evolutionary patterns and illustrates early morphological variation among marine Xiphosura. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Xiphosuran chelicerates, also known as horseshoe crabs, are a long-lived clade characterized by a highly distinctive morphology and are a classic example of supposed evolutionary stasis. One key feature of horseshoe crabs is the fusion of the opisthosomal segments into a single sclerite referred to as a thoracetron. There has been historical uncertainty as to whether the thoracetron originated once or multiple times within the clade. Here we review criteria for determining whether segments are fused and apply them to a broad census of taxa for which their ontogeny is known or the adult status of specimens can be reasonably asserted to explore the evolution of the thoracetron within a developmental framework. Our findings indicate that the thoracetron evolved once in the common ancestor to Xiphosura. However, subsequent independent loss of the thoracetron segment boundaries is identified and shown to be the result of heterochronic processes acting on a shared developmental pathway. The multiple cases of effacement of the thoracetron within Limuloidea are cases of peramorphically driven parallelism, while the effacement of the thoracetron in the pedomorphic Belinurina is a case of convergence. Xiphosurids therefore represent an interesting case study for recognizing parallelism and convergence on the same structure within closely related lineages. We also demonstrate that somite VII has been incorporated into the prosoma multiple times within the chelicerate lineage, which has implications for interpreting the ground pattern of the group. 
    more » « less
  3. The burgeoning field of phylogenetic paleoecology combines paleoecological data with hypotheses of phylogenetic relationships to tease apart the roles that ecology and relatedness both play in the evolution and function of an organism. The purpose of this review is to make phylogenetic paleontology more accessible to a wider array of scientists and attract new researchers to the discipline. Herein, we use recently published analyses of a diverse array of fossil animals (e.g., arthropods, echinoderms, and carnivorans) to better illustrate the breadth of research questions that can be studied using phylogenetic paleoecology. Phylogenetic paleoecology has been used to discern drivers of morphological change and variations in evolutionary rates, along with the relationship between phylogeny, biogeography, and ecology. Additional avenues of research could focus on modularity and mosaicism in evolution, as well as the impact of mass extinctions and adaptive radiations. By encouraging a greater diversity of scientific backgrounds and plurality of thought, and by incorporating new perspectives from different areas of both geology and biology, the field of phylogenetic paleoecology will lead to the consideration of new questions, avenues, and possibilities that would otherwise go unexplored. 
    more » « less
    Free, publicly-accessible full text available May 29, 2027
  4. Free, publicly-accessible full text available November 19, 2026
  5. Trilobites are an extinct group of arthropods that are often preserved into the modern day through the fossilization of their cuticle, or exoskeleton, which can hold a wealth of information about their biology and environment. An understanding of the original and diagenetic structures of the trilobite cuticle is necessary to derive information about their exoskeletal morphology, as well as the chemistry of their depositional environment. Here, methods for analyzing trilobite cuticle have been refined, utilizing different techniques to gain a full picture of their structure and taphonomy. Petrographic thin sections were cut from two Kaskia sp. pygidia from different localities to better understand how original structures may be altered post deposition. These thin sections were observed at three thicknesses, to see if sections thinner than the standard 30 μm revealed more information. The trilobites from one locality were found to be recrystallized, while those from the other preserved much of the original cuticle. The evidence for this was best observed using the standard 30 μm thin sections. SEM analysis of the surface cuticle was also performed, reconsidering previous notions about original and diagenetic surface structures. Previous claims about surface taphonomy were called into question, as marks left by a bamboo dowel, not visible to the naked eye, appeared similar under SEM to textures previously described as original. Dendritic structures were also determined to be unreliable for determining the extent to which a trilobite cuticle has been altered. After observing physical changes that occur with diagenesis, two non destructive elemental mapping techniques, μ-XRF and FESEM-EDS, were compared in trilobites from both localities, to determine which method can most efficiently detect trace elements, and to see if differences in elemental composition were observable between well preserved and recrystallized cuticles. μ-XRF detected trace elements more effectively than FESEM-EDS, though no difference was observed between well preserved and altered cuticles when using either method. More work needs to be done on trilobite cuticles from other sites, as different depositional and diagenetic environments will likely impact the visible structure of the cuticles in different ways. Different species of trilobites from different time periods and paleoenvironments may also differ from those studied here, requiring further analysis. 
    more » « less
  6. Horseshoe crabs are an ancient lineage with an evolutionary history stretching back 450 million years and are generally considered to be examples of ‘living fossils’ exhibiting slow rates of evolution. Despite this reputation, relatively little is known of the early evolution of the group, with only two species described from the Ordovician and a subsequent 80-million-year gap in their fossil record until xiphosurids appear in the Late Devonian. Furthermore, all described Ordovician species are assigned to a single genus, with their close phylogenetic relatedness rendering it unclear whether their morphology is representative of the horseshoe crab ground pattern or an independently derived condition. Here, a new species of horseshoe crab is described from the Silurian of Indiana, USA. The new species bridges the temporal gap in the xiphosuran fossil record and has an overall morphology similar to that of the Ordovician taxa. These new data provide critical information on the ancestral morphology of horseshoe crabs, showing that xiphosurids evolved from forms with a fused thoracetron exhibiting axial segment boundaries, and demonstrate the persistence of basal Xiphosura into the Silurian. Laser-stimulated fluorescence is also shown to be an effective method for studying and imaging arthropod fossils exhibiting challenging preservation. 
