skip to main content

Title: Non-destructive quantification of anaerobic gut fungi and methanogens in co-culture reveals increased fungal growth rate and changes in metabolic flux relative to mono-culture
Abstract Background

Quantification of individual species in microbial co-cultures and consortia is critical to understanding and designing communities with prescribed functions. However, it is difficult to physically separate species or measure species-specific attributes in most multi-species systems. Anaerobic gut fungi (AGF) (Neocallimastigomycetes) are native to the rumen of large herbivores, where they exist as minority members among a wealth of prokaryotes. AGF have significant biotechnological potential owing to their diverse repertoire of potent lignocellulose-degrading carbohydrate-active enzymes (CAZymes), which indirectly bolsters activity of other rumen microbes through metabolic exchange. While decades of literature suggest that polysaccharide degradation and AGF growth are accelerated in co-culture with prokaryotes, particularly methanogens, methods have not been available to measure concentrations of individual species in co-culture. New methods to disentangle the contributions of AGF and rumen prokaryotes are sorely needed to calculate AGF growth rates and metabolic fluxes to prove this hypothesis and understand its causality for predictable co-culture design.


We present a simple, microplate-based method to measure AGF and methanogen concentrations in co-culture based on fluorescence and absorbance spectroscopies. Using samples of < 2% of the co-culture volume, we demonstrate significant increases in AGF growth rate and xylan and glucose degradation rates in co-culture with methanogens relative to mono-culture. Further, we calculate significant differences in AGF metabolic fluxes in co-culture relative to mono-culture, namely increased flux through the energy-generating hydrogenosome organelle. While calculated fluxes highlight uncertainties in AGF primary metabolism that preclude definitive explanations for this shift, our method will enable steady-state fluxomic experiments to probe AGF metabolism in greater detail.


The method we present to measure AGF and methanogen concentrations enables direct growth measurements and calculation of metabolic fluxes in co-culture. These metrics are critical to develop a quantitative understanding of interwoven rumen metabolism, as well as the impact of co-culture on polysaccharide degradation and metabolite production. The framework presented here can inspire new methods to probe systems beyond AGF and methanogens. Simple modifications to the method will likely extend its utility to co-cultures with more than two organisms or those grown on solid substrates to facilitate the design and deployment of microbial communities for bioproduction and beyond.

more » « less
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Springer Science + Business Media
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Microbial Cell Factories
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Zhao, Liping ; Bello, Maria Gloria (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT Complex interactions exist among microorganisms in a community to carry out ecological processes and adapt to changing environments. Here, we constructed a quad-culture consisting of a cellulolytic bacterium ( Ruminiclostridium cellulolyticum ), a hydrogenotrophic methanogen ( Methanospirillum hungatei ), an acetoclastic methanogen ( Methanosaeta concilii ), and a sulfate-reducing bacterium ( Desulfovibrio vulgaris ). The four microorganisms in the quad-culture cooperated via cross-feeding to produce methane using cellulose as the only carbon source and electron donor. The community metabolism of the quad-culture was compared with those of the R. cellulolyticum -containing tri-cultures, bi-cultures, and mono-culture. Methane production was higher in the quad-culture than the sum of the increases in the tri-cultures, which was attributed to a positive synergy of four species. In contrast, cellulose degradation by the quad-culture was lower than the additive effects of the tri-cultures which represented a negative synergy. The community metabolism of the quad-culture was compared between a control condition and a treatment condition with sulfate addition using metaproteomics and metabolic profiling. Sulfate addition enhanced sulfate reduction and decreased methane and CO 2 productions. The cross-feeding fluxes in the quad-culture in the two conditions were modeled using a community stoichiometric model. Sulfate addition strengthened metabolic handoffs from R. cellulolyticum to M. concilii and D. vulgaris and intensified substrate competition between M. hungatei and D. vulgaris . Overall, this study uncovered emergent properties of higher-order microbial interactions using a four-species synthetic community. IMPORTANCE A synthetic community was designed using four microbial species that together performed distinct key metabolic processes in the anaerobic degradation of cellulose to methane and CO 2 . The microorganisms exhibited expected interactions, such as cross-feeding of acetate from a cellulolytic bacterium to an acetoclastic methanogen and competition of H 2 between a sulfate reducing bacterium and a hydrogenotrophic methanogen. This validated our rational design of the interactions between microorganisms based on their metabolic roles. More interestingly, we also found positive and negative synergies as emergent properties of high-order microbial interactions among three or more microorganisms in cocultures. These microbial interactions can be quantitatively measured by adding and removing specific members. A community stoichiometric model was constructed to represent the fluxes in the community metabolic network. This study paved the way toward a more predictive understanding of the impact of environmental perturbations on microbial interactions sustaining geochemically significant processes in natural systems. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Anaerobic fungi and methanogenic archaea are two classes of microorganisms found in the rumen microbiome that metabolically interact during lignocellulose breakdown. Here, stable synthetic co-cultures of the anaerobic fungusCaecomyces churrovisand the methanogenMethanobacterium bryantii(not native to the rumen) were formed, demonstrating that microbes from different environments can be paired based on metabolic ties. Transcriptional and metabolic changes induced by methanogen co-culture were evaluated inC. churrovisacross a variety of substrates to identify mechanisms that impact biomass breakdown and sugar uptake. A high-quality genome ofC. churroviswas obtained and annotated, which is the first sequenced genome of a non-rhizoid-forming anaerobic fungus.C. churrovispossess an abundance of CAZymes and carbohydrate binding modules and, in agreement with previous studies of early-diverging fungal lineages, N6-methyldeoxyadenine (6mA) was associated with transcriptionally active genes. Co-culture with the methanogen increased overall transcription of CAZymes, carbohydrate binding modules, and dockerin domains in co-cultures grown on both lignocellulose and cellulose and caused upregulation of genes coding associated enzymatic machinery including carbohydrate binding modules in family 18 and dockerin domains across multiple growth substrates relative toC. churrovismonoculture. Two other fungal strains grown on a reed canary grass substrate in co-culture with the same methanogen also exhibited high log2-fold change values for upregulation of genes encoding carbohydrate binding modules in families 1 and 18. Transcriptional upregulation indicated that co-culture of theC. churrovisstrain with a methanogen may enhance pyruvate formate lyase (PFL) function for growth on xylan and fructose and production of bottleneck enzymes in sugar utilization pathways, further supporting the hypothesis that co-culture with a methanogen may enhance certain fungal metabolic functions. Upregulation of CBM18 may play a role in fungal–methanogen physical associations and fungal cell wall development and remodeling.

