We consider the problem of optimal control of district cooling energy plants (DCEPs) consisting of multiple chillers, a cooling tower, and a thermal energy storage (TES), in the presence of time-varying electricity price. A straightforward application of model predictive control (MPC) requires solving a challenging mixed-integer nonlinear program (MINLP) because of the on/off of chillers and the complexity of the DCEP model. Reinforcement learning (RL) is an attractive alternative since its real-time control computation is much simpler. But designing an RL controller is challenging due to myriad design choices and computationally intensive training. In this paper, we propose an RL controller and an MPC controller for minimizing the electricity cost of a DCEP and compare them via simulations. The two controllers are designed to be comparable in terms of objective and information requirements. The RL controller uses a novel Q-learning algorithm that is based on least-squares policy iteration. We describe the design choices for the RL controller, including the choice of state space and basis functions, that are found to be effective. The proposed MPC controller does not need a mixed integer solver for implementation, but only a nonlinear program (NLP) solver. A rule-based baseline controller is also proposed to aid in comparison. Simulation results show that the proposed RL and MPC controllers achieve similar savings over the baseline controller, about 17%.
more »
« less
Reinforcement Learning-Based Home Energy Management System for Resiliency
With increase in the frequency of natural disasters such as hurricanes that disrupt the supply from the grid, there is a greater need for resiliency in electric supply. Rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) panels along with batteries can provide resiliency to a house in a blackout due to a natural disaster. Our previous work showed that intelligence can reduce the size of a PV+battery system for the same level of post-blackout service compared to a conventional system that does not employ intelligent control. The intelligent controller proposed is based on model predictive control (MPC), which has two main challenges. One, it requires simple yet accurate models as it involves real-time optimization. Two, the discrete actuation for residential loads (on/off) makes the underlying optimization problem a mixed-integer program (MIP) which is challenging to solve. An attractive alternative to MPC is reinforcement learning (RL) as the real-time control computation is both model-free and simple. These points of interest accompany certain trade-offs; RL requires computationally expensive offline learning, and its performance is sensitive to various design choices. In this work, we propose an RL-based controller. We compare its performance with the MPC controller proposed in our prior work and a non-intelligent baseline controller. The RL controller is found to provide a resiliency performance — by commanding critical loads and batteries—similar to MPC with a significant reduction in computational effort.
more »
« less
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10281416
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- American Control Conference
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1358 to 1364
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)Abstract An autonomous adaptive model predictive control (MPC) architecture is presented for control of heating, ventilation, and air condition (HVAC) systems to maintain indoor temperature while reducing energy use. Although equipment use and occupant changes with time, existing MPC methods are not capable of automatically relearning models and computing control decisions reliably for extended periods without intervention from a human expert. We seek to address this weakness. Two major features are embedded in the proposed architecture to enable autonomy: (i) a system identification algorithm from our prior work that periodically re-learns building dynamics and unmeasured internal heat loads from data without requiring re-tuning by experts. The estimated model is guaranteed to be stable and has desirable physical properties irrespective of the data; (ii) an MPC planner with a convex approximation of the original nonconvex problem. The planner uses a descent and convergent method, with the underlying optimization problem being feasible and convex. A yearlong simulation with a realistic plant shows that both of the features of the proposed architecture—periodic model and disturbance update and convexification of the planning problem—are essential to get performance improvement over a commonly used baseline controller. Without these features, long-term energy savings from MPC can be small while with them, the savings from MPC become substantial.more » « less
-
Model predictive control (MPC) has drawn a considerable amount of attention in automotive applications during the last decade, partially due to its systematic capacity of treating system constraints. Even though having received broad acknowledgements, there still exist two intrinsic shortcomings on this optimization-based control strategy, namely the extensive online calculation burden and the complex tuning process, which hinder MPC from being applied to a wider extent. To tackle these two drawbacks, different methods were proposed. Nevertheless, the majority of these approaches treat these two issues independently. However, parameter tuning in fact has double-sided effects on both the controller performance and the real-time computational burden. Due to the lack of theoretical tools for globally analyzing the complex conflicts among MPC parameter tuning, controller performance optimization, and computational burden easement, a look-up table-based online parameter selection method is proposed in this paper to help a vehicle track its reference path under both the stability and computational capacity constraints. matlab-carsim conjoint simulations show the effectiveness of the proposed strategy.more » « less
-
Learning a dynamical system requires stabilizing the unknown dynamics to avoid state blow-ups. However, the standard reinforcement learning (RL) methods lack formal stabilization guarantees, which limits their applicability for the control of real-world dynamical systems. We propose a novel policy optimization method that adopts Krasovskii's family of Lyapunov functions as a stability constraint. We show that solving this stability-constrained optimization problem using a primal-dual approach recovers a stabilizing policy for the underlying system even under modeling error. Combining this method with model learning, we propose a model-based RL framework with formal stability guarantees, Krasovskii-Constrained Reinforcement Learning (KCRL). We theoretically study KCRL with kernel-based feature representation in model learning and provide a sample complexity guarantee to learn a stabilizing controller for the underlying system. Further, we empirically demonstrate the effectiveness of KCRL in learning stabilizing policies in online voltage control of a distributed power system. We show that KCRL stabilizes the system under various real-world solar and electricity demand profiles, whereas standard RL methods often fail to stabilize.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Abstract Flooding in coastal cities is increasing due to climate change and sea-level rise, stressing the traditional stormwater systems these communities rely on. Automated real-time control (RTC) of these systems can improve performance, and creating control policies for smart stormwater systems is an active area of study. This research explores reinforcement learning (RL) to create control policies to mitigate flood risk. RL is trained using a model of hypothetical urban catchments with a tidal boundary and two retention ponds with controllable valves. RL's performance is compared to the passive system, a model predictive control (MPC) strategy, and a rule-based control strategy (RBC). RL learns to proactively manage pond levels using current and forecast conditions and reduced flooding by 32% over the passive system. Compared to the MPC approach using a physics-based model and genetic algorithm, RL achieved nearly the same flood reduction, just 3% less than MPC, with a significant 88× speedup in runtime. Compared to RBC, RL was able to quickly learn similar control strategies and reduced flooding by an additional 19%. This research demonstrates that RL can effectively control a simple system and offers a computationally efficient method that could scale to RTC of more complex stormwater systems.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/10.23919/ACC50511.2021.9483162
