Extractive summarization is an important natural language processing approach used for document compression, improved reading comprehension, key phrase extraction, indexing, query set generation, and other analytics approaches. Extractive summarization has specific advantages over abstractive summarization in that it preserves style, specific text elements, and compound phrases that might be more directly associated with the text. In this article, the relative effectiveness of extractive summarization is considered on two widely different corpora: (1) a set of works of fiction (100 total, mainly novels) available from Project Gutenberg, and (2) a large set of news articles (3000) for which a ground truthed summarization (gold standard) is provided by the authors of the news articles. Both sets were evaluated using 5 different Python Sumy algorithms and compared to randomly-generated summarizations quantitatively. Two functional approaches to assessing the efficacy of summarization using a query set on both the original documents and their summaries, and using document classification on a 12-class set to compare among different summarization approaches, are introduced. The results, unsurprisingly, show considerable differences consistent with the different nature of these two data sets. The LSA and Luhn summarization approaches were most effective on the database of fiction, while all five summarization approaches were similarly effective on the database of articles. Overall, the Luhn approach was deemed the most generally relevant among those tested.
more »
« less
DocEng'19 Competition on Extractive Text Summarization
The DocEng’19 Competition on Extractive Text Summarization assessed the performance of two new and fourteen previously published extractive text sumarization methods. The competitors were evaluated using the CNN-Corpus, the largest test set available today for single document extractive summarization.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1842577
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10185296
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the ACM Symposium on Document Engineering
- Volume:
- 19
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1-2
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
This paper details the features and the methodology adopted in the construction of the CNN-corpus, a test corpus for single document extractive text summarization of news articles. The current version of the CNN-corpus encompasses 3,000 texts in English, and each of them has an abstractive and an extractive summary. The corpus allows quantitative and qualitative assessments of extractive summarization strategies.more » « less
-
Extractive text summarization aims at extract- ing the most representative sentences from a given document as its summary. To extract a good summary from a long text document, sen- tence embedding plays an important role. Re- cent studies have leveraged graph neural net- works to capture the inter-sentential relation- ship (e.g., the discourse graph) to learn con- textual sentence embedding. However, those approaches neither consider multiple types of inter-sentential relationships (e.g., semantic similarity & natural connection), nor model intra-sentential relationships (e.g, semantic & syntactic relationship among words). To ad- dress these problems, we propose a novel Mul- tiplex Graph Convolutional Network (Multi- GCN) to jointly model different types of rela- tionships among sentences and words. Based on Multi-GCN, we propose a Multiplex Graph Summarization (Multi-GraS) model for extrac- tive text summarization. Finally, we evaluate the proposed models on the CNN/DailyMail benchmark dataset to demonstrate the effec- tiveness of our method.more » « less
-
This paper details the development and features of the CNN-corpus in Spanish, possibly the largest test corpus for single document extractive text summarization in the Spanish language. Its current version encompasses 1,117 well-written texts in Spanish, each of them has an abstractive and an extractive summary. The development methodology adopted allows good-quality qualitative and quantitative assessments of summarization strategies for tools developed in the Spanish language.more » « less
-
For decades, research in natural language processing (NLP) has focused on summarization. Sequence-to-sequence models for abstractive summarization have been studied extensively, yet generated summaries commonly suffer from fabricated content, and are often found to be near-extractive. We argue that, to address these issues, summarizers need to acquire the co-references that form multiple types of relations over input sentences, e.g., 1-to-N, N-to-1, and N-to-N relations, since the structured knowledge for text usually appears on these relations. By allowing the decoder to pay different attention to the input sentences for the same entity at different generation states, the structured graph representations generate more informative summaries. In this paper, we propose a hierarchical graph attention networks (HGATs) for abstractive summarization with a topicsensitive PageRank augmented graph. Specifically, we utilize dual decoders, a sequential sentence decoder, and a graph-structured decoder (which are built hierarchically) to maintain the global context and local characteristics of entities, complementing each other. We further design a greedy heuristic to extract salient users’ comments while avoiding redundancy to drive a model to better capture entity interactions. Our experimental results show that our models produce significantly higher ROUGE scores than variants without graph-based attention on both SSECIF and CNN/Daily Mail (CNN/DM) datasets.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3342558.3351874
