An official website of the United States government
Data are becoming increasingly important in science and society, and thus data literacy is a vital asset to students as they prepare for careers in and outside science, technology, engineering, and mathematics and go on to lead productive lives. In this paper, we discuss why the strongest learning experiences surrounding data literacy may arise when students are given opportunities to work with authentic data from scientific research. First, we explore the overlap between the fields of quantitative reasoning, data science, and data literacy, specifically focusing on how data literacy results from practicing quantitative reasoning and data science in the context of authentic data. Next, we identify and describe features that influence the complexity of authentic data sets (selection, curation, scope, size, and messiness) and implications for data-literacy instruction. Finally, we discuss areas for future research with the aim of identifying the impact that authentic data may have on student learning. These include defining desired learning outcomes surrounding data use in the classroom and identification of teaching best practices when using data in the classroom to develop students’ data-literacy abilities.
more »
« less
Using Messy, Authentic Data to Promote Data Literacy & Reveal the Nature of Science
Authentic, “messy data” contain variability that comes from many sources, such as natural variation in nature, chance occurrences during research, and human error. It is this messiness that both deters potential users of authentic data and gives data the power to create unique learning opportunities that reveal the nature of science itself. While the value of bringing contemporary research and messy data into the classroom is recognized, implementation can seem overwhelming. We discuss the importance of frequent interactions with messy data throughout K–16 science education as a mechanism for students to engage in the practices of science, such as visualizing, analyzing, and interpreting data. Next, we describe strategies to help facilitate the use of messy data in the classroom while building complexity over time. Finally, we outline one potential sequence of activities, with specific examples, to highlight how various activity types can be used to scaffold students' interactions with messy data.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10205875
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- The American Biology Teacher
- Volume:
- 82
- Issue:
- 7
- ISSN:
- 0002-7685
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 439 to 446
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Incorporating authentic research skills and practices into K‐12 science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) instruction is a challenging yet crucial approach for introducing students to authentic science inquiry. While recommendations for emphasizing data literacy and quantitative reasoning in science classroom contexts are well‐established, implementation remains challenging. Over the span of 4 years (2019–2023), a multi‐institution team of teachers, education researchers, and forest scientists established a partnership with the overarching goal of integrating authentic forest research and data into middle and high school classrooms. The education researchers played a critical role in facilitating effective scientist and teacher interactions while addressing classroom implementation challenges. Importantly, the effectiveness and mutual benefits of the research partnership were greatly influenced by specific practices implemented by the education research team, and the assumption of different collaborative roles by all stakeholders involved. In this study, we examine these roles, relationships, and interactions of all stakeholders in the partnership, with “stakeholder” referring to participating teachers, education researchers, and collaborating forest scientists.more » « less
-
While phenomena-based approaches in K-12 science education are increasingly focusing on data sensemaking, curricula often remain disconnected from students' cultural identities, lived experiences, and local contexts. Teachers lack practical, evidence-based guidance on how to localize instruction and integrate authentic data with digital tools in culturally responsive ways. This paper presents a conceptual framework for place-based, data-rich (PBDR) professional learning (PL) developed through four years of design-based research. The framework positions teachers as learners first, immersing them in authentic, locally grounded data inquiry before engaging in metacognitive reflection to translate their experiences into similar technology-enhanced, PBDR instruction for their students. An illustrative example from one PL pilot site and a teacher's subsequent classroom implementation demonstrates how the framework principles can translate to classroom practice. This work offers actionable guidance for professional learning providers, instructional designers, and curriculum writers seeking to support equitable, locally relevant data science integration in K-12 STEM.more » « less
-
Data literacy is a critical skill for developing the next generation of scientists and informed citizens. Authentic engagement with real-world Earth science datasets in K–12 classrooms is often limited by the complexity of research data and the need for effective pedagogical strategies to support sensemaking. Data Puzzles, a collaborative effort between scientists, curriculum developers, and educators housed at the Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences (CIRES), addresses this challenge by transforming authentic Earth and climate science datasets into structured, instructional modules designed for secondary classrooms. Each Data Puzzle is anchored in a relevant Earth system phenomenon and pairs authentic datasets (e.g., from satellite observations, field sensors, and physical samples) with research-based instructional practices from Ambitious Science Teaching (AST, Windschitl et al., 2020 ) to support data-driven reasoning, uncertainty exploration, and evidence-based explanation. Data Puzzle lessons have been adopted by hundreds of educators, empowering thousands of students to analyze and interpret authentic datasets while building critical data literacy skills. In parallel, the emerging Puzzle Piece resources allow students and teachers to extend structured learning into open-ended investigations using large, secondary datasets within a free, web-based analysis platform (CODAP). This combination of structured and open-ended resources creates an accessible pathway from curated datasets toward exploratory science practices, amplifying the’ broader impacts of science by translating complex datasets into classroom-ready learning experiences. This presentation will demonstrate how Data Puzzles serve as a model for scientists to broaden the impact of their research, enabling authentic data use and discovery in classrooms nationwide. We will share examples of how scientists’ data have been integrated into Data Puzzle lessons, highlight outcomes from teacher professional learning experiences, and discuss how this framework helps foster equitable data access and supports the next generation of Earth scientists and informed citizens.more » « less
-
Abstract Reformed science curricula provide opportunities for students to engage with authentic science practices. However, teacher implementation of such curricula requires teachers to consider their role in the classroom, including realigning instructional decisions with the epistemic aims of science. Guiding newcomers in science can take place in settings ranging from the classroom to the undergraduate research laboratory. We suggest thinking about the potential intersections of guiding students across these contexts is important. We describe the Classroom‐Research‐Mentoring (CRM) Framework as a novel lens for examining science practice‐based instruction. We present a comparative case study of two teachers as they instruct undergraduate students in a model‐based inquiry laboratory. We analyzed stimulated‐recall episodes uncovering how these teachers interacted with their students and the rationale behind their instructional choices. Through the application of the CRM Framework, we revealed ways teachers can have instructional goals that align with those of a research mentor. For example, our teachers had the goals of “creating an inclusive environment open to student ideas,” “acknowledging students as scientists,” and “focusing students on skills and ideas needed to solve biological problems.” We suggest three functions of research mentoring that translate across the classroom and research laboratory settings: (1) build a shared understanding of epistemic aims, (2) support learners in the productive use of science practices, and (3) motivate learner engagement in science practices.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1525/abt.2020.82.7.439
