skip to main content


Title: PP12B-05 and CO2 14C - Constraints on the Deglacial Release of Geologic Carbon Using Atmospheric Records
While a reinvigoration of ocean circulation and CO 2 marine geologic carbon release over the last 20,000 years. Much of this evidence points to outgassing is the leading explanation for atmospheric CO rise since the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), there is also evidence of regions of the mid-depth Pacific Ocean, where multiple radiocarbon (1 4 C) records show anomalously low 14 C/C values, potentially caused by the addition of carbon [1,2]. To better constrain this geologic carbon release hypothesis, we aim to place 14 C-free geologic an upper bound limit on the amount of carbon that may have been added, in addition to the geochemical pathway of that carbon. To do so, we numerical invert a carbon cycle model based on observational atmospheric CO 2 and 14 C records. Given these observational constraints, we use data assimilation techniques and an optimization algorithm to calculate the rate of carbon addition and its alkalinity-to-carbon ratio (R ) over the last 20,000 A/C years. Using the modeled planetary radiocarbon budget calculated in Hain et al. [3], we find observations allow for only ~300 Pg of carbon to be added, as a majority of the deglacial atmospheric 14 C decline is already explained by magnetic field strength changes and ocean circulation changes [3]. However, when we adjust the initial state of the model by increasing C by 75‰ to match the observational C records, we find that observations 14 14 allow for ~3500 Pg of carbon addition with an average R of ~1.4. A/C These results allow for the possibility of a large release of 14C-free geologic carbon, which could provide local and regional 14C anomalies, as the records have in the Pacific [1,2]. As this geological carbon was added with a RA/C of ~1.4, these results also imply that 14C evidence for significant geologic carbon release since the LGM may not be taken as contributing to deglacial CO2 rise, unless there is evidence for significant local acidification and corrosion of seafloor sediments. If the geologic carbon cycle is indeed more dynamic than previously thought, we may also need to rethink the approach to estimate the land/ocean carbon repartitioning from the deglacial stable carbon isotope budget. [1] Rafter et al. (2019), GRL 46(23), 13950–13960. [2] Ronge et al. (2016), Nature Communications 7(1), 11487. [3] Hain et al. (2014), EPSL 394, 198–208.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2032340
PAR ID:
10320212
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
AGU Fall Meeting
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The observation of extremely low radiocarbon content / old radiocarbon ages (>4000 years old) in the intermediate-depth ocean during the last ice age draws attention to our incomplete understanding of ocean carbon cycling. For example, glacial-interglacial seawater 14C anomalies near the Gulf of California have been explained by both the advection from a 14C-depleted abyssal source and local geologic carbon flux. To provide insight to this the origin of the seawater 14C anomalies, we have produced several new records of glacial-interglacial intermediate water (i.e., 14C, δ11B, δ18O, and δ13C) in waters that are “upstream” and “downstream” of the Gulf of California. These observations plus geochemical modeling allow us to: (1) Answer whether the old seawater 14C ages are advected or produced locally; (2) Identify the approximate chemical make-up of this carbon; and (3) Consider the role of known sedimentary processes in this carbon flux to the ocean. (Note that several sites have age model controls based on terrestrial plant 14C ages, providing more confidence in our results.) Our new measurements and modeling indicate that the well-established >4000-year-old seawater 14C anomalies observed near known seafloor volcanism in the Gulf of California are not present “upstream,” indicating that this carbon flux results from a “local” geologic carbon. Furthermore, based on our new benthic foraminifera δ11B measurements, this local carbon Blux does not appear to affect seawater pH. Finally, we suggest several potential geologic carbon source(s) that could explain the anomalously old seawater 14C ages, the relatively unremarkable changes in seawater δ13C, and the essentially negligible change in seawater pH. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT There is a growing database of radiocarbon ( 14 C) reconstructions from biogenic carbonate taken from marine sediment cores being used to investigate changing ocean circulation and carbon cycling at the end of the last great ice age. Reported here are 14 C results from a marine core taken in the Makassar Straits of the western equatorial Pacific that was intended to test whether there was evidence of geologic carbon release to the ocean during the glacial termination. A thorough investigation of planktic and benthic 14 C ages with stable isotopes and CT-scans revealed extensive burrowing in the upper 2 m of the core that displaced younger sediments downward by more than half a meter into the glacial section of the core. The vertical displacement is evident in both planktic and benthic fossils. However, the extent of displacement and the stratigraphic disturbance became evident only after multiple measurements of different species and genera. A CT-scan prior to sampling would be an effective screening tool to avoid sampling problem cores such as this. 
    more » « less
  3. Radiocarbon (14C) is a critical tool for understanding the global carbon cycle. During the Anthropocene, two new processes influenced14C in atmospheric, land and ocean carbon reservoirs. First,14C-free carbon derived from fossil fuel burning has diluted14C, at rates that have accelerated with time. Second, ‘bomb’14C produced by atmospheric nuclear weapon tests in the mid-twentieth century provided a global isotope tracer that is used to constrain rates of air–sea gas exchange, carbon turnover, large-scale atmospheric and ocean transport, and other key C cycle processes. As we write, the14C/12C ratio of atmospheric CO2is dropping below pre-industrial levels, and the rate of decline in the future will depend on global fossil fuel use and net exchange of bomb14C between the atmosphere, ocean and land. This milestone coincides with a rapid increase in14C measurement capacity worldwide. Leveraging future14C measurements to understand processes and test models requires coordinated international effort—a ‘decade of radiocarbon’ with multiple goals: (i) filling observational gaps using archives, (ii) building and sustaining observation networks to increase measurement density across carbon reservoirs, (iii) developing databases, synthesis and modelling tools and (iv) establishing metrics for identifying and verifying changes in carbon sources and sinks.

