skip to main content

Title: The effect of cooling during deformation on recrystallized grain-size piezometry
Abstract Most exposed middle- and lower-crustal shear zones experienced deformation while cooling. We investigated the effect of the strengthening associated with such cooling on differential stress estimates based on recrystallized grain size. Typical geologic ratios of temperature change per strain unit were applied in Griggs Rig (high pressure-temperature deformation apparatus) general shear experiments on quartzite with cooling rates of 2–10 °C/h from 900 °C to 800 °C, and a shear strain rate of ∼2 × 10−5 s−1. Comparisons between these “cooling-ramp” experiments and control experiments at constant temperatures of 800 °C and 900 °C indicated that recrystallized grain size did not keep pace with evolving stress. Mean recrystallized grain sizes of the cooling-ramp experiments were twice as large as expected from the final stresses of the experiments. The traditional approach to piezometry involves a routine assumption of a steady-state microstructure, and this would underestimate the final stress during the cooling-ramp experiments by ∼40%. Recrystallized grain size in the cooling-ramp experiments is a better indicator of the average stress of the experiments (shear strains ≥3). Due to the temperature sensitivity of recrystallization processes and rock strength, the results may underrepresent the effect of cooling in natural samples. Cooling-ramp experiments produced wider and more skewed grain-size distributions than control experiments, suggesting that analyses of grain-size distributions might be used to quantify the degree to which grain size departs from steady-state values due to cooling, and thereby provide more accurate constraints on final stress.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Page Range / eLocation ID:
531 to 535
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. SUMMARY The occurrence of plate tectonics on Earth is rooted in the physics of lithospheric ductile weakening and shear-localization. The pervasiveness of mylonites at lithospheric shear zones is a key piece of evidence that localization correlates with reduction in mineral grain size. Most lithospheric mylonites are polymineralic and the interaction between mineral phases, such as olivine and pyroxene, especially through Zener pinning, impedes normal grain growth while possibly enhancing grain damage, both of which facilitate grain size reduction and weakening, as evident in lab experiments and field observations. The efficacy of pinning, however, relies on the mineral phases being mixed and dispersed at the grain scale, where well-mixed states lead to greater mylonitization. To model grain mixing between different phases at the continuum scale, we previously developed a theory treating grain-scale processes as diffusion between phases, but driven by imposed compressive stresses acting on the boundary between phases. Here we present a new model for shearing rock that combines our theory for diffusive grain mixing, 2-D non-Newtonian flow and two-phase grain damage. The model geometry is designed specifically for comparison to torsional shear-deformation experiments. Deformation is either forced by constant velocity or constant stress boundary conditions. As the layer is deformed, mixing zones between different mineralogical units undergo enhanced grain size reduction and weakening, especially at high strains. For constant velocity boundary experiments, stress drops towards an initial piezometric plateau by a strain of around 4; this is also typical of monophase experiments for which this initial plateau is the final steady state stress. However, polyphase experiments can undergo a second large stress drop at strains of 10–20, and which is associated with enhanced phase mixing and resultant grain size reduction and weakening. Model calculations for polyphase media with grain mixing and damage capture the experimental behaviour when damage to the interface between phases is moderately slower or less efficient than damage to the grain boundaries. Other factors such as distribution and bulk fraction of the secondary phase, as well as grain-mixing diffusivity also influence the timing of the second stress drop. For constant stress boundary conditions, the strain rate increases during weakening and localization. For a monophase medium, there is theoretically one increase in strain rate to a piezometric steady state. But for the polyphase model, the strain rate undergoes a second abrupt increase, the timing for which is again controlled by interface damage and grain mixing. The evolution of heterogeneity through mixing and deformation, and that of grain size distributions also compare well to experimental observations. In total, the comparison of theory to deformation experiments provides a framework for guiding future experiments, scaling microstructural physics to geodynamic applications and demonstrates the importance of grain mixing and damage for the formation of plate tectonic boundaries. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    We performed deformation and grain growth experiments on natural olivine aggregates with olivine water contents (COH = 600 ± 300 H/106 Si) similar to upper mantle olivine, at 1000–1200°C and 1,400 ± 100 MPa confining pressure. Our experiments differ from published grain growth studies in that most were (1) conducted on natural olivine cores rather than hot‐pressed aggregates and (2) dynamically recrystallized prior to or during grain growth. We combine our results with similar experiments performed at 1200–1300°C and fit the data to a grain growth relationship, yielding a growth exponent (p) of 3.2, activation energy (EG) 620 ± 145 kJ mol1(570 ± 145 kJ mol1when accounting for the role of temperature on water content), activation volume (VG) ~5 × 10−6 m3mol1, and rate constant (k0) 1.8 × 103 mp s−1. OurEGis within uncertainty of that predicted for dislocation creep of wet olivine (E* = 480 ± 40 kJ mol−1). Grain size in strain rate‐stepping samples adjusted to the olivine piezometer within 1.3–7.9% strain. The active grain boundary migration processes during deformation and dynamic recrystallization affect the kinetics of postdeformation grain growth, as grain boundary migration driven by strain energy density (ρGBM) may delay the onset of grain growth driven by interfacial energy (γGBM). We compared our postdeformation grain growth rates with data from previously published hydrostatic annealing experiments on synthetic olivine. At geologic timescales, the growth rates are much slower than predicted by the existing wet olivine grain growth law.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Relationships between the recrystallized grain size and stress are investigated for experimentally deformed water‐added quartz aggregates. For stresses ≥100 MPa there is a variation in the measured recrystallized grain size for a given stress. This variation correlates with a change in thec‐axis fabric in general shear experiments, where samples with larger recrystallized grain sizes for a given stress have dominantly prism c‐axis fabrics and samples with smaller recrystallized grain sizes for a given stress have dominantly basal c‐axis fabrics. The dislocation creep flow law also changes at conditions where these twoc‐axis fabrics form (Tokle et al., 2019, Using the wattmeter model (Austin & Evans, 2007,, different piezometric relationships are quantified for samples that develop prism and basal c‐axis fabrics, respectively. The wattmeter model is sensitive to grain growth kinetics; a new grain growth law for quartz is formulated based on reanalysis of microstructures in samples from previous work. The activation enthalpies and water fugacity exponents for our grain growth law and dislocation creep flow laws are the same within error, suggesting the recrystallized grain size versus stress relationships are nearly independent of temperature and water fugacity, consistent with laboratory observations. The wattmeters successfully predict the recrystallized grain size versus stress relationships of all quartzite samples from experiments with added water. These results support the use and extrapolation of the wattmeter model for both experimental and geologic conditions to investigate the stress state and grain size evolution of quartz rich rocks.

