skip to main content

Explore Research Products in the NSF-PAR

Title: Low-temperature nucleation anomaly in silicate glasses shown to be artifact in a 5BaO·8SiO2 glass
Abstract For over 40 years, measurements of the nucleation rates in a large number of silicate glasses have indicated a breakdown in the Classical Nucleation Theory at temperatures below that of the peak nucleation rate. The data show that instead of steadily decreasing with decreasing temperature, the work of critical cluster formation enters a plateau and even starts to increase. Many explanations have been offered to explain this anomaly, but none have provided a satisfactory answer. We present an experimental approach to demonstrate explicitly for the example of a 5BaO ∙ 8SiO 2 glass that the anomaly is not a real phenomenon, but instead an artifact arising from an insufficient heating time at low temperatures. Heating times much longer than previously used at a temperature 50 K below the peak nucleation rate temperature give results that are consistent with the predictions of the Classical Nucleation Theory. These results raise the question of whether the claimed anomaly is also an artifact in other glasses.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1720296
NSF-PAR ID:
10230347
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Nature Communications
Volume:
12
Issue:
1
ISSN:
2041-1723
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ( , Journal of Climate)
    Abstract

    Arctic surface warming under greenhouse gas forcing peaks in winter and reaches its minimum during summer in both observations and model projections. Many mechanisms have been proposed to explain this seasonal asymmetry, but disentangling these processes remains a challenge in the interpretation of general circulation model (GCM) experiments. To isolate these mechanisms, we use an idealized single-column sea ice model (SCM) that captures the seasonal pattern of Arctic warming. SCM experiments demonstrate that as sea ice melts and exposes open ocean, the accompanying increase in effective surface heat capacity alone can produce the observed pattern of peak warming in early winter (shifting to late winter under increased forcing) by slowing the seasonal heating rate, thus delaying the phase and reducing the amplitude of the seasonal cycle of surface temperature. To investigate warming seasonality in more complex models, we perform GCM experiments that individually isolate sea ice albedo and thermodynamic effects under CO2forcing. These also show a key role for the effective heat capacity of sea ice in promoting seasonal asymmetry through suppressing summer warming, in addition to precluding summer climatological inversions and a positive summer lapse-rate feedback. Peak winter warming in GCM experiments is further supported by a positive winter lapse-rate feedback, due to cold initial surface temperatures and strong surface-trapped warming that are enabled by the albedo effects of sea ice alone. While many factors contribute to the seasonal pattern of Arctic warming, these results highlight changes in effective surface heat capacity as a central mechanism supporting this seasonality.

    Significance Statement

    Under increasing concentrations of atmospheric greenhouse gases, the strongest Arctic warming has occurred during early winter, but the reasons for this seasonal pattern of warming are not well understood. We use experiments in both simple and complex models with certain sea ice processes turned on and off to disentangle potential drivers of seasonality in Arctic warming. When sea ice melts and open ocean is exposed, surface temperatures are slower to reach the warm-season maximum and slower to cool back down below freezing in early winter. We find that this process alone can produce the observed pattern of maximum Arctic warming in early winter, highlighting a fundamental mechanism for the seasonality of Arctic warming.

