As scaling of conventional memory devices has stalled, many high-end computing systems have begun to incorporate alternative memory technologies to meet performance goals. Since these technologies present distinct advantages and tradeoffs compared to conventional DDR* SDRAM, such as higher bandwidth with lower capacity or vice versa, they are typically packaged alongside conventional SDRAM in a heterogeneous memory architecture. To utilize the different types of memory efficiently, new data management strategies are needed to match application usage to the best available memory technology. However, current proposals for managing heterogeneous memories are limited, because they either (1) do not consider high-level application behavior when assigning data to different types of memory or (2) require separate program execution (with a representative input) to collect information about how the application uses memory resources. This work presents a new data management toolset to address the limitations of existing approaches for managing complex memories. It extends the application runtime layer with automated monitoring and management routines that assign application data to the best tier of memory based on previous usage, without any need for source code modification or a separate profiling run. It evaluates this approach on a state-of-the-art server platform with both conventional DDR4 SDRAM and non-volatile Intel Optane DC memory, using both memory-intensive high-performance computing (HPC) applications as well as standard benchmarks. Overall, the results show that this approach improves program performance significantly compared to a standard unguided approach across a variety of workloads and system configurations. The HPC applications exhibit the largest benefits, with speedups ranging from 1.4× to 7× in the best cases. Additionally, we show that this approach achieves similar performance as a comparable offline profiling-based approach after a short startup period, without requiring separate program execution or offline analysis steps.
more »
« less
Performance Potential of Mixed Data Management Modes for Heterogeneous Memory Systems
Many high-performance systems now include different types of memory devices within the same compute platform to meet strict performance and cost constraints. Such heterogeneous memory systems often include an upper-level tier with better performance, but limited capacity, and lower-level tiers with higher capacity, but less bandwidth and longer latencies for reads and writes. To utilize the different memory layers efficiently, current systems rely on hardware-directed, memory -side caching or they provide facilities in the operating system (OS) that allow applications to make their own data-tier assignments. Since these data management options each come with their own set of trade-offs, many systems also include mixed data management configurations that allow applications to employ hardware- and software-directed management simultaneously, but for different portions of their address space. Despite the opportunity to address limitations of stand-alone data management options, such mixed management modes are under-utilized in practice, and have not been evaluated in prior studies of complex memory hardware. In this work, we develop custom program profiling, configurations, and policies to study the potential of mixed data management modes to outperform hardware- or software-based management schemes alone. Our experiments, conducted on an Intel ® Knights Landing platform with high-bandwidth memory, demonstrate that the mixed data management mode achieves the same or better performance than the best stand-alone option for five memory intensive benchmark applications (run separately and in isolation), resulting in an average speedup compared to the best stand-alone policy of over 10 %, on average.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1943305
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10232736
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- 2020 IEEE/ACM Workshop on Memory Centric High Performance Computing
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 10 to 16
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)Non-volatile memory (NVRAM) based on phase-change memory (such as Optane DC Persistent Memory Module) is making its way into Intel servers to address the needs of emerging applications that have a huge memory footprint. These systems have both DRAM and NVRAM on the same memory channel with the smaller capacity DRAM serving as a cache to the larger capacity NVRAM in the so called 2LM mode. In this work we analyze the performance of such DRAM caches on real hardware using a broad range of synthetic and real-world benchmarks. We identify three key limitations of DRAM caches in these emerging systems which prevent large-scale, bandwidth bound applications from taking full advantage of NVRAM read and write bandwidth. We show that software based techniques are necessary for orchestrating the data movement between DRAM and PMM for such workloads to take full advantage of these new heterogeneous memory systems.more » « less
-
Today, larger memory capacity and higher memory bandwidth are required for better performance and energy efficiency for many important client and datacenter applications. Hardware memory compression provides a promising direction to achieve this without increasing system cost. Unfortunately, current memory compression solutions face two significant challenges. First, keeping memory compressed requires additional memory accesses, sometimes on the critical path, which can cause performance overheads. Second, they require changing the operating system to take advantage of the increased capacity, and to handle incompressible data, which delays deployment. We propose Compresso, a hardware memory compression architecture that minimizes memory overheads due to compression, with no changes to the OS. We identify new data-movement trade-offs and propose optimizations that reduce additional memory movement to improve system efficiency. We propose a holistic evaluation for compressed systems. Our results show that Compresso achieves a 1.85x compression for main memory on average, with a 24% speedup over a competitive hardware compressed system for single-core systems and 27% for multi-core systems. As compared to competitive compressed systems, Compresso not only reduces performance overhead of compression, but also increases performance gain from higher memory capacity.more » « less
-
Many applications can benefit from data that increases performance but is not required for correctness (commonly referred to as soft state). Examples include cached data from backend web servers and memoized computations in data analytics systems. Today's systems generally statically limit the amount of memory they use for storing soft state in order to prevent unbounded growth that could exhaust the server's memory. Static provisioning, however, makes it difficult to respond to shifts in application demand for soft state and can leave significant amounts of memory idle. Existing OS kernels can only spend idle memory on caching disk blocks—which may not have the most utility—because they do not provide the right abstractions to safely allow applications to store their own soft state. To effectively manage and dynamically scale soft state, we propose soft memory, an elastic virtual memory abstraction with unmap-and-reconstruct semantics that makes it possible for applications to use idle memory to store whatever soft state they choose while guaranteeing both safety and efficiency. We present Midas, a soft memory management system that contains (1) a runtime that is linked to each application to manage soft memory objects and (2) OS kernel support that coordinates soft memory allocation between applications to maximize their performance. Our experiments with four real-world applications show that Midas can efficiently and safely harvest idle memory to store applications' soft state, delivering near-optimal application performance and responding to extreme memory pressure without running out of memory.more » « less
-
Papadopoulos, Alessandro V. (Ed.)Temporal isolation is one of the most significant challenges that must be addressed before Multi-Processor Systems-on-Chip (MPSoCs) can be widely adopted in mixed-criticality systems with both time-sensitive real-time (RT) applications and performance-oriented non-real-time (NRT) applications. Specifically, the main memory subsystem is one of the most prevalent causes of interference, performance degradation and loss of isolation. Existing memory bandwidth regulation mechanisms use static, dynamic, or predictive DRAM bandwidth management techniques to restore the execution time of an application under contention as close as possible to the execution time in isolation. In this paper, we propose a novel distribution-driven regulation whose goal is to achieve a timeliness objective formulated as a constraint on the probability of meeting a certain target execution time for the RT applications. Using existing interconnect-level Performance Monitoring Units (PMU), we can observe the Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the per-request memory latency. Regulation is then triggered to enforce first-order stochastical dominance with respect to a desired reference. Consequently, it is possible to enforce that the overall observed execution time random variable is dominated by the reference execution time. The mechanism requires no prior information of the contending application and treats the DRAM subsystem as a black box. We provide a full-stack implementation of our mechanism on a Commercial Off-The-Shelf (COTS) platform (Xilinx Ultrascale+ MPSoC), evaluate it using real and synthetic benchmarks, experimentally validate that the timeliness objectives are met for the RT applications, and demonstrate that it is able to provide 2.2x more overall throughput for NRT applications compared to DRAM bandwidth management-based regulation approaches.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/10.1109/MCHPC51950.2020.00007