    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    We present constraints on the hydration state and rheology of the lithospheric mantle beneath the North Anatolian fault zone (NAFZ). Peridotite xenoliths from the Biyikali and Çorlu volcanic centers record deformational microstructures consistent with shearing in a lithosphere‐scale transcurrent fault system. Analysis by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy indicates that nominally anhydrous phases retain some OH, but bulk rock concentrations are generally restricted to <50 ppm H2O by weight. From the rock microstructure, we determined differential stress magnitude and active deformation mechanism(s); combined with estimates of hydration state, we constrained the rheology. Recrystallized grain size piezometry shows that the mantle beneath the NAFZ sustained differential stresses of 10–20 MPa, largely independent of depth. The dominant deformation mechanism(s) change with depth; xenoliths extracted from shallower depths record evidence for grain size‐sensitive creep possibly in the presence of melt. At intermediate depths, both dislocation creep and grain size‐sensitive mechanisms were active, and we did not observe evidence for deformation in the presence of melt. The deepest samples were dominated by dislocation creep. The strong temperature sensitivity of creep mechanisms, combined with the low variability in differential stress, contributes to a stratified viscosity profile ranging from 1018 Pa s for the deepest samples to >1022 Pa s at shallower depths (assuming a melt‐free rheology). Although difficult to quantify from the rock record, melt likely reduced the viscosity of the shallow lithospheric mantle. Vertical stratification in viscosity beneath the NAFZ, the result of melt‐present deformation and/or transitions in the dominant deformation mechanism, has important consequences for the seismic cycle of strike‐slip fault systems.

    more » « less
  5. The southern Appalachian Inner Piedmont (IP) has been interpreted to represent a relict crustal escape flow system that was active during the Neoacadian (370-340 Ma) orogeny. Critical to the support of this hypothesis is the identification of both the high-temperature, rheologically weak “channel,” with crustal flow driven by relatively low differential stress, and the rheologically strong “buttress,” where deformation was driven by relatively high differential stress. Paleopiezometric analyses from southern Appalachian quartz mylonites, quartzites, and quartz-bearing pelitic rocks of the eastern Blue Ridge (EBR; buttress) and IP (channel) allow gradients of differential stress driving flow to be examined. Samples located along a transect in the EBR northwest of the Brevard fault zone (BFZ) are used to define gradients in differential stress and deformation temperatures in the proposed buttress. Preliminary results for these samples suggest that deformation temperature increased, and differential stress decreased during deformation approaching the BFZ from the northwest. Mechanisms of quartz recrystallization shift from minor grain boundary bulging and dominant subgrain rotation (SGR) in samples located away from the BFZ to dominant SGR and minor grain boundary migration (GBM) in samples in the immediate BFZ footwall. Recrystallized grain sizes in the EBR are, in almost all cases, less than 150 microns on the major axis of ellipses used to approximate grain size. In the proposed crustal channel, quartz-rich samples collected along a transect south of Rosman, NC in the Brevard and Brindle Creek thrust sheets of the IP show GBM and SGR as the dominant mechanisms of deformation, as well as a general increase in grain size into the “core” of the proposed crustal channel. Recrystallized grain sizes in the Piedmont away from the BFZ commonly exceed 500 microns. These preliminary results suggest increasing deformation temperatures and decreasing differential stresses from close to the BFZ into the Piedmont, which is consistent with increased cooling of the proposed channel proximal to the colder, stronger Blue Ridge. Ongoing piezometric analyses, combined with quartz c-axis thermometry and thermochronology, may provide additional evidence to better refine the hypothesized buttress-channel relationship. 
    more » « less