An official website of the United States government
PremiseRecent advances in generating large‐scale phylogenies enable broad‐scale estimation of species diversification. These now common approaches typically are characterized by (1) incomplete species coverage without explicit sampling methodologies and/or (2) sparse backbone representation, and usually rely on presumed phylogenetic placements to account for species without molecular data. We used empirical examples to examine the effects of incomplete sampling on diversification estimation and provide constructive suggestions to ecologists and evolutionary biologists based on those results. MethodsWe used a supermatrix for rosids and one well‐sampled subclade (Cucurbitaceae) as empirical case studies. We compared results using these large phylogenies with those based on a previously inferred, smaller supermatrix and on a synthetic tree resource with complete taxonomic coverage. Finally, we simulated random and representative taxon sampling and explored the impact of sampling on three commonly used methods, both parametric (RPANDA and BAMM) and semiparametric (DR). ResultsWe found that the impact of sampling on diversification estimates was idiosyncratic and often strong. Compared to full empirical sampling, representative and random sampling schemes either depressed or inflated speciation rates, depending on methods and sampling schemes. No method was entirely robust to poor sampling, but BAMM was least sensitive to moderate levels of missing taxa. ConclusionsWe suggest caution against uncritical modeling of missing taxa using taxonomic data for poorly sampled trees and in the use of summary backbone trees and other data sets with high representative bias, and we stress the importance of explicit sampling methodologies in macroevolutionary studies.
more »
« less
Estimating diversification rates for higher taxa: BAMM can give problematic estimates of rates and rate shifts: ESTIMATING DIVERSIFICATION RATES
- Award ID(s):
- 1655690
- PAR ID:
- 10047124
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley-Blackwell
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Evolution
- Volume:
- 72
- Issue:
- 1
- ISSN:
- 0014-3820
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 39 to 53
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
As a part of the Scientific Committee on Oceanographic Research (SCOR) Working Group #160 “Analyzing ocean turbulence observations to quantify mixing” (ATOMIX), we have developed recommendations on best practices for estimating the rate of dissipation of kinetic energy,ε, from measurements of turbulence shear using shear probes. The recommendations provided here are platform-independent and cover the conceivable range of dissipation rates in the ocean, seas, and other natural waters. They are applicable to commonly deployed platforms that include vertical profilers, fixed and moored instruments, towed profilers, submarines, self-propelled ocean gliders, and other autonomous underwater vehicles. The procedure for preparing the shear data for spectral estimation is discussed in detail, as are the quality control metrics that should accompany each estimate ofε. The methods are illustrated using a high-quality ‘benchmark’ dataset, while potential pitfalls are demonstrated with a second dataset containing common faults.more » « less
-
Many processes in nature such as conformal changes in biomolecules and clusters of interacting particles, genetic switches, mechanical or electromechanical oscillators with added noise, and many others are modeled using stochastic differential equations with small white noise. The study of rare transitions between metastable states in such systems is of great interest and importance. The direct simulation of rare transitions is difficult due to long waiting times. Transition path theory is a mathematical framework for the quantitative description of rare events. Its crucial component is the committor function, the solution to a boundary value problem for the backward Kolmogorov equation. The key fact exploited in this work is that the optimal controller constructed from the committor leads to the generation of transition trajectories exclusively. We prove this fact for a broad class of stochastic differential equations. Moreover, we demonstrate that the committor computed for a dimensionally reduced system and then lifted to the original phase space still allows us to construct an effective controller and estimate the transition rate with reasonable accuracy. Furthermore, we propose an all-the- way-through scheme for computing the committor via neural networks, sampling the transition trajectories, and estimating the transition rate without meshing the space. We apply the proposed methodology to four test problems: the overdamped Langevin dynamics with Mueller’s potential and the rugged Mueller potential in 10D, the noisy bistable Duffing oscillator, and Lennard-Jones-7 in 2D.more » « less