    more » « less
  3. Summary

    In contrast to the current paradigm of using microbial mono‐cultures in most biotechnological applications, increasing efforts are being directed towards engineering mixed‐species consortia to perform functions that are difficult to programme into individual strains. In this work, we developed a synthetic microbial consortium composed of two genetically engineered microbes, a cyanobacterium (Synechococcus elongatusPCC 7942) and a heterotrophic bacterium (Pseudomonas putidaEM173). These microbial species specialize in the co‐culture: cyanobacteria fix CO2through photosynthetic metabolism and secrete sufficient carbohydrates to support the growth and active metabolism ofP. putida, which has been engineered to consume sucrose and to degrade the environmental pollutant 2,4‐dinitrotoluene (2,4‐DNT). By encapsulatingS. elongatuswithin a barium–alginate hydrogel, cyanobacterial cells were protected from the toxic effects of 2,4‐DNT, enhancing the performance of the co‐culture. The synthetic consortium was able to convert 2,4‐DNT with light and CO2as key inputs, and its catalytic performance was stable over time. Furthermore, cycling this synthetic consortium through low nitrogen medium promoted the sucrose‐dependent accumulation of polyhydroxyalkanoate, an added‐value biopolymer, in the engineeredP. putidastrain. Altogether, the synthetic consortium displayed the capacity to remediate the industrial pollutant 2,4‐DNT while simultaneously synthesizing biopolymers using light and CO2as the primary inputs.

    more » « less
  4. Abstract Background

    Microbial co-cultures and consortia are of interest in cell-based molecular production and even as “smart” therapeutics in that one can take advantage of division of labor and specialization to expand both the range of available functions and mechanisms for control. The development of tools that enable coordination and modulation of consortia will be crucial for future application of multi-population cultures. In particular, these systems would benefit from an expanded toolset that enables orthogonal inter-strain communication.


    We created a co-culture for the synthesis of a redox-active phenazine signaling molecule, pyocyanin (PYO), by dividing its synthesis into the generation of its intermediate, phenazine carboxylic acid (PCA) from the first strain, followed by consumption of PCA and generation of PYO in a second strain. Interestingly, both PCA and PYO can be used to actuate gene expression in cells engineered with thesoxRSoxidative stress regulon, although importantly this signaling activity was found to depend on growth media. That is, like other signaling motifs in bacterial systems, the signaling activity is context dependent. We then used this co-culture’s phenazine signals in a tri-culture to modulate gene expression and production of three model products: quorum sensing molecule autoinducer-1 and two fluorescent marker proteins, eGFP and DsRed. We also showed how these redox-based signals could be intermingled with other quorum-sensing (QS) signals which are more commonly used in synthetic biology, to control complex behaviors. To provide control over product synthesis in the tri-cultures, we also showed how a QS-induced growth control module could guide metabolic flux in one population and at the same time guide overall tri-culture function. Specifically, we showed that phenazine signal recognition, enabled through the oxidative stress response regulonsoxRS,was dependent on media composition such that signal propagation within our parsed synthetic system could guide different desired outcomes based on the prevailing environment. In doing so, we expanded the range of signaling molecules available for coordination and the modes by which they can be utilized to influence overall function of a multi-population culture.


    Our results show that redox-based signaling can be intermingled with other quorum sensing signaling in ways that enable user-defined control of microbial consortia yielding various outcomes defined by culture medium. Further, we demonstrated the utility of our previously designed growth control module in influencing signal propagation and metabolic activity is unimpeded by orthogonal redox-based signaling. By exploring novel multi-modal strategies for guiding communication and consortia outcome, the concepts introduced here may prove to be useful for coordination of multiple populations within complex microbial systems.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Human‐induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) hold the promise to improve cell‐based therapies. Yet, to meet rising demands and become clinically impactful, sufficient high‐quality iPSCs in quantity must be generated, a task that exceeds current capabilities. In this study, K3 iPSCs cultures were examined using parallel‐labeling metabolic flux analysis (13C‐MFA) to quantify intracellular fluxes at relevant bioprocessing stages: glucose concentrations representative of initial media concentrations and high lactate concentrations representative of fed‐batch culture conditions, prior to and after bolus glucose feeds. The glucose and lactate concentrations are also representative of concentrations that might be encountered at different locations within 3D cell aggregates. Furthermore, a novel method was developed to allow the isotopic tracer [U‐13C3] lactate to be used in the13C‐MFA model. The results indicated that high extracellular lactate concentrations decreased glucose consumption and lactate production, while glucose concentrations alone did not affect rates of aerobic glycolysis. Moreover, for the high lactate cultures, lactate was used as a metabolic substrate to support oxidative mitochondrial metabolism. These results demonstrate that iPSCs have metabolic flexibility and possess the capacity to metabolize lactate to support exponential growth, and that high lactate concentrations alone do not adversely impact iPSC proliferation.

    more » « less