Pyrite is a ubiquitous iron sulfide mineral that is oxidized by trace oxygen. The mineral has been largely absent from global sediments since the rise in oxygen concentration in Earth’s early atmosphere. We analyzed weathering in shale, the most common rock exposed at Earth’s surface, with chemical and microscopic analysis. By looking across scales from 10−9to 102meters, we determined the factors that control pyrite oxidation. Under the atmosphere today, pyrite oxidation is rate-limited by diffusion of oxygen to the grain surface and regulated by large-scale erosion and clast-scale fracturing. We determined that neither iron- nor sulfur-oxidizing microorganisms control global pyrite weathering fluxes despite their ability to catalyze the reaction. This multiscale picture emphasizes that fracturing and erosion are as important as atmospheric oxygen in limiting pyrite reactivity over Earth’s history.
- Award ID(s):
- 1736771
- PAR ID:
- 10230660
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Volume:
- 117
- Issue:
- 52
- ISSN:
- 0027-8424
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 33043 to 33050
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
more » « less
-
The large range in oxidation states of sulfur (-II to +VI) provides it with a large oxidation potential in rocks, even at relatively low concentrations. Most importantly, the transition from sulfide to sulfate species in rocks and silicate melts occurs in the same approximate fO2 region (for a given temperature) as the transition from ferrous to ferric iron, and reduced S species can coexist with oxidized Fe and vice versa. The result is a large potential for reactions involving sulfur to oxidize or reduce Fe in silicate minerals, since Fe only occurs in two oxidation states (+II and +III). In order for sulfur to be released during slab dehydration, sulfur in sulfide must be converted into an easily dissolved species, such as SO42− or H2S, through either oxidation or reduction. We propose that oxidation of sulfur in sulfide follows the generalized reaction: 8Fe3+SiaOb(OH)c +S2− = 8Fe2+SidOe +SO42− +(H2O)f (1) In this type of reaction, sulfur participates in the dehydration of greenschist- or blueschist-facies hydrous silicates during transition to the eclogite facies: ferric Fe in Fe-bearing silicates (chlorite, amphibole, epidote) is reduced to ferrous Fe in anhydrous ferromagnesian silicates (pyroxene, garnet). At the same time, the reaction consumes sulfide by oxidation of S2− to produce SO42−, which is readily dissolved in the fluid produced during dehydration. Additionally, a similar redox reaction could oxidize sulfur by reducing ferric Fe in oxides. It is important to note that one mole of S has the same redox potential as 8 moles of Fe. The molar ratio of 8 moles of Fe per 1 mole of S translates to a mass ratio of approximately 14; therefore, small concentrations of sulfur can have a large impact on reduction/oxidation of the silicate assemblage. Our observations show that sulfide minerals that can be identified as primary or related to the peak metamorphic stage are rare in eclogites and restricted to inclusions in garnet, consistent with reaction (1). Thermodynamic modeling is currently underway to assess the influence of sulfur on the phase equilibria of silicate phases during high pressure metamorphism.more » « less
-
more » « less
ABSTRACT The microbial recycling of organic matter in marine sediments depends upon electron acceptors that are utilized based on availability and energetic yield. Since sulfate is the most abundant oxidant once oxygen has been depleted, the sulfide produced after sulfate reduction becomes an important electron donor for autotrophic microbes. The ability of sulfide to be re‐oxidized through multiple metabolic pathways and intermediates with variable oxidation states prompts investigation into which species are preferentially utilized and what are the factors that determine the fate of reduced sulfur species. Quantifying these sulfur intermediates in porewaters is a critical first step towards achieving a more complete understanding of the oxidative sulfur cycle, yet this has been accomplished in very few studies, none of which include oligotrophic sedimentary environments in the open ocean. Here we present profiles of porewater sulfur intermediates from sediments underlying oligotrophic regions of the ocean, which encompass about 75% of the ocean's surface and are characterized by low nutrient levels and productivity. Aiming at addressing uncertainties about if and how sulfide produced by the degradation of scarce sedimentary organic matter plays a role in carbon fixation in the sediment, we determine depth profiles of redox‐sensitive metals and sulfate isotope compositions and integrate these datasets with 16S rRNA microbial community composition data and solid‐phase sulfur concentrations. We did not find significant correlations between sulfur species or trace metals and specific sulfur cycling taxa, which suggests that microorganisms in pelagic and oxic sediments may be generalists utilizing flexible metabolisms to oxidize organic matter through different electron acceptors.
