skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Data Recovery from “Scrubbed” NAND Flash Storage: Need for Analog Sanitization
Digital sanitization of flash based non-volatile memory system is a well-researched topic. Since flash memory cell holds information in the analog threshold voltage, flash cell may hold the imprints of previously written data even after digital sanitization. In this paper, we show that data is partially or completely recoverable from the flash media sanitized with “scrubbing” based technique, which is a popular technique for page deletion in NAND flash. We find that adversary may utilize the data retention property of the memory cells for recovering the deleted data using standard digital interfaces with the memory. We demonstrate data recovery from commercial flash memory chip, sanitized with scrubbing, by using partial erase operation on the chip. Our results show that analog scrubbing is needed to securely delete information in flash system. We propose and implement analog scrubbing using partial program operation based on the file creation time information.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2007403
PAR ID:
10285913
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
29th USENIX Security Symposium
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Electronic device fingerprints, unique bit vectors extracted from device's physical properties, are used to differentiate between instances of functionally identical devices. This article introduces a new technique that extracts fingerprints from unique properties of partially erased NOR flash memory cells in modern microcontrollers. NOR flash memories integrated in modern systems-on-a-chip typically hold firmware and read-only data, but they are increasingly in-system-programmable, allowing designers to erase and program them during normal operation. The proposed technique leverages partial erase operations of flash memory segments that bring them into the state that exposes physical properties of the flash memory cells through a digital interface. These properties reflect semiconductor process variations and defects that are unique to each microcontroller or a flash memory segment within a microcontroller. The article explores threshold voltage variation in NOR flash memory cells for generating fingerprints and describes an algorithm for extracting fingerprints. The experimental evaluation utilizing a family of commercial microcontrollers demonstrates that the proposed technique is cost-effective, robust, and resilient to changes in voltage and temperature as well as to aging effects. 
    more » « less
  2. Instant data deletion (or sanitization) in NAND flash devices is essential for achieving data privacy, but it remains challenging due to the mismatch between erase and write granularities, which leads to high overhead and accelerated wear. While page-overwrite-based instant data sanitization has proven effective for 2D NAND, its applicability to 3D NAND is limited due to the unique sub-block architecture. In this study, we experimentally evaluate page-overwrite-based sanitization on commercial 3D NAND flash memory chips and uncover significant threshold voltage disturbances in erased cells on adjacent pages within the same layer but across different sub-blocks. Our key findings reveal that page-overwrite sanitization increases the median raw bit error rate (RBER) beyond correction limits (exceeding 0.93%) in Floating-Gate (FG) Single-Level Cell (SLC) technology, whereas Charge-Trap (CT) SLC 3D NAND flash memories exhibit higher robustness. In Triple-Level Cell (TLC) 3D NAND, page-overwrite sanitization proves impractical, with the median RBER of ∼13% for FG and ∼5% for CT devices. To overcome these challenges, we proposePULSE, a low-disturbance sanitization technique that balances sanitization efficiency ({{\eta }_{san}}) and data integrity (RBER). Experimental results show that PULSE eliminates RBER increases in SLC devices and reduces the median RBER to below 0.57% for FG and 0.79% for CT in fresh TLC blocks, demonstrating its practical viability for 3D NAND flash sanitization. 
    more » « less
  3. Vector-matrix multiplication (VMM) is a core operation in many signal and data processing algorithms. Previous work showed that analog multipliers based on nonvolatile memories have superior energy efficiency as compared to digital counterparts at low-to-medium computing precision. In this paper, we propose extremely energy efficient analog mode VMM circuit with digital input/output interface and configurable precision. Similar to some previous work, the computation is performed by gate-coupled circuit utilizing embedded floating gate (FG) memories. The main novelty of our approach is an ultra-low power sensing circuitry, which is designed based on translinear Gilbert cell in topological combination with a floating resistor and a low-gain amplifier. Additionally, the digital-to-analog input conversion is merged with VMM, while current-mode algorithmic analog-to-digital circuit is employed at the circuit backend. Such implementations of conversion and sensing allow for circuit operation entirely in a current domain, resulting in high performance and energy efficiency. For example, post-layout simulation results for 400×400 5-bit VMM circuit designed in 55 nm process with embedded NOR flash memory, show up to 400 MHz operation, 1.68 POps/J energy efficiency, and 39.45 TOps/mm2 computing throughput. Moreover, the circuit is robust against process-voltage-temperature variations, in part due to inclusion of additional FG cells that are utilized for offset compensation. 
    more » « less
  4. On-chip learning with compute-in-memory (CIM) paradigm has become popular in machine learning hardware design in the recent years. However, it is hard to achieve high on-chip learning accuracy due to the high nonlinearity in the weight update curve of emerging nonvolatile memory (eNVM) based analog synapse devices. Although digital synapse devices offer good learning accuracy, the row-by-row partial sum accumulation leads to high latency. In this paper, the methods to solve the aforementioned issues are presented with a device-to-algorithm level optimization. For analog synapses, novel hybrid precision synapses with good linearity and more advanced training algorithms are introduced to increase the on-chip learning accuracy. The latency issue for digital synapses can be solved by using parallel partial sum read-out scheme. All these features are included into the recently released MLP + NeuroSimV3.0, which is an in-house developed device-to-system evaluation framework for neuro-inspired accelerators based on CIM paradigm. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper presents a Ferroelectric FET (FeFET) based processing-in-memory (PIM) architecture to accelerate inference of deep neural networks (DNNs). We propose a digital in-memory vector-matrix multiplication (VMM) engine design utilizing the FeFET crossbar to enables bit-parallel computation and eliminate analog-to-digital conversion in prior mixed-signal PIM designs. A dedicated hierarchical network-on-chip (H-NoC) is developed for input broadcasting and on-the-fly partial results processing, reducing the data transmission volume and latency. Simulations in 28nm CMOS technology show 115x and 6.3x higher computing efficiency (GOPs/W) over desktop GPU (Nvidia GTX 1080Ti) and ReRAM based design, respectively. 
    more » « less