skip to main content


Title: Longitudinal metabarcode analysis of karst bacterioplankton microbiomes provide evidence of epikarst to cave transport and community succession
Caves are often assumed to be static environments separated from weather changes experienced on the surface. The high humidity and stability of these subterranean environments make them attractive to many different organisms including microbes such as bacteria and protists. Cave waters generally originate from the surface, may be filtered by overlying soils, can accumulate in interstitial epikarst zones underground, and emerge in caves as streams, pools and droplets on speleothems. Water movement is the primary architect of karst caves, and depending on the hydrologic connectivity between surface and subsurface, is the most likely medium for the introduction of microbes to caves. Recently published metabarcoding surveys of karst cave soils and speleothems have suggested that the vast majority of bacteria residing in these habitats do not occur on the surface, calling into question the role of microbial transport by surface waters. The purpose of this study was to use metabarcoding to monitor the aquatic prokaryotic microbiome of a cave for 1 year, conduct longitudinal analyses of the cave’s aquatic bacterioplankton, and compare it to nearby surface water. Water samples were collected from two locations inside Panel Cave in Natural Tunnel State Park in Duffield, VA and two locations outside of the cave. Of the two cave locations, one was fed by groundwater and drip water and the other by infiltrating surface water. A total of 1,854 distinct prokaryotic ASVs were detected from cave samples and 245 (13.1%) were not found in surface samples. PCo analysis demonstrated a marginal delineation between two cave sample sites and between cave and surface microbiomes suggesting the aquatic bacterioplankton in a karst cave is much more similar to surface microbes than reported from speleothems and soils. Most surprisingly, there was a cave microbe population and diversity bloom in the fall months whereas biodiversity remained relatively steady on the surface. The cave microbiome was more similar to the surface before the bloom than during and afterwards. This event demonstrates that large influxes of bacteria and particulate organic matter can enter the cave from either the surface or interstitial zones and the divergence of the cave microbiome from the surface demonstrates movement of microbes from the epikarst zones into the cave.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1919491
NSF-PAR ID:
10298148
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
PeerJ
Volume:
9
ISSN:
2167-8359
Page Range / eLocation ID:
e10757
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Fe-bearing minerals are a tiny fraction of the composition of speleothems. They have their origin in the karst system or are transported from the drainage basin into the cave. Recent studies on the magnetism of speleothems focused on the variations of their magnetic mineralogy in specific time intervals and are usually limited to a single sample. In this study, we describe a database of environmental magnetism parameters built from 22 stalagmites from different caves located in Brazil (South America) at different latitudes, comprising different climates and biomes. The magnetic signal observed in these stalagmites is dominated by low-coercivity minerals (∼20 mT) whose magnetic properties resemble those of the magnetite formed in pedogenic environments. Also, a comparison with few samples from soils and the carbonate from cave’s walls shows a good agreement of the magnetic properties of speleothems with those of soil samples, reinforcing previous suggestions that in (sub-)tropical regimes, the dominant magnetic phase in speleothems is associated with the soil above the cave. Spearman’s rank correlation points to a positive strong correlation between magnetic concentration parameters (mass-normalized magnetic susceptibility, natural remanent magnetization, anhysteretic remanent magnetization, and isothermal remanent magnetization). This implies that ultrafine ferrimagnetic minerals are the dominant phase in these (sub-)tropical karst systems, which extend across a diverse range of biomes. Although the samples are concentrated in the savannah biome (Cerrado) (∼70%), comparison with other biomes shows a higher concentration of magnetic minerals in speleothem underlying savannahs and lower concentration in those underlying moist broadleaf forests (Atlantic and Amazon biome) and dry forests (Caatinga). Thus, rainfall, biome, and epikarst dynamics play an important role in the concentration of magnetic minerals in speleothems in (sub-)tropical sites and indicate they can be an important target for paleoenvironmental research in cave systems. 
