skip to main content

Title: Image-Based Closed-Loop Control of Aerosol Jet Printing Using Classical Control Methods
Aerosol jet printing (AJP) is a complex process for additive electronics that is often unstable. To overcome this instability, observation while printing and control of the printing process using image-based monitoring is demonstrated. This monitoring is validated against images taken after the print and shown highly correlated and useful for the determination of printed linewidth. These images and the observed linewidth are used as input for closed-loop control of the printing process, with print speed changed in response to changes in the observed linewidth. Regression is used to relate these quantities and forms the basis of proportional and proportional integral control. Electrical test structures were printed with controlled and uncontrolled printing, and it was found that the control influenced their linewidth and electrical properties, giving improved uniformity in both size and electrical performance.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;  ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Extrusion-based bioprinting is the most common printing technology used in regenerative medicine. Despite recent technological advances, a pressing challenge for extrusion printing is low spatial resolution, which limits the functionality of printed constructs. One of the reasons for the low spatial resolution is a lack of process monitoring and control strategies to monitor fabrication and correct for print errors. Few research efforts implement process control and investigate the relationship between extrusion process parameters and printing fidelity. The lack of understanding between process parameters and print results ultimately limits the complexity of the possible structures. For example, fabrication of structures whose topologies vary spatially within the part is not possible without advanced process control. Here we enable fabrication of advanced spatially graded structures by implementing process monitoring and control strategies. We develop material models to better understand the relationship between process parameters and printing outcomes. We also present an experimental procedure to generate a process map that provides insight into the regions of the processing space that produce the desired extrusion features (e.g., width of the filament). After generation of a process map and material models, we implement a process monitoring and control strategy that measures the feature error and intelligently updates the process control inputs to reduce defects and improve spatial fidelity, which will lead to better functionality of the final construct. 
    more » « less
  2. Aerosol jet printing is a compelling technology for hybrid electronics, combining digital and noncontact patterning with broad materials compatibility, resolution as fine as ≈10 microns, and a high standoff distance of 1–5 mm. Despite its growing popularity in research environments, a robust process understanding and improved manufacturing control are essential for achieving the reliability and predictability required for broader adoption in advanced applications. Herein, recent developments in process monitoring using in‐line light scattering measurements are discussed, including their mechanistic foundations, experimental validation, relevance for process control and reliability, and value as a diagnostic tool for fundamental studies. Experimental measurements confirm the correlation between measured light scattering and deposition rate. Building on this platform, feedback from the real‐time measurement is coupled with printer software to support automated closed‐loop control via a simple proportional‐integral‐derivative software control loop. Combined with the utility of these measurements as a diagnostic to accelerate ink formulation and support fundamental process science experiments, this in‐line measurement provides a useful tool to improve print reliability with the potential to advance the adoption and capabilities of this method in conformal, flexible, and hybrid electronics applications.

    more » « less
  3. Additive Manufacturing (AM) is a crucial component of the smart manufacturing industry. In this paper, we propose an automated quality grading system for the fused deposition modeling (FDM) process as one of the major AM processes using a developed real-time deep convolutional neural network (CNN) model. The CNN model is trained offline using the images of the internal and surface defects in the layer-by-layer deposition of materials and tested online by studying the performance of detecting and grading the failure in AM process at different extruder speeds and temperatures. The model demonstrates an accuracy of 94% and specificity of 96%, as well as above 75% in measures of the F-score, the sensitivity, and the precision for classifying the quality of the AM process in five grades in real-time. The high-performance of the model could not be achieved with the values usually used for printing temperature and printing speed, only in addition with much higher values. The proposed online model adds an automated, consistent, and non-contact quality control signal to the AM process. The quality monitoring signal can also be used by the AM machine to stop the AM process and eliminate the sophisticated inspection of the printed parts for internal defects. The proposed quality control model ensures reliable parts with fewer quality hiccups while improving performance in time and material consumption. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Roll-to-Roll (R2R) printing techniques are promising for high-volume continuous production of substrate-based products, as opposed to sheet-to-sheet (S2S) approach suited for low-volume work. However, meeting the tight alignment tolerance requirements of additive multi-layer printed electronics specified by device resolution that is usually at micrometer scale has become a major challenge in R2R flexible electronics printing, preventing the fabrication technology from being transferred from conventional S2S to high-speed R2R production. Print registration in a R2R process is to align successive print patterns on the flexible substrate and to ensure quality printed devices through effective control of various process variables. Conventional model-based control methods require an accurate web-handling dynamic model and real-time tension measurements to ensure control laws can be faithfully derived. For complex multistage R2R systems, physics-based state-space models are difficult to derive, and real-time tension measurements are not always acquirable. In this paper, we present a novel data-driven model predictive control (DD-MPC) method to minimize the multistage register errors effectively. We show that the DD-MPC can handle multi-input and multi-output systems and obtain the plant model from sensor data via an Eigensystem Realization Algorithm (ERA) and Observer Kalman filter identification (OKID) system identification method. In addition, the proposed control scheme works for systems with partially measurable system states.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    In this work, a novel technique of inkjet printing e‐textiles with particle free reactive silver inks on knit structures is developed. The inkjet‐printed e‐textiles are highly conductive, with a sheet resistance of 0.09 Ω sq‐1, by means of controlling the number of print passes, annealing process, and textile structures. It is notable that the inkjet process allows textiles to maintain its inherent properties, including stretchability, flexibility, breathability, and fabric hand after printing process. This is achieved by formation of ultrathin silver layers surrounding individual fibers. The silver layers coated on fibers range from 250 nm to 2.5 µm, maintaining the size of interstices and flexibility of fibers. The annealing process, structure of fibers, and printed layers significantly influence the electrical conductivity of the patterned structures on textiles. Outstanding electrical conductivity and durability are demonstrated by optimizing print passes, controlling textile structures, and incorporating an in situ annealing process. The electrical resistance dependence on the strain rate of the textiles is examined, showing the ability to maintain electrical conductivity to retain light‐emitting diode use, stable more than 500 consecutive strain cycles. Most importantly, inkjet‐printed e‐textiles maintain their characteristic washability, breathability, and fabric hands for applications in wearable technology.

    more » « less