skip to main content

Title: Molecular simulations and understanding of antifouling zwitterionic polymer brushes
Zwitterionic materials are an important class of antifouling biomaterials for various applications. Despite such desirable antifouling properties, molecular-level understanding of the structure–property relationship associated with surface chemistry/topology/hydration and antifouling performance still remains to be elucidated. In this work, we computationally studied the packing structure, surface hydration, and antifouling property of three zwitterionic polymer brushes of poly(carboxybetaine methacrylate) (pCBMA), poly(sulfobetaine methacrylate) (pSBMA), and poly((2-(methacryloyloxy)ethyl)phosporylcoline) (pMPC) brushes and a hydrophilic PEG brush using a combination of molecular mechanics (MM), Monte Carlo (MC), molecular dynamics (MD), and steered MD (SMD) simulations. We for the first time determined the optimal packing structures of all polymer brushes from a wide variety of unit cells and chain orientations in a complex energy landscape. Under the optimal packing structures, MD simulations were further conducted to study the structure, dynamics, and orientation of water molecules and protein adsorption on the four polymer brushes, while SMD simulations to study the surface resistance of the polymer brushes to a protein. The collective results consistently revealed that the three zwitterionic brushes exhibited stronger interactions with water molecules and higher surface resistance to a protein than the PEG brush. It was concluded that both the carbon space length between zwitterionic groups and more » the nature of the anionic groups have a distinct effect on the antifouling performance, leading to the following antifouling ranking of pCBMA > pMPC > pSBMA. This work hopefully provides some structural insights into the design of new antifouling materials beyond traditional PEG-based antifouling materials. « less
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Award ID(s):
Publication Date:
Journal Name:
Journal of Materials Chemistry B
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Membrane separations are simple to operate, scalable, versatile, and energy efficient, but their broader use is curtailed by fouling or performance decline due to feed component depositing on the membrane surface. Surface functionalization with groups such as zwitterions can mitigate the adsorption of organic compounds, thus limiting fouling. This can be achieved by using surface-segregating copolymer additives during membrane manufacture, but there is a need for better understanding of how the polymer structure and architecture affect the effectiveness of these additives in improving membrane performance. In this study, we aim to explore the impact of the architecture of zwitterionic copolymer additives for polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF)-based membranes in fouling mitigation and ionic strength response. We prepared membranes from blends of PVDF with zwitterionic (ZI) copolymers with two different architectures, random and comb-shaped. As the random copolymer, we used poly(methyl methacrylate- random- sulfobetaine-2-vinyl pyridine) (PMMA- r -SB2VP) synthesized by free radical polymerization. The comb-shaped copolymer was synthesized by grafting SB2VP side-chains from a PVDF backbone by controlled radical polymerization. Membranes were fabricated from PVDF-copolymer blends containing up to 5 wt% ZI copolymer. Compared to the additive-free PVDF membrane, water permeance increased five-fold with 5 wt% addition of either copolymer. The comb copolymermore »additive led to better resistance to fouling by a saline oil-in-water emulsion and to simulated protein adsorption in Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) force measurements. The additive architecture had a significant influence on how membranes respond to changes in feed salinity, which is known to affect intra- and inter-molecular interactions in zwitterionic polymers. The random copolymer containing membrane showed a small and mostly reversible decrease in its permeance with salinity. In contrast, the comb copolymer-containing membrane underwent a conformational reorganization in saline solutions that leads to an irreversible permeance decrease, increased zwitterionic group content on the membrane surface, and smoother surface topography. The higher mobility of the zwitterionic groups in the comb-shaped architecture facilitates reorganization of the zwitterionic side-chains in response to ionic strength. Overall, this study establishes a new approach for developing highly fouling resistant membranes and defines how the architecture of a zwitterionic copolymer additive impacts the ionic strength response and fouling resistance of the membrane.« less
  2. Polyzwitterions (PZs) are promising materials for the antifouling in reverse osmosis and nanofiltration membrane technology for water treatment. Fundamental understanding of the structure and molecular interactions involving zwitterions is crucial to the optimal design of antifouling in membrane separation. Here we employ the umbrella sampling and molecular dynamics simulations to investigate molecular interactions between sulfobetaine/carboxybetaine zwitterions and different metal ions (Na+, K+ and Ca2+) in an aqueous solution. Simulation results show that these ions can form stable or meta-stable contact-ionic/solvent-shared-ionic pairs with zwitterions. Simulations at different grafting densities of PZ brush arrays reveal complex competitive association mechanisms, which are attributed to non-bonded electrostatic and van der Waals interactions among zwitterions, water molecules, and different metal ions in an aqueous environment. While the high-grafting density of the PZ brush array leads to a strong branch association between different zwitterions in water, this association is decreased at intermediate- and low-grafting densities due to strong zwitterion-water interactions. More importantly, adding ions into water at intermediate- and low-grafting densities further breaks down zwitterion branch association, resulting in a randomly oriented and dispersed branch configuration with significant swelling of the polymers. The degree of swelling depends on the type of ions, which further changes themore »surface electrostatic potential of PZ coatings.« less
