This paper presents a summary of the element test simulations (calibration simulations) submitted by 11 numerical simulation (prediction) teams that participated in the LEAP-2017 prediction exercise. A significant number of monotonic and cyclic triaxial (Vasko, An investigation into the behavior of Ottawa sand through monotonic and cyclic shear tests. Masters Thesis, The George Washington University, 2015; Vasko et al., LEAP-GWU-2015 Laboratory Tests. DesignSafe-CI, Dataset, 2018; El Ghoraiby et al., LEAP 2017: Soil characterization and element tests for Ottawa F65 sand. The George Washington University, Washington, DC, 2017; El Ghoraiby et al., LEAP-2017 GWU Laboratory Tests. DesignSafe-CI, Dataset, 2018; El Ghoraiby et al., Physical and mechanical properties of Ottawa F65 Sand. In B. Kutter et al. (Eds.), Model tests and numerical simulations of liquefaction and lateral spreading: LEAP-UCD-2017. New York: Springer, 2019) and direct simple shear tests (Bastidas, Ottawa F-65 Sand Characterization. PhD Dissertation, University of California, Davis, 2016) are available for Ottawa F-65 sand. The focus of this element test simulation exercise is to assess the performance of the constitutive models used by participating team in simulating the results of undrained stress-controlled cyclic triaxial tests on Ottawa F-65 sand for three different void ratios (El Ghoraiby et al., LEAP 2017: Soil characterization and element tests for Ottawa F65 sand. The George Washington University, Washington, DC, 2017; El Ghoraiby et al., LEAP-2017 GWU Laboratory Tests. DesignSafe-CI, Dataset, 2018; El Ghoraiby et al., Physical and mechanical properties of Ottawa F65 Sand. In B. Kutter et al. (Eds.), Model tests and numerical simulations of liquefaction and lateral spreading: LEAP-UCD-2017. New York: Springer, 2019). The simulated stress paths, stress-strain responses, and liquefaction strength curves show that majority of the models used in this exercise are able to provide a reasonably good match to liquefaction strength curves for the highest void ratio (0.585) but the differences between the simulations and experiments become larger for the lower void ratios (0.542 and 0.515).
more »
« less
On Suitability of Element Tests to Represent Constitutive Response of Liquefiable Soils
Calibration and validation of constitutive models and numerical modeling techniques used in analysis of soil liquefaction and its effects are often based on extensive comparisons with the results of element tests and centrifuge experiments. While good quality experimental data are available to understand and quantify the stress-strain-strength response of liquefiable soils in monotonic and cyclic drained/undrained element (triaxial and direct simple shear) tests, the results of these experiments are often less repeatable when the soil approaches liquefaction state and relatively large deviatoric strains suddenly develop within a few cycles of loading. The main source of these less repeatable patterns of soil behavior appears to be instability rather than the attainment of a state of material failure. The goal of this paper is to investigate the role of instability on the stress-strain response of liquefiable soils by using a critical state sand plasticity model that is enriched with an internal length scale representing the potential shear bands that may develop during monotonic or cyclic loading conditions. Through a series of numerical simulations, it is shown that the global stress-strain response measured in the element tests is a good approximation of the soil constitutive response before an unstable condition such as shear banding or liquefaction develops in the soil specimen.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1635524
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10036282
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Sixth Biot Conference on Poromechanics
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Constitutive relations used to describe the stress-strain-strength behavior of soils in cyclic loading are known to play a critical role on our ability to predict the response of geo-structures to seismic loading. The extent and intricacies of this role, however, are highly problem-dependent and often difficult to discern from the effects of other ingredients of a numerical simulation. Moreover, realistic assessments of constitutive models and numerical analysis techniques require detailed comparisons of their performances with reliable experimental observations. The experimental data that have been produced in the course of recent Liquefaction Experiments and Analysis Projects (LEAP-2015 and LEAP-2017) provide an opportunity for a more thorough assessment of the capabilities and limitations of constitutive models for sands over a wide range of strains. The LEAP experimental data along with a large number of cyclic element tests are used here to explore the performance of several constitutive models in numerical simulation of soil liquefaction and its effects on lateral spreading of mildly sloping grounds.more » « less
-
Constitutive relations used to describe the stress-strain-strength behavior of soils in cyclic loading are known to play a critical role on our ability to predict the response of geo-structures to seismic loading. The extent and intricacies of this role, however, are highly problem-dependent and often difficult to discern from the effects of other ingredients of a numerical simulation. Moreover, realistic assessments of constitutive models and numerical analysis techniques require detailed comparisons of their performances with reliable experimental observations. The experimental data that have been produced in the course of recent Liquefaction Experiments and Analysis Projects (LEAP-2015 and LEAP-2017) provide an opportunity for a more thorough assessment of the capabilities and limitations of constitutive models for sands over a wide range of strains. The LEAP experimental data along with a large number of cyclic element tests are used here to explore the performance of several constitutive models in numerical simulation of soil liquefaction and its effects on lateral spreading of mildly sloping grounds.more » « less
-
Static liquefaction has been associated with several failures of tailings storage facilities (TSFs) around the world. The failures result in devastating consequences for the environment and for civil infrastructure, as well as losses of human life. In this study, we present trends for the response of mine tailings to monotonic loading considering a) triaxial tests, b) bender element tests, and c) consolidation tests performed on mine tailings. These materials have a broad range of states, particle size distributions, and compressibility. The trends are evaluated in the context of static liquefaction using the critical state soil mechanics framework. In particular, we present trends for shear strength (residual and peak), state and brittleness soil indexes, instability stress ratios, and dilatancy. Besides, we highlight that mine tailings' mechanical properties reflect both the properties of the particles themselves and the relative proportions of different particle sizes. For instance, the observed trends suggest that particle gradation influences the small strain stiffness and dilatancy; the proportion of voids to the size of fine particles influences strength, and particle shape affects dilatancy. Finally, static liquefaction screening indexes are proposed based on the observed trendsmore » « less
-
Calibrations of the PM4Silt constitutive model are presented for two low-plasticity fine-grained soils that exhibit significantly different cyclic loading be-haviors. The PM4Silt model is a stress-ratio controlled, critical state compatible, bounding surface plasticity model that was recently developed for representing low-plasticity silts and clays in geotechnical earthquake engineering applications. The low-plasticity clayey silt and silty clay examined herein were reconstituted mixtures of silica silt and kaolin with plasticity indices (PIs) of 6 and 20. Un-drained monotonic and undrained cyclic direct simple shear (DSS) tests were per-formed on normally consolidated, slurry deposited specimens. Calibration of the PM4Silt model was based on the monotonic and cyclic DSS test data, plus em-pirical relationships for strain-dependent secant shear moduli and equivalent damping ratios. The calibration process and performance of the PM4Silt constitu-tive model are described for each soil. The results illustrate that PM4Silt is capa-ble of reasonably approximating a range of monotonic and cyclic loading behav-iors important to many earthquake engineering applications and is relatively easy to calibrate.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/9780784480779.227
