An official website of the United States government
Multirotor configurations introduce complicated aerodynamic and aeroacoustic interactions that must be considered during aircraft design. In this paper we explore two numerical methods to model the acoustic noise caused by aerodynamic rotor-on-rotor interactions of rotors in hover. The first method uses a conventional mesh-based unsteady Reynolds-average Navier-Stokes (URANS) solver, while the second consists of a meshless Lagrangian solver based on the viscous vortex particle method (VPM). Both methods are coupled with an aeroacoustics solver for tonal and broadband noise predictions. Noise predictions are validated for single and multi-rotor configurations, obtaining with the VPM a similar accuracy than URANS while being two orders of magnitude faster. We characterize the interactions of two side-by-side rotors in hover as the tip-to-tip distance and downstream spacing are varied. At an observer located six diameters away, multirotor noise is the strongest above and below the rotors, increasing by about 10 dBA directly underneath as the rotors are brought closer together. The interactions show no sensitivity to blade loading distribution, indicating that multirotor interactions are not alleviated with a lighter tip loading. We found that noise can be mitigated by spacing the rotors in the downstream direction—with the optimal spacing being about half a diameter—achieving a noise decrease of about 4 dBA without any aerodynamic penalties.
more »
« less
Rotor-on-Rotor Aeroacoustic Interactions of Multirotor in Hover
Multirotor configurations introduce complicated aerodynamic and aeroacoustic interactions that must be considered during aircraft design. In this paper we explore two numerical methods to model the acoustic noise caused by aerodynamic rotor-on-rotor interactions of rotors in hover. The first method uses a conventional mesh-based unsteady Reynolds-average Navier-Stokes (URANS) solver, while the second consists of a meshless Lagrangian solver based on the viscous vortex particle method (VPM). Both methods are coupled with an aeroacoustics solver for tonal and broadband noise predictions. Noise predictions are validated for single and multi-rotor configurations, obtaining with the VPM a similar accuracy than URANS while being two orders of magnitude faster. We characterize the interactions of two side-by-side rotors in hover as the tip-to-tip distance and downstream spacing are varied. At an observer located six diameters away, multirotor noise is the strongest above and below the rotors, increasing by about 10 dBA directly underneath as the rotors are brought closer together. The interactions show no sensitivity to blade loading distribution, indicating that multirotor interactions are not alleviated with a lighter tip loading. We found that noise can be mitigated by spacing the rotors in the downstream direction—with the optimal spacing being about half a diameter—achieving a noise decrease of about 4 dBA without any aerodynamic penalties.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1650547
- PAR ID:
- 10316279
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of the American Helicopter Society
- ISSN:
- 2161-6027
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
View Video Presentation: https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2022-3218.vid The ability to accurately and rapidly assess unsteady interactional aerodynamics is a shortcoming and bottleneck in the design of various next-generation aerospace systems: from electric vertical takeoff and landing (eVTOL) aircraft to airborne wind energy (AWE) and wind farms. In this study, we present a meshless CFD framework based on the reformulated vortex particle method (rVPM) for the analysis of complex interactional aerodynamics. The rVPM is a large eddy simulation (LES) solving the Navier-Stokes equations in their vorticity form. It uses a meshless Lagrangian scheme, which not only avoids the hurdles of mesh generation, but it also conserves the vortical structure of wakes over long distances with minimal numerical dissipation, while being 100x faster than conventional mesh-based LES. Wings and rotating blades are introduced in the computational domain through actuator line and actuator surface models. Simulations are coupled with an aeroacoustics solver to predict tonal and broadband noise radiated by rotors. The framework, called FLOWUnsteady, is hereby released as an open-source code and extensively validated. Validation studies published in previous work by the authors are summarized, showcasing rotors across operating conditions with a rotor in hover, propellers, a wind turbine, and two side-by-side rotors in hover. Validation of rotor-wing interactions is presented simulating a tailplane with tip-mounted propellers and a blown wing with propellers mounted mid-span. The capabilities of the framework are showcased through the simulation of a tiltwing eVTOL vehicle and an AWE wind-harvesting aircraft, featuring rotors with variable RPM, variable pitch, tilting of wings and rotors, non-trivial flight paths, and complex aerodynamic interactions.more » « less
-
A multirotor trim module is developed for the HPCMP CREATETM-AV Helios rotorcraft simulation code. Trimmed free-flight simulation results are presented for two multirotor configurations, using rotor frequencies and aircraft attitudes as the control variables. The loose-coupling procedure is used to achieve trim, where aerodynamic loading on the rotor blades and fuselage are computed using a simplified aerodynamic model, and modified at each coupling iteration using the airloads computed by the higher fidelity CFD based aerodynamics. Two different optimization methods are tested: a least-square regression algorithm, with the norm of the loads at the center of gravity as the objective function, and a nonlinear constrained optimization code, with the total power as the objective function, and with constraints applied to satisfy trim. First, a commercial small-scale UAV is simulated in forward flight. A reference model for midscale UAM applications is then trimmed in hover to demonstrate the module’s ability to model and trim a complex configuration.more » « less
-
This paper investigates the aeroacoustic interactions of small hovering rotors, using both experiments and computations. The experiments were conducted in an anechoic chamber with arrays of microphones setup to evaluate the azimuthal and polar directivity. The computational methodology consists of high fidelity detached eddy simulations coupled to the Ffowcs-Williams and Hawkings equation, supplemented by a trailing edge broadband noise code. The aerodynamics and aeroacoustics of a single rotor are investigated first. The simulations capture a Reynolds number effect seen in the performance parameters that results in the coefficient of thrust changing with the RPM. The acoustic analysis enables the identification of self-induced noise sources. Next, dual side-by-side rotors are studied in both counter-rotating and co-rotating configurations to quantify the impact of their interactions. Higher harmonics appear due to the interactions and it is verified that the counter-rotating case leads to more noise and a less uniform azimuthal directivity. Difficulties that arise when trying to validate small rotor calculations against experiments are discussed. Comparisons of computational and experimental results yield further insight into the noise mechanisms that are captured by each methodology.more » « less
-
The vortex particle method (VPM) has gained popularity in recent years due to a growing need to predict complex aerodynamic interactions during the preliminary design of electric multirotor aircraft. However, VPM is known to be numerically unstable when vortical structures break down close to the turbulent regime. In recent work, the VPM has been reformulated as a large-eddy simulation (LES) in a scheme that is both meshless and numerically stable without increasing its computational cost. In this study, we build upon this meshless LES scheme to create a solver for interactional aerodynamics. Propeller blades are introduced through an actuator line model following well-established practices for LES. A novel, vorticity-based actuator surface model (ASM) is developed for wings, which is suitable for propeller–wing interactions when a wake impinges on the surface of a wing. This ASM imposes the no-flow-through condition at the airfoil centerline by calculating the circulation that meets this condition and by immersing the associated vorticity in the LES following a pressure-like distribution. Extensive validation of propeller–wing interactions is presented by simulating a tailplane with tip-mounted propellers and a blown wing with propellers mounted midspan.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- The DOI is not currently available.