-
more » « less
Abstract The sedimentary pyrite sulfur isotope (δ34S) record is an archive of ancient microbial sulfur cycling and environmental conditions. Interpretations of pyrite δ34S signatures in sediments deposited in microbial mat ecosystems are based on studies of modern microbial mat porewater sulfide δ34S geochemistry. Pyrite δ34S values often capture δ34S signatures of porewater sulfide at the location of pyrite formation. However, microbial mats are dynamic environments in which biogeochemical cycling shifts vertically on diurnal cycles. Therefore, there is a need to study how the location of pyrite formation impacts pyrite δ34S patterns in these dynamic systems. Here, we present diurnal porewater sulfide δ34S trends and δ34S values of pyrite and iron monosulfides from Middle Island Sinkhole, Lake Huron. The sediment–water interface of this sinkhole hosts a low‐oxygen cyanobacterial mat ecosystem, which serves as a useful location to explore preservation of sedimentary pyrite δ34S signatures in early Earth environments. Porewater sulfide δ34S values vary by up to ~25‰ throughout the day due to light‐driven changes in surface microbial community activity that propagate downwards, affecting porewater geochemistry as deep as 7.5 cm in the sediment. Progressive consumption of the sulfate reservoir drives δ34S variability, instead of variations in average cell‐specific sulfate reduction rates and/or sulfide oxidation at different depths in the sediment. The δ34S values of pyrite are similar to porewater sulfide δ34S values near the mat surface. We suggest that oxidative sulfur cycling and other microbial activity promote pyrite formation in and immediately adjacent to the microbial mat and that iron geochemistry limits further pyrite formation with depth in the sediment. These results imply that primary δ34S signatures of pyrite deposited in organic‐rich, iron‐poor microbial mat environments capture information about microbial sulfur cycling and environmental conditions at the mat surface and are only minimally affected by deeper sedimentary processes during early diagenesis.
-
more » « less
Abstract Deep‐sea methane seeps are amongst the most biologically productive environments on Earth and are often characterised by stable, low oxygen concentrations and microbial communities that couple the anaerobic oxidation of methane to sulfate reduction or iron reduction in the underlying sediment. At these sites, ferrous iron (Fe2+) can be produced by organoclastic iron reduction, methanotrophic‐coupled iron reduction, or through the abiotic reduction by sulfide produced by the abundant sulfate‐reducing bacteria at these sites. The prevalence of Fe2+in the anoxic sediments, as well as the availability of oxygen in the overlying water, suggests that seeps could also harbour communities of iron‐oxidising microbes. However, it is unclear to what extent Fe2+remains bioavailable and in solution given that the abiotic reaction between sulfide and ferrous iron is often assumed to scavenge all ferrous iron as insoluble iron sulfides and pyrite. Accordingly, we searched the sea floor at methane seeps along the Cascadia Margin for microaerobic, neutrophilic iron‐oxidising bacteria, operating under the reasoning that if iron‐oxidising bacteria could be isolated from these environments, it could indicate that porewater Fe2+can persist is long enough for biology to outcompete pyritisation. We found that the presence of sulfate in our enrichment media muted any obvious microbially‐driven iron oxidation with most iron being precipitated as iron sulfides. Transfer of enrichment cultures to sulfate‐depleted media led to dynamic iron redox cycling relative to abiotic controls and sulfate‐containing cultures, and demonstrated the capacity for biogenic iron (oxyhydr)oxides from a methane seep‐derived community. 16S rRNA analyses revealed that removing sulfate drastically reduced the diversity of enrichment cultures and caused a general shift from a Gammaproteobacteria‐domainated ecosystem to one dominated by
Rhodobacteraceae (Alphaproteobacteria ). Our data suggest that, in most cases, sulfur cycling may restrict the biological “ferrous wheel” in contemporary environments through a combination of the sulfur‐adapted sediment‐dwelling ecosystems and the abiotic reactions they influence.
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2008235117
