skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Influence of Ground Motion Orientation on Predicted Seismic Compression
Seismic compression is the accrual of contractive volumetric strain in unsaturated or partially saturated sandy soils during earthquake shaking and has caused significant distress to overlying and nearby structures. The phenomenon can be well-characterized by load-dependent, interaction macro-level fatigue theories, which means that the nature of the accumulation of volumetric strain is a function of the absolute amplitude and sequencing of pulses in the loading function. One model that captures this behavior and that can be used to predict seismic compression is the expanded Byrne cyclic shear-volumetric strain coupling model. However, one potential implication of the load-dependent, interaction macro-level fatigue behaviour is that ground motion orientation will influence predicted settlements. To examine the significance of this, the seismic compression that occurred at the Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Power Plant (KKNPP) site during the 2007, Mw6.6 Niigata-ken Chuetsu-oki, Japan, earthquake is analyzed using the expanded Byrne model. The horizontal motions recorded at the site by a down-hole array during this event are rotated in 5° increments and the predicted settlements due to seismic compression are computed. The predicted settlements range from 12.3 to 16.1 cm, with a geometric mean of the values for various orientations being 13.8 cm. These results are in general accord with the post-earthquake field observations and highlight the sensitivity of predicted magnitude of the seismic compression to ground motion orientation.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1825189
PAR ID:
10209085
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Proc. New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering Annual Conference 2020 (NZSEE 2020)
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Seismic compression is the accrual of contractive volumetric strain in unsaturated or partially saturated sandy soils during earthquake shaking and has caused significant distress to overlying and nearby structures. The phenomenon can be well characterized by load-dependent, interaction macro-level fatigue theories. Toward this end, the Byrne cyclic shear-volumetric strain coupling model is expanded and calibrated for evaluating seismic compression for several soil types. In addition, the model was transformed to allow it to be implemented in a “simplified” manner, in addition to the original “non-simplified” formulation. Both implementation approaches are used to analyze a site in Japan impacted by the 2007, Mw6.6 Niigata-ken Chuetsu-oki earthquake. The results from the analyses are in general accord with the post-earthquake field observations and highlight the sensitivity of predicted magnitude of the seismic compression to the input variables used and modeling assumptions (e.g. relative density of the soil, magnitude of the volumetric threshold strain, orientation of the ground motions, settlement of soils below the ground water table, and accounting for multidirectional shaking). Although additional studies are needed to further validate the findings presented herein, estimation of relative density and threshold shear strain of the soil and ground motion orientation individually have moderate-to-significant influence on the computed magnitude of seismic compression, but they have a significant influence when taken in combination. Also, the seismic compression models can seemingly be used to predict the settlement in fully saturated sand when the excess pore water pressures are limited. Finally, accounting for multidirectional shaking has a significant influence on the computed magnitude of seismic compression. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    Seismic compression is the accrual of contractive volumetric strain in unsaturated or partially saturated sandy soils during earthquake shaking and has caused significant distress to overlying and nearby structures, to include the 2007, Mw6.6 Niigata-ken Chuetsu-oki, Japan earthquake. Of specific interest to this study is the seismic compression that occurred during this event at the Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Power Plant (KKNPP) site. What makes this case history of particular value is that the motions at the site were recorded by a free-field downhole array (Service Hall Array, SHA) and the magnitude of the seismic compression was accurately determined from the settlement of soil around a vertical pipe housing one of the array seismographs. The seismic compression at the site was ~10-20 cm. The profile at the site was well characterized by in-situ tests and laboratory tests performed on samples from the site, which allows seismic compression models to be calibrated. The study presented herein compares the predictions of the simplified and non-simplified forms of the expanded Byrne model. The predictions are in good accord with field observations, but the slight under-prediction by the non-simplified model may relate to estimated soil properties, assumed orientation of the ground motions and accounting for multidirectional shaking, and/or the numerical site response analyses used to compute the variation of the shear strains during shaking at depth in the soil profile. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract The nonlinear mechanical responses of rocks and soils to seismic waves play an important role in earthquake physics, influencing ground motion from source to site. Continuous geophysical monitoring, such as ambient noise interferometry, has revealed co‐seismic wave speed reductions extending tens of kilometers from earthquake sources. However, the mechanisms governing these changes remain challenging to model, especially at regional scales. Using a nonlinear damage model constrained by laboratory experiments, we develop and apply an open‐source 3D discontinuous Galerkin method to simulate regional co‐seismic wave speed changes during the 2015 Mw7.8 Gorkha earthquake. We find pronounced spatial variations of co‐seismic wave speed reduction, ranging from <0.01% to >50%, particularly close to the source and within the Kathmandu Basin, while disagreement with observations remains. The most significant reduction occurs within the sedimentary basin and varies with basin depths, whereas wave speed reductions correlate with the fault slip distribution near the source. By comparing ground motions from simulations with elastic, viscoelastic, elastoplastic, and nonlinear damage rheologies, we demonstrate that the nonlinear damage model effectively captures low‐frequency ground motion amplification due to strain‐dependent wave speed reductions in soft sediments. We verify the accuracy of our approach through comparisons with analytical solutions and assess its scalability on high‐performance computing systems. The model shows near‐linear strong and weak scaling up to 2,048 nodes, enabling efficient large‐scale simulations. Our findings provide a physics‐based framework to quantify nonlinear earthquake effects and emphasize the importance of damage‐induced wave speed variations for seismic hazard assessment and ground motion predictions. 
    more » « less
  4. Assessment of earthquake-induced liquefaction is an important topic in geotechnical engineering due to the significant potential for damage to infrastructure. Some of the most significant infrastructure damage occurs due to differential settlement of the ground, including due to liquefaction. Postliquefaction deformations commonly are assessed using one-dimensional empirical models, which inherently assume laterally homogeneous soil layers. Numerical models offer the potential to examine the effects of ground motion variability and spatially variable soil properties on liquefaction-induced deformations. This study explored the postliquefaction reconsolidation settlement for a site in Hollywood, South Carolina, which was characterized using a three-dimensional (3D) geostatistical model and simulated using the numerical platform FLAC and constitutive model PM4Sand. The effects of ground motion characteristics on mean and maximum differential settlements were investigated. The physical mechanisms associated with postliquefaction responses such as excess pore pressures, shear strains, and volumetric strains also were examined. The efficacy of uniform models assuming representative percentile soil properties to represent the stochastic mean settlement was investigated. The inherent inability of uniform models to capture differential settlements and therefore the need for using stochastic models is discussed. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper develops a probabilistic earthquake risk assessment for the electric power transmis- sion system in the City of Los Angeles. Via a dc load flow analysis of a suite of damage scenarios that reflect the seismic risk in Los Angeles, we develop a probabilistic representation for load shed during the restoration process. This suite of damage scenarios and their associated annual probabilities of occurrence are developed from 351 risk-adjusted earthquake scenarios using ground motion that collectively represent the seismic risk in Los Angeles at the census tract level. For each of these 351 earthquake scenarios, 12 damage scenarios are developed that form a probabilistic representation of the consequences of the earthquake scenario on the components of the transmission system. This analysis reveals that substation damage is the key driver of load shed. Damage to generators has a substantial but still secondary impact, and damage to transmission lines has significantly less impact. We identify the census tracts that are substantially more vulnerable to power transmission outages during the restoration process. Further, we explore the impact of forecasted increases in penetration of residential storage paired with rooftop solar. The deployment of storage paired with rooftop solar is represented at the census tract level and is assumed to be able to generate and store power for residential demand during the restoration process. The deployment of storage paired with rooftop solar reduces the load shed during the restoration process, but the distribution of this benefit is correlated with household income and whether the dwelling is owned or rented. 
    more » « less