     
    more » « less
  2. ( , Xth Hutton Symposium)
    The granitic water-saturated solidus (G-WSS) is the lower temperature limit of magmatic mineral crystallization. The accepted water-saturated solidus for granitic compositions was largely determined >60 years ago1. More recent advances in experimental petrology, improved analytical techniques, and recent observations that granitic systems can remain active or spend a significant proportion of their lives at conditions below the traditional G-WSS2–5 necessitate a careful experimental investigation of the near-solidus regions of granitic systems. Natural and synthetic starting materials were melted at 10 kbar and 900°C with 48 wt% H2O to produce hydrous glasses for subsequent experiments at lower PT conditions used to locate the G-WSS. We performed crystallization experiments and melting experiments at temperatures ranging from 575 to 800°C and 1, 6, 8, and 10 kbar on 12 granitoid compositions. First, we ran a series of isothermal crystallization experiments along each isobar at progressively lower temperatures until runs completely crystallized to identify apparent solidus temperatures. Geochemical analyses of quenched glass compositions demonstrate that progressive crystallization drives all starting compositions towards silica-rich, water-saturated rhyolitic/granitic melts (e.g., ~7578 wt% SiO2). After identifying the apparent solidus temperatures at which the various compositions crystallized, we then ran series of reversal-type melting experiments. With the goal of producing rocks with hydrous equilibrium microstructures, we crystallized compositions at temperatures ~10°C below the apparent solidus identified in crystallization experiments, and then heated isobarically to conditions that produced ~20% melt during the crystallization experiments. Importantly, crystallization experiments and heating experiments at the same PT conditions produced similar proportions of melt, crystals, and vapor. A time-series of experiments 230 days at PT conditions previously identified to produce ~10% to 20% melt did not reveal any kinetic effects on melt crystallization. Experiments at 6 to 10 kbar crystallized/melted at temperatures close to the published G-WSS. However, at lower pressures where the published G-WSS is strongly curved in PT space, all compositions investigated contained melt to temperatures ~75 to 100°C below the accepted G-WSS. The similarity of crystallization temperatures for the higher-pressure experiments to previously published results, similar phase proportions in melting and crystallization experiments, and the lack of kinetic effects on crystallization collectively suggest that our lower pressure constraints on the G-WSS are accurate. The new experimental results demonstrating that the lower-pressure G-WSS is significantly lower than unanimously accepted estimates will help us to better understand the storage conditions, evolution, and potential for eruption in mid- to upper-crustal silicic magmatic systems. (1) Tuttle, O.; Bowen, N. Origin of Granite in the Light of Experimental Studies in the System NaAlSi3O8–KAlSi3O8–SiO2–H2O; Geological Society of America Memoirs; Geological Society of America, 1958; Vol. 74. https://doi.org/10.1130/MEM74. (2) Rubin, A. E.; Cooper, K. M.; Till, C. B.; Kent, A. J. R.; Costa, F.; Bose, M.; Gravley, D.; Deering, C.; Cole, J. Rapid Cooling and Cold Storage in a Silicic Magma Reservoir Recorded in Individual Crystals. Science 2017, 356 (6343), 1154–1156. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aam8720. (3) Andersen, N. L.; Jicha, B. R.; Singer, B. S.; Hildreth, W. Incremental Heating of Bishop Tuff Sanidine Reveals Preeruptive Radiogenic Ar and Rapid Remobilization from Cold Storage. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2017, 114 (47), 12407–12412. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1709581114. (4) Ackerson, M. R.; Mysen, B. O.; Tailby, N. D.; Watson, E. B. Low-Temperature Crystallization of Granites and the Implications for Crustal Magmatism. Nature 2018, 559 (7712), 94–97. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-018-0264-2. (5) Glazner, A. F.; Bartley, J. M.; Coleman, D. S.; Lindgren, K. Aplite Diking and Infiltration: A Differentiation Mechanism Restricted to Plutonic Rocks. Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology 2020, 175 (4). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00410-020-01677-1. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ( , Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences)

    Ice nucleation in the atmosphere influences cloud properties, altering precipitation and the radiative balance, ultimately regulating Earth’s climate. An accepted ice nucleation pathway, known as deposition nucleation, assumes a direct transition of water from the vapor to the ice phase, without an intermediate liquid phase. However, studies have shown that nucleation occurs through a liquid phase in porous particles with narrow cracks or surface imperfections where the condensation of liquid below water saturation can occur, questioning the validity of deposition nucleation. We show that deposition nucleation cannot explain the strongly enhanced ice nucleation efficiency of porous compared with nonporous particles at temperatures below −40 °C and the absence of ice nucleation below water saturation at −35 °C. Using classical nucleation theory (CNT) and molecular dynamics simulations (MDS), we show that a network of closely spaced pores is necessary to overcome the barrier for macroscopic ice-crystal growth from narrow cylindrical pores. In the absence of pores, CNT predicts that the nucleation barrier is insurmountable, consistent with the absence of ice formation in MDS. Our results confirm that pore condensation and freezing (PCF), i.e., a mechanism of ice formation that proceeds via liquid water condensation in pores, is a dominant pathway for atmospheric ice nucleation below water saturation. We conclude that the ice nucleation activity of particles in the cirrus regime is determined by the porosity and wettability of pores. PCF represents a mechanism by which porous particles like dust could impact cloud radiative forcing and, thus, the climate via ice cloud formation.