    This article is part of the Theo Murphy meeting issue 'Radiocarbon in the Anthropocene'.

     
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Abstract. During the early part of the last glacial termination (17.2–15 ka) and coincident with a ∼35 ppm rise in atmospheric CO2, a sharp 0.3‰–0.4‰ decline in atmospheric δ13CO2 occurred, potentially constraining the key processes that account for the early deglacial CO2 rise. A comparable δ13C decline has also been documented in numerous marine proxy records from surface and thermocline-dwelling planktic foraminifera. The δ13C decline recorded in planktic foraminifera has previously been attributed to the release of respired carbon from the deep ocean that was subsequently transported within the upper ocean to sites where the signal was recorded (and then ultimately transferred to the atmosphere). Benthic δ13C records from the global upper ocean, including a new record presented here from the tropical Pacific, also document this distinct early deglacial δ13C decline. Here we present modeling evidence to show that rather than respired carbon from the deep ocean propagating directly to the upper ocean prior to reaching the atmosphere, the carbon would have first upwelled to the surface in the Southern Ocean where it would have entered the atmosphere. In this way the transmission of isotopically light carbon to the global upper ocean was analogous to the ongoing ocean invasion of fossil fuel CO2. The model results suggest that thermocline waters throughout the ocean and 500–2000 m water depths were affected by this atmospheric bridge during the early deglaciation. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Identifying processes within the Earth System that have modulated atmospheric pCO2during each glacial cycle of the late Pleistocene stands as one of the grand challenges in climate science. The growing array of surface ocean pH estimates from the boron isotope proxy across the last glacial termination may reveal regions of the ocean that influenced the timing and magnitude of pCO2rise. Here we present two new boron isotope records from the subtropical‐subpolar transition zone of the Southwest Pacific that span the last 20 kyr, as well as new radiocarbon data from the same cores. The new data suggest this region was a source of carbon to the atmosphere rather than a moderate sink as it is today. Significantly higher outgassing is observed between ~16.5 and 14 kyr BP, associated with increasing δ13C and [CO3]2−at depth, suggesting loss of carbon from the intermediate ocean to the atmosphere. We use these new boron isotope records together with existing records to build a composite pH/pCO2curve for the surface oceans. The pH disequilibrium/CO2outgassing was widespread throughout the last deglaciation, likely explained by upwelling of CO2from the deep/intermediate ocean. During the Holocene, a smaller outgassing peak is observed at a time of relatively stable atmospheric CO2, which may be explained by regrowth of the terrestrial biosphere countering ocean CO2release. Our stack is likely biased toward upwelling/CO2source regions. Nevertheless, the composite pCO2curve provides robust evidence that various parts of the ocean were releasing CO2to the atmosphere over the last 25 kyr.

     
    more » « less