    more » « less
  2. In the past decade, Huagapo and Pacupahuain Caves in the Central Peruvian Andes have become sources of speleothem oxygen isotope (δ18O) paleoclimate records. These studies identify the South American Summer Monsoon (SASM) as the main climate system controlling δ18O variability. While this interpretation is verified through inter-proxy record comparisons on millennial scales, interpretation of the high-resolution variability within these records is limited by a lack of modern proxy calibration studies at these sites. Here we present results from a modern cave monitoring study undertaken to address the controls on the δ18O values of precipitation at these sites and how surface and in-cave processes affect the δ18O value of speleothem calcite. Speleothem calcite δ18O values reflect an integrated signal of atmospheric processes (e.g., rainout, Raleigh distillation, upstream moisture recycling, changes in moisture source), evaporation and mixing during infiltration in the soil and epikarst, and in-cave processes such as degassing and evaporation. In consideration of these factors, we compare isotope trends in precipitation, cave drip water and modern farmed calcite from the two cave sites. We find that precipitationδ18O values during peak monsoon activity (January -February) shows considerable inter-annual variation with averages of -16.7‰ for 2020, -18.5‰ for 2021 and -13.8‰ in 2022. We investigate the source of this variability in regional atmospheric circulation patterns using weather station data and back trajectories. The mean annual precipitation (MAP) from outside Huagapo Cave is δ18O = -15.5+/- 6‰, while seasonal samples of drip water δ18O = -14.5+/- 1‰, are offset from MAP possibly due to evaporation during infiltration. Cave drip waterδ18O has low variability over inter-annual and seasonal timescales indicating homogenization in the epikarst. Using geochemical and sensor data (e.g. cave relative humidity, temperature, and drip rate) as inputs for a karst based forward model, we simulate modern speleothem δ18O to quantitatively assess the combined effects of hydroclimate processes integration to the isotope record. 
    more » « less
  3. Recent developments in speleothem science are showing their potential for paleofire reconstruction through a variety of inorganic and organic proxies including trace metals (1) and the pyrogenic organic compound levoglucosan (2). Previous work by Argiriadis et al. (2019) presented a method for the analysis of trace polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and n -alkanes in stalagmites (3). These compounds reflect biogeochemical processes occurring at the land surface, in the soil, and in the cave. PAHs are primarily related to combustion of biomass while n-alkanes, with their potential for vegetation reconstruction (4), provide information on fuel availability and composition, as well as fire activity. These organic molecules are carried downward by infiltrating water and incorporated into speleothems (5), thereby creating the potential to serve as novel paleofire archives. Using this approach, we developed a high-resolution stalagmite record of paleofire activity from cave KNI-51 in tropical northwestern Australia. This site is well suited for high resolution paleofire reconstruction as bushfire activity in this tropical savanna is some of the highest on the continent, the cave is shallow and overlain by extremely thin soils, and the stalagmites are fast-growing (1-2 mm yr-1) and precisely dated. We analyzed three stalagmites which grew continuously in different time intervals through the last millennium - KNI-51-F (CE ~1100-1620), KNI-51-G (CE ~1320-1640), and KNI-51-11 (CE ~1750-2009). Samples were drilled continuously at 1-3 mm resolution from stalagmite slabs, processed in a stainless-steel cleanroom to prevent contamination. Despite a difference in resolution between stalagmites KNI-51-F and -G, peaks in the target compounds show good replication in the overlapping time interval of the two stalagmites, and PAH abundances in a portion of stalagmite KNI-51-11 that grew from CE 2000-2009 are well correlated with satellite-mapped fires occurring proximally to the cave. Our results suggest an increase in the frequency of low intensity fire in the 20th century relative to much of the previous millennium. The timing of this shift is broadly coincident with the arrival of European pastoralists in the late 19th century and the subsequent displacement of Aboriginal peoples from the land. Aboriginal peoples had previously utilized “fire stick farming”, a method of prescribed, low intensity burning, that was an important influence of ecology, biomass, and fire. Prior to the late 1800s, the period with the most frequent low intensity fire activity was the 13th century, the wettest interval of the entire record. Peak high intensity fire activity occurred during the 12th century. Controlled burn and irrigation experiments capable of examining the transmission of pyrogenic compounds from the land surface to cave dripwater represent the next step in this analysis. Given that karst is present in many fire-prone environments, and that stalagmites can be precisely dated and grow continuously for millennia, the potential utility of a stalagmite-based paleofire proxy is high. (1) L.K. McDonough et al., Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta. 325, 258–277 (2022). (2) J. Homann et al., Nat. Commun., 13:7175 (2022). (3) E. Argiriadis et al., Anal. Chem. 91, 7007–7011 (2019). (4) R.T. Bush, F. A. McInerney, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta. 117, 161–179 (2013). (5) Y. Sun et al., Chemosphere. 230, 616–627 (2019). 