  3. Simultaneous fouling and pore wetting of the membrane during membrane distillation (MD) is a major concern. In this work, an electrospun bilayer membrane for enhancing fouling and wetting resistance has been developed for treating hydraulic fracture-produced water (PW) by MD. These PWs can contain over 200,000 ppm total dissolved solids, organic compounds and surfactants. The membrane consists of an omniphobic surface that faces the permeate stream and a hydrophilic surface that faces the feed stream. The omniphobic surface was decorated by growing nanoparticles, followed by silanization to lower the surface energy. An epoxied zwitterionic polymer was grafted onto the membrane surface that faces the feed stream to form a tight antifouling hydration layer. The membrane was challenged with an aqueous NaCl solution containing sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), an ampholyte and crude oil. In the presence of SDS and crude oil, the membrane was stable and displayed salt rejection (>99.9%). Further, the decrease was much less than the base polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) electrospun membrane. The membranes were also challenged with actual PW. Our results highlight the importance of tuning the properties of the membrane surface that faces the feed and permeate streams in order to maximize membrane stability, flux and saltmore »rejection.« less
  4. This article reports a study of the effects of temperature on chaotropic anion (CA)-induced star-globule shape transitions in acidic water of three-arm star bottlebrushes composed of heterografted poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) and either poly(2-( N , N -dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (PDMAEMA) or poly(2-( N , N -diethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (PDEAEMA) (the brushes denoted as SMB-11 and -22, respectively). The brush polymers were synthesized by grafting alkyne-end-functionalized PEO and PDMAEMA or PDEAEMA onto an azide-bearing three-arm star backbone polymer using the copper( i )-catalyzed alkyne-azide cycloaddition reaction. Six anions were studied for their effects on the conformations of SMB-11 and -22 in acidic water: super CAs [Fe(CN) 6 ] 3− and [Fe(CN)6] 4− , moderate CAs PF 6 − and ClO 4 − , weak CA I − , and for comparison, kosmotropic anion SO 4 2− . At 25 °C, the addition of super and moderate CAs induced shape transitions of SMB-11 and -22 in pH 4.50 water from a starlike to a collapsed globular state stabilized by PEO side chains, which was driven by the ion pairing of protonated tertiary amine groups with CAs and the chaotropic effect. The shape changes occurred at much lower salt concentrations for super CAs than moderatemore »CAs. Upon heating from near room temperature to 70 °C, the super CA-collapsed brushes remained in the globular state, whereas the moderate CA-collapsed brushes underwent reversible globule-to-star shape transitions. The transition temperature increased with increasing salt concentration and was found to be higher for SMB-22 at the same salt concentration, presumably caused by the chaotropic effect. In contrast, I − and SO 4 2− had small effects on the conformations of SMB-11 and -22 at 25 °C in the studied salt concentration range, and only small and gradual size variations were observed upon heating to 70 °C. The results reported here may have potential uses in the design of stimuli-responsive systems for substance encapsulation and release.« less
  5. Obtaining insights into the adsorption and assembly of polyelectrolytes on chemically variable calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H) surfaces at the atomic scale has been a longstanding challenge in the chemistry of sustainable building materials and mineral–polymer interactions. Specifically, polycarboxylate ethers (PCEs) based on acrylate and poly(ethylene glycol) acrylate co-monomers are widely used to engineer the fluidity and hydration of cement and play an important role in the search for building materials with a lower carbon footprint. We report the first systematic study of PCE interactions with C-S-H surfaces at the molecular level using simulations at single molecule coverage and comparisons to experimental data. The mechanism of adsorption of the ionic polymers is a two-step process with initial cation adsorption that reverses the mineral surface charge, followed by adsorption of the polymer backbone through ion pairing. Free energies of binding are tunable in a wide range of 0 to −5 kcal mol −1 acrylate monomer. Polymer attraction increases for higher calcium-to-silicate ratio of the mineral and higher pH value in solution, and varies significantly with PCE composition. Thereby, successive negatively charged carboxylate groups along the backbone induce conformation strain and local detachment from the surface. Polyethylene glycol (PEG) side chains in themore »copolymers avoid contact with the C-S-H surfaces. The results guide in the rational design of adsorption strength and conformations of the comb copolymers, and lay the groundwork to explore the vast phase space of C-S-H compositions, surface morphologies, electrolyte conditions, and PCE films of variable surface coverage. Chemically similar minerals and copolymers also find applications in other structural and biomimetic materials.« less