skip to main content


Title: Evaluating the Inverted Pyramid Structure through Automatic 5W1H Extraction and Summarization
The inverted pyramid is a basic structure of news reporting used by journalists to convey information and it is considered a key element of objectivity in news reporting. In this article, we propose the Inverted Pyramid Scoring method to evaluate how well a news article follows the inverted pyramid structure using main event descriptors (5W1H) extraction and news summarization. We evaluate our proposed method on a proprietary data set of Associated Press news articles across breaking and non-breaking news spanning two topics—political and business. Our results show that the method works at distinguishing the structural differences between breaking and non-breaking news. In particular, our results confirm that breaking news articles are more likely to follow the inverted pyramid structure.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2128642
NSF-PAR ID:
10274096
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Computational Journalism C+J
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The inverted pyramid is a basic structure of news reporting used by journalists to convey information and it is considered a key element of objectivity in news reporting. In this article, we propose the Inverted Pyramid Scoring method to evaluate how well a news article follows the inverted pyramid structure using main event descriptors (5W1H) extraction and news summarization. We evaluate our proposed method on a proprietary data set of Associated Press news articles across breaking and non-breaking news spanning two topics—political and business. Our results show that the method works at distinguishing the structural differences between breaking and non-breaking news. In particular, our results confirm that breaking news articles are more likely to follow the inverted pyramid structure. 
    more » « less
  2. Espinosa-Anke, Luis ; Martín-Vide, Carlos ; Spasić, Irena (Ed.)
    Algorithmic journalism refers to automatic AI-constructed news stories. There have been successful commercial implementations for news stories in sports, weather, financial reporting and similar domains with highly structured, well defined tabular data sources. Other domains such as local reporting have not seen adoption of algorithmic journalism, and thus no automated reporting systems are available in these categories which can have important implications for the industry. In this paper, we demonstrate a novel approach for producing news stories on government legislative activity, an area that has not widely adopted algorithmic journalism. Our data source is state legislative proceedings, primarily the transcribed speeches and dialogue from floor sessions and committee hearings in US State legislatures. Specifically, we create a library of potential events called phenoms. We systematically analyze the transcripts for the presence of phenoms using a custom partial order planner. Each phenom, if present, contributes some natural language text to the generated article: either stating facts, quoting individuals or summarizing some aspect of the discussion. We evaluate two randomly chosen articles with a user study on Amazon Mechanical Turk with mostly Likert scale questions. Our results indicate a high degree of achievement for accuracy of facts and readability of final content with 13 of 22 users in the first article and 19 of 20 subjects of the second article agreeing or strongly agreeing that the articles included the most important facts of the hearings. Other results strengthen this finding in terms of accuracy, focus and writing quality. 
    more » « less
  3. The V-defect is a naturally occurring inverted hexagonal pyramid structure that has been studied in GaN and InGaN growth since the 1990s. Strategic use of V-defects in pre-quantum well superlattices or equivalent preparation layers has enabled record breaking efficiencies for green, yellow, and red InGaN light emitting diodes (LEDs) utilizing lateral injection of holes through the semi-polar sidewalls of the V-defects. In this article, we use advanced characterization techniques such as scattering contrast transmission electron microscopy, high angle annular dark field scanning transmission electron microscopy, x-ray fluorescence maps, and atom probe tomography to study the active region compositions, V-defect formation, and V-defect structure in green and red LEDs grown on (0001) patterned sapphire and (111) Si substrates. We identify two distinct types of V-defects. The “large” V-defects are those that form in the pre-well superlattice and promote hole injection, usually nucleating on mixed (Burgers vector b=±a±c) character threading dislocations. In addition, “small” V-defects often form in the multi-quantum well region and are believed to be deleterious to high-efficiency LEDs by providing non-radiative pathways. The small V-defects are often associated with basal plane stacking faults or stacking fault boxes. Furthermore, we show through scattering contrast transmission electron microscopy that during V-defect filling, the threading dislocation, which runs up the center of the V-defect, will “bend” onto one of the six {101¯1} semi-polar planes. This result is essential to understanding non-radiative recombination in V-defect engineered LEDs.

     
    more » « less
  4. As news organizations embrace transparency practices on their websites to distinguish themselves from those spreading misinformation, HCI designers have the opportunity to help them effectively utilize the ideals of transparency to build trust. How can we utilize transparency to promote trust in news? We examine this question through a qualitative lens by interviewing journalists and news consumers---the two stakeholders in a news system. We designed a scenario to demonstrate transparency features using two fundamental news attributes that convey the trustworthiness of a news article: source and message. In the interviews, our news consumers expressed the idea that news transparency could be best shown by providing indicators of objectivity in two areas (news selection and framing) and by providing indicators of evidence in four areas (presence of source materials, anonymous sourcing, verification, and corrections upon erroneous reporting). While our journalists agreed with news consumers' suggestions of using evidence indicators, they also suggested additional transparency indicators in areas such as the news reporting process and personal/organizational conflicts of interest. Prompted by our scenario, participants offered new design considerations for building trustworthy news platforms, such as designing for easy comprehension, presenting appropriate details in news articles (e.g., showing the number and nature of corrections made to an article), and comparing attributes across news organizations to highlight diverging practices. Comparing the responses from our two stakeholder groups reveals conflicting suggestions with trade-offs between them. Our study has implications for HCI designers in building trustworthy news systems. 
    more » « less
  5. Kidney trade has been on the rise despite the domestic and international law enforcement aiming to protect the vulnerable population from potential exploitation. Regional hubs are emerging in several parts of the world including South Asia, Central America, the Middle East and East Asia. Kidney trade networks reported in these hot spots are often complex systems involving several players such as buyers, sellers and surgery countries operating across international borders so that they can bypass domestic laws in sellers and buyers’ countries. The exact patterns of the country networks are, however, largely unknown due to the lack of a systematic approach to collect the data. Most of the kidney trade information is currently available in the form of case studies, court materials and news articles or reports, and no comprehensive database exists at this time. The present study thus explored online newspaper scraping to systematically collect 10 419 news articles from 24 major English newspapers in South Asia (January 2016 to May 2019) and build transnational kidney trade networks at the country level. Additionally, this study applied text mining techniques to extract words from each news article and developed machine learning algorithms to identify kidney trade and non-kidney trade news articles. Our findings suggest that online newspaper scraping coupled with the machine learning method is a promising approach to compile such data, especially in the dire shortage of empirical data. 
    more » « less