    more » « less
  4. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are produced by the burning of biomass, with molecular weights reflecting combustion conditions. After being formed, PAHs are transported downward through soil and bedrock by infiltrating rainwater (Perrette et al., 2013), and in karst areas can become incorporated into stalagmites as they crystallize from dripwater in underlying caves (Perrette et al., 2008; Denniston et al., 2018). Thus, when stalagmite growth is high, infiltration times short, and fluid mixing minimized, there exists the potential for PAHs in stalagmites to preserve evidence of the presence and intensity of fire through time. We have previously reported a high-resolution analysis of PAH distributions in two non-overlapping aragonite stalagmites from cave KNI-51, tropical Western Australia, that together span the majority of the last 900 years. The geologic conditions of this site make it well suited for the transmission of discrete pulses of fire-derived compounds from the land surface to the stalagmite. Soils are thin to absent above the stalagmite chamber and the cave is shallow. As a result, homogenization of infiltrated water (and thus PAHs) is expected to be small on interannual time scales. In addition, intense summer monsoon rains flush fire debris from the hillsides over the cave. These characteristics, coupled with the fast growth rates (1-2 mm/yr) and precise radiometric dates (±1-30 years 2 s.d. over the last millennium) of KNI-51 stalagmites suggest that they hold the potential for extremely high resolution paleofire reconstruction. Here we provide the first test of replication of PAH abundances, ratios, and trends in coeval stalagmites. Samples were analyzed at Ca’ Foscari University using methods of Argiriadis et al. (2019) and the results validated by comparing them with fire activity detected through satellite images. Stalagmites KNI-51-F and -G overlap in age from CE 1310-1630, allowing an examination of the consistency of the PAH signal along different infiltration pathways. References Argiriadis, E. et al. (2019) European Geosciences Union Annual Meeting, Vienna, Australia. Denniston, R.F. et al. (2018) American Geophysical Union Annual Meeting, Washington, D.C. Perrette, Y. et al. (2008) Chemical Geology, 251, 67-76. Perrette, Y. et al. (2013) Organic Geochemistry, 65, 37-45. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Caves deliver freshwater from coastal carbonate landscapes to estuaries but how these caves form and grow remains poorly understood. Models suggest fresh and salt water mixing drives dissolution in eogenetic limestone, but have rarely been validated through sampling of mixing waters. Here we assess controls on carbonate mineral saturation states using new and legacy geochemical data that were collected in vertical profiles through three cenotes and one borehole in the Yucatan Peninsula. Results suggest saturation states are primarily controlled by carbon fluxes rather than mixing. Undersaturation predicted by mixing models that rely on idealized end members is diminished or eliminated when end members are collected from above and below actual mixing zones. Undersaturation due to mixing is limited by CO2degassing from fresh water in karst windows, which results in calcite supersaturation. With respect to saline groundwater, controls on capacity for mixing dissolution were more varied. Oxidation of organic carbon increased pCO2of saline groundwater in caves (pCO2 = 10–2.06to 10–0.96 atm) relative to matrix porosity (10–2.39 atm) and local seawater (10–3.12 atm). The impact of increased pCO2on saturation state, however, depended on the geochemical composition of the saline water and the magnitude of organic carbon oxidation. Carbonate undersaturation due to mixing was limited where gypsum dissolution (Cenote Angelita) or sulfate reduction (Cenote Calica) increased concentrations of common ions (Ca2+or HCO3, respectively). Maximum undersaturation was found to occur in mixtures including saline water that had ion concentrations and ratios similar to seawater, but with moderately elevated pCO2(Cenote Eden). Undersaturation, however, was dominated by the initial undersaturation of the saline end member, mixing was irrelevant. Our results add to a growing body of literature that suggests oxidation of organic carbon, and not mixing dissolution, is the dominant control on cave formation and enlargement in coastal eogenetic karst aquifers. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

     
    more » « less