skip to main content


Title: Enzyme promiscuity prediction using hierarchy-informed multi-label classification
Abstract Motivation As experimental efforts are costly and time consuming, computational characterization of enzyme capabilities is an attractive alternative. We present and evaluate several machine-learning models to predict which of 983 distinct enzymes, as defined via the Enzyme Commission (EC) numbers, are likely to interact with a given query molecule. Our data consists of enzyme-substrate interactions from the BRENDA database. Some interactions are attributed to natural selection and involve the enzyme’s natural substrates. The majority of the interactions however involve non-natural substrates, thus reflecting promiscuous enzymatic activities. Results We frame this ‘enzyme promiscuity prediction’ problem as a multi-label classification task. We maximally utilize inhibitor and unlabeled data to train prediction models that can take advantage of known hierarchical relationships between enzyme classes. We report that a hierarchical multi-label neural network, EPP-HMCNF, is the best model for solving this problem, outperforming k-nearest neighbors similarity-based and other machine-learning models. We show that inhibitor information during training consistently improves predictive power, particularly for EPP-HMCNF. We also show that all promiscuity prediction models perform worse under a realistic data split when compared to a random data split, and when evaluating performance on non-natural substrates compared to natural substrates. Availability and implementation We provide Python code and data for EPP-HMCNF and other models in a repository termed EPP (Enzyme Promiscuity Prediction) at https://github.com/hassounlab/EPP. Supplementary information Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1909536
PAR ID:
10297149
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Editor(s):
Martelli, Pier Luigi
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Bioinformatics
Volume:
37
Issue:
14
ISSN:
1367-4803
Page Range / eLocation ID:
2017 to 2024
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Motivation

    While traditionally utilized for identifying site-specific metabolic activity within a compound to alter its interaction with a metabolizing enzyme, predicting the site-of-metabolism (SOM) is essential in analyzing the promiscuity of enzymes on substrates. The successful prediction of SOMs and the relevant promiscuous products has a wide range of applications that include creating extended metabolic models (EMMs) that account for enzyme promiscuity and the construction of novel heterologous synthesis pathways. There is therefore a need to develop generalized methods that can predict molecular SOMs for a wide range of metabolizing enzymes.

    Results

    This article develops a Graph Neural Network (GNN) model for the classification of an atom (or a bond) being an SOM. Our model, GNN-SOM, is trained on enzymatic interactions, available in the KEGG database, that span all enzyme commission numbers. We demonstrate that GNN-SOM consistently outperforms baseline machine learning models, when trained on all enzymes, on Cytochrome P450 (CYP) enzymes, or on non-CYP enzymes. We showcase the utility of GNN-SOM in prioritizing predicted enzymatic products due to enzyme promiscuity for two biological applications: the construction of EMMs and the construction of synthesis pathways.

    Availability and implementation

    A python implementation of the trained SOM predictor model can be found at https://github.com/HassounLab/GNN-SOM.

    Supplementary information

    Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Motivation

    Despite experimental and curation efforts, the extent of enzyme promiscuity on substrates continues to be largely unexplored and under documented. Providing computational tools for the exploration of the enzyme–substrate interaction space can expedite experimentation and benefit applications such as constructing synthesis pathways for novel biomolecules, identifying products of metabolism on ingested compounds, and elucidating xenobiotic metabolism. Recommender systems (RS), which are currently unexplored for the enzyme–substrate interaction prediction problem, can be utilized to provide enzyme recommendations for substrates, and vice versa. The performance of Collaborative-Filtering (CF) RSs; however, hinges on the quality of embedding vectors of users and items (enzymes and substrates in our case). Importantly, enhancing CF embeddings with heterogeneous auxiliary data, specially relational data (e.g. hierarchical, pairwise or groupings), remains a challenge.

