An official website of the United States government
Abstract This study indicates the most effective combinations of scaffolding features within computer science and technology education settings. It addresses the research question, “What combinations of scaffolding characteristics, contexts of use, and assessment levels lead to medium and large effect sizes among college‐ and graduate‐level engineering and technology learners?” To do so, studies in which scaffolding led to a medium or large effect size within the context of technology and engineering education were identified within a scaffolding meta‐analysis data set. Next, two‐step cluster analysis in SPSS 24 was used to identify distinct groups of scaffolding attributes tailored to learning computer science at the undergraduate and graduate levels. Input variables included different scaffolding characteristics, the context of use, education level, and effect size. There was an eight‐cluster solution: five clusters were associated with large effect size, two with medium effect size, and one with both medium and large effect size. The three most important predictors were the context in which scaffolding was used, if and how scaffolding is customized over time and the decision rules that govern scaffolding change. Notably, highly effective scaffolding clusters are associated with most levels of each predictor.
more »
« less
Customized Scaffolding for Pre-service Teachers’ Problem-Solving in STEM
This paper explores customized scaffolding for pre-service teachers’ problem-solving in technology and engineering discipline. We used clustering analysis to discover natural groupings of scaffolding characteristics which were used in 144 computer-based scaffolding studies from the previous meta-analysis. We first selected input variables based on our research questions which include different scaffolding characteristics, context of use, education level, and effect size. Next, using a two-step clustering algorithm, we found four clusters based on the predominant scaffolding characteristics and profiled each cluster in terms of scaffolding characteristics and their context of use. The resulting cluster solutions indicate what combination of scaffolding characteristics used in different types of problem-centered learning context would be effective for pre-service teachers’ technology- and engineering-related problem-solving.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10178440
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Annual meeting program American Educational Research Association
- ISSN:
- 0163-9676
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
As artificial intelligence (AI) technology becomes increasingly pervasive, it is critical that students recognize AI and how it can be used. There is little research exploring learning capabilities of elementary students and the pedagogical supports necessary to facilitate students’ learning. PrimaryAI was created as a 3rd-5th grade AI curriculum that utilizes problem-based and immersive learning within an authentic life science context through four units that cover machine learning, computer vision, AI planning, and AI ethics. The curriculum was implemented by two upper elementary teachers during Spring 2022. Based on pre-test/post-test results, students were able to conceptualize AI concepts related to machine learning and computer vision. Results showed no significant differences based on gender. Teachers indicated the curriculum engaged students and provided teachers with sufficient scaffolding to teach the content in their classrooms. Recommendations for future implementations include greater alignment between the AI and life science concepts, alterations to the immersive problem-based learning environment, and enhanced connections to local animal populations.more » « less
-
Posing questions is a direct way for teachers to push students to verbalize justifications and make connections among ideas, but this skill is difficult to learn. We recruited four pre-service special education teachers to participate in a semester-long professional development focused on developing mathematics knowledge and asking questions, while concurrently providing 1-1 tutoring to students with learning disabilities. The pre-service teachers increased their frequency of questions overall and of questions that probed students’ thinking or explored mathematical relationships. The pre-service teachers also developed strategies for shifting among different types of questions when students struggled. The findings of this study illustrate the potential for pre-service teachers to develop questioning routines that challenge students while scaffolding their progress towards new understanding.more » « less
-
na (Ed.)As part of Next Generation of Science Standards (NGSS), in-service and pre-service teachers must become familiar with and learn to plan and implement engineering activities using one of the available engineering design models. In addition, pre-service teachers must teach this content to a growing multilingual students in elementary grades in the US. In this presentation, we describe how pre-service teachers use a modified 7-step engineering model to teach about sound to a group of rising 4th grade emergent bilingual students in a summer program in English and Spanish. Using the process of territorialization from assemblage theory, we explore how three pre-service teachers implemented engineering activities using culturally and linguistically sustaining pedagogies. We conclude with a series of recommendations to facilitate the process of territorialization for pre-service teachers in science/engineering education.more » « less
-
This study employed an ethnographic qualitative research approach to examine the experiences of Science, Technology, Engineering, or Math (STEM) faculty who participated in a supplementary mentoring network, the National Science Foundation Noyce Scholarship program, for STEM pre-service teachers. The findings highlight the ways in which mentoring programs can positively impact faculty and the preparation of STEM pre-service teachers.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