    more » « less
  7. Understanding how the mechanisms that result in the development of new morphologies act is fundamental to exploring how evolutionoperates. Carcinosomatids are an unusual group of eurypterids which are characterized by the possession of a greatly expanded,disc-like preabdomen along with relatively short prosomal appendages bearing well-developed spines. The ontogeny of this highlydistinctive group is revealed by a species from the Silurian of Lesmahagow, Scotland. Specimens of Carcinosoma scorpioides ,originally considered to be three separate species, are here shown to represent at least three different ontogenetic stages rangingfrom early juveniles to adults. The earliest instars are markedly different from the adults, with a narrow preabdomen and elongatedprosomal appendages bearing moderately-sized spines, resulting in an overall appearance more reminiscent of the closely relatedmixopterids. The species first undergoes an expansion of the preabdomen while a relative reduction in the length of the prosomalappendages occurs in later instars. Other eurypterids exhibit a relative reduction in prosomal appendage length over ontogeny, withjuveniles having exceptionally long appendages, and also have a reduced prosomal armature which increases progressively duringgrowth. Eurypterids also show a positive allometric trend in preabdominal width early in their ontogeny. As such, Carcinosomascorpioides exhibits the same general developmental trends seen in other eurypterids, indicating that the ontogenetic trajectory ofeurypterids is generally conserved even amongst highly aberrant members of the clade. Furthermore, the preserved ontogeny of Carcinosoma scorpioides suggests that the unusual morphology of carcinosomatids developed due to peramorphic heterochronicprocesses whereby species develop exaggerated characteristics along the ontogenetic trajectory beyond the ancestral condition.Interestingly, despite these traits all being derived through peramorphy, mosaicism is evident in these heterochronic changes with thebody width increase occurring due to an increase in the rate of allometric change early on in ontogeny, while the reduced appendagelength and enlarged armature appears to be associated with an increase in body size and may be due to either a delay in reachingmaturity or an increase in the rate of growth later in ontogeny. 
    more » « less
  8. Developmental sequence polymorphism (variation in the timing of developmental events) is a neglected form of variation, and whetherit is correlated with other forms of variation, what role it plays in shaping a species’ evolutionary trajectory, and the overall extent towhich it characterizes and can be measured in extinct species remain open questions. Intraspecific variation constitutes the rawmaterial with which natural selection shapes phenotypes over the course of evolutionary history. A complete understanding of themechanisms underpinning biological evolution therefore requires detailed knowledge of the different forms of variation by whichspecies are characterized. Intraspecific developmental variation is an important source of phenotypic variety because minordifferences in developmental pathways can result in significant differences among adult phenotypes. The fossil record provides representatives of past species, the most direct evidence we have of evolutionary change across geologictime. However, one limitation of studying fossils is that they are generally uncommon and sample sizes are often small. Intraspecificvariation of any kind is therefore rarely quantified for fossil species. Here, continuous growth and discrete developmental timing datafor the well-studied and abundant trilobite species Elrathia kingii are presented. 116 specimens representing a range of growth stageswere photographed, measured, and coded for the expression of discrete developmental transformations. The fossils are reposited atthe AMNH and were collected from a narrow stratigraphic interval in the Wheeler Formation of west central Utah. Linearmeasurements were plotted in multivariate space to construct growth series, a common practice in trilobite ontogenetic research. Inaddition to this, however, phenotypic characters associated with abrupt developmental transformations are documented for eachspecimen and coded into the growth series to illustrate the timing of these transformations relative to continuous changes in size andshape. The result is a series of plots in which overlap in developmental character states represents variation. This novel techniqueindicates that sequence polymorphism is present in E. kingii and future work will use this result as a starting point for the application ofOntogenetic Sequence Analysis. 
    more » « less
  9. Eurypterids are a group of diverse chelicerates that first appeared during the Middle Ordovician and went extinct at the end of the Permian. Despite there being over 250 species of eurypterids known, the fossil record of eurypterids during the Ordovician is relatively sparce, comprising only 12 species representing the Megalograptidae, a ‘waeringopterid’ clade, Rhenopteridae, Onychopterellidae, Adelophthalmidae, and Eurypteroidea. As such, any new discoveries that elucidate on the early evolutionary history of the clade is noteworthy. Here, we report on early eurypterids from the Late Ordovician Big Hill Lagerstätte of Michigan’s Stonington Peninsula with preserved organic cuticle. Preliminary study of the available specimens indicates they may comprise two new species, each assignable to new genera within the Carcinosomatidae and Dolichopteridae, which would represent the oldest known occurrence of both clades. The new species may help elucidate on the morphological ground pattern of these clades and will be incorporated into existing phylogenetic frameworks. The eurypterids at Big Hill represent the oldest known eurypterid community for which more than a single species is known to co-occur. The Big Hill Lagerstätte is unique in preserving eurypterids, chasmataspidids, and xiphosurans all in association and as such affords an important window into the early evolution of euchelicerates. 
    more » « less