     
    more » « less
  4. ( , AGU Fall Meeting)
    The accepted water-saturated solidus for granitic compositions (granitic water-saturated solidus, G-WSS) was largely determined >60 years ago. Significant experimental resources using modern approaches have been allocated to defining, refining, and parameterizing the solidus positions for other rock compositions, but limited work has been performed to accurately define G-WSS. Modern experimental and analytical techniques afford the opportunity to re-investigate the position of the G-WSS. Various thermobarometric applications to many granitic and rhyolitic composition rocks commonly return temperature estimates significantly lower than the widely accepted G-WSS determined largely by Tuttle and Bowen (1958). To evaluate the apparent discrepancies and help distinguish igneous from metamorphic processes recorded in granitic mineral assemblages, we performed experiments at temperatures ranging from 575 to 900°C and 0.5 to 10 kbar on 12 granitoid compositions composed of natural and synthetic starting materials. Most starting materials were melted in the presence of water at 10 kbar and 900°C in piston cylinders and quenched to room temperature in under one minute to produce water-saturated glasses for usage in subsequent crystallization experiments. The results of experiments on glass compositions were further validated in several runs using finely-ground crystalline starting materials. We ran crystallization experiments at P-T conditions spanning the accepted G-WSS. Decreasing experimental temperatures along each isobar caused systematic decreases in melt percentages until achieving complete crystallization at solidus conditions. A time-series of experiments at P-T conditions with ~20% melt did not reveal any kinetic effects on melt crystallization. All compositions investigated contained melt to temperatures ~75 to 100°C below the accepted G-WSS. Experimental results demonstrating that the G-WSS is significantly lower than unanimously accepted estimates will help us to better understand the storage conditions and evolution of silicic magmatic systems. Tuttle O, Bowen N (1958) Origin of Granite in the Light of Experimental Studies in the System NaAlSi3O8–KAlSi3O8–SiO2–H2O. Geological Society of America 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; ; ( , Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth)
    Abstract

    The physical properties of minerals are modified by the high temperatures of volcanic lightning during explosive eruptions. Alteration involves rapid heating and volatilization, melting, and fusion of ash grains within the discharge channel, followed by rapid quenching into new glassy textures. High current impulse experiments reveal that lightning alters not only the morphology and mineralogy of volcanic ash but also its magnetic properties. We investigate lightning‐induced magnetic changes in five igneous minerals (<32 μm powders of albite, labradorite, augite, hornblende, and magnetite) by comparing hysteresis parameters before and after impulse experiments conducted at peak currents of 25 and 40 kA. Both the paramagnetic and ferrimagnetic behaviors of the samples were altered, which we interpret as a superposition of two processes. (a) Rapid melting allows iron contained within inclusions of Fe‐oxides and Fe‐bearing silicates to diffuse into the newly formed melt, thereby increasing the paramagnetism of the resulting glass. (b) Nucleation and growth of magnetite from the newly formed melt increases the ferrimagnetic behavior of the post‐experimental samples. Nominally non‐Fe‐bearing silicates like albite and labradorite have significantly increased paramagnetism and ferrimagnetism. Fe‐bearing silicates like augite and hornblende contain higher concentrations of ferrimagnetic inclusions, from which Fe diffuses into the newly formed melt, thereby increasing paramagnetism while decreasing ferrimagnetism. Experiments conducted on magnetite produced new magnetite crystals with dendritic habits. Although specific to volcanic ash, these results provide important insights into the magnetism of other materials affected by lightning on Earth, the Moon, and throughout the solar system.

     
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email