    Results

    We propose an innovative general RS framework, termed Boost-RS that enhances RS performance by ‘boosting’ embedding vectors through auxiliary data. Specifically, Boost-RS is trained and dynamically tuned on multiple relevant auxiliary learning tasks Boost-RS utilizes contrastive learning tasks to exploit relational data. To show the efficacy of Boost-RS for the enzyme–substrate prediction interaction problem, we apply the Boost-RS framework to several baseline CF models. We show that each of our auxiliary tasks boosts learning of the embedding vectors, and that contrastive learning using Boost-RS outperforms attribute concatenation and multi-label learning. We also show that Boost-RS outperforms similarity-based models. Ablation studies and visualization of learned representations highlight the importance of using contrastive learning on some of the auxiliary data in boosting the embedding vectors.

    Availability and implementation

    A Python implementation for Boost-RS is provided at https://github.com/HassounLab/Boost-RS. The enzyme-substrate interaction data is available from the KEGG database (https://www.genome.jp/kegg/).

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Motivation

    Gene annotation is the problem of mapping proteins to their functions represented as Gene Ontology (GO) terms, typically inferred based on the primary sequences. Gene annotation is a multi-label multi-class classification problem, which has generated growing interest for its uses in the characterization of millions of proteins with unknown functions. However, there is no standard GO dataset used for benchmarking the newly developed new machine learning models within the bioinformatics community. Thus, the significance of improvements for these models remains unclear.

    Results

    The Gene Benchmarking database is the first effort to provide an easy-to-use and configurable hub for the learning and evaluation of gene annotation models. It provides easy access to pre-specified datasets and takes the non-trivial steps of preprocessing and filtering all data according to custom presets using a web interface. The GO bench web application can also be used to evaluate and display any trained model on leaderboards for annotation tasks.

    Availability and implementation

    The GO Benchmarking dataset is freely available at www.gobench.org. Code is hosted at github.com/mofradlab, with repositories for website code, core utilities and examples of usage (Supplementary Section S.7).

    Supplementary information

    Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

     
    more » « less
  4. Machine learning with missing data has been approached in two different ways, including feature imputation where missing feature values are estimated based on observed values and label prediction where downstream labels are learned directly from incomplete data. However, existing imputation models tend to have strong prior assumptions and cannot learn from downstream tasks, while models targeting label prediction often involve heuristics and can encounter scalability issues. Here we propose GRAPE, a graph-based framework for feature imputation as well as label prediction. GRAPE tackles the missing data problem using a graph representation, where the observations and features are viewed as two types of nodes in a bipartite graph, and the observed feature values as edges. Under the GRAPE framework, the feature imputation is formulated as an edge-level prediction task and the label prediction as a node-level prediction task. These tasks are then solved with Graph Neural Networks. Experimental results on nine benchmark datasets show that GRAPE yields 20% lower mean absolute error for imputation tasks and 10% lower for label prediction tasks, compared with existing state-of-the-art methods. 
    more » « less
  5. Multi-label classification is a challenging structured prediction task in which a set of output class labels are predicted for each input. Real-world datasets often have natural or latent taxonomic relationships between labels, making it desirable for models to employ label representations capable of capturing such taxonomies. Most existing multi-label classification methods do not do so, resulting in label predictions that are inconsistent with the taxonomic constraints, thus failing to accurately represent the fundamentals of problem setting. In this work, we introduce the multi-label box model (MBM), a multi-label classification method that combines the encoding power of neural networks with the inductive bias and probabilistic semantics of box embeddings (Vilnis, et al 2018). Box embeddings can be understood as trainable Venn-diagrams based on hyper-rectangles. Representing labels by boxes rather than vectors, MBM is able to capture taxonomic relations among labels. Furthermore, since box embeddings allow these relations to be learned by stochastic gradient descent from data, and to be read as calibrated conditional probabilities, our model is endowed with a high degree of interpretability. This interpretability also facilitates the injection of partial information about label-label relationships into model training, to further improve its consistency. We provide theoretical grounding for our method and show experimentally the model's ability to learn the true latent taxonomic structure from data. Through extensive empirical evaluations on both small and large-scale multi-label classification datasets, we show that BBM can significantly improve taxonomic consistency while preserving or surpassing the state-of-the-art predictive performance. 
    more » « less