Abstract Traumatic brain injury (TBI), particularly from explosive blasts, is a major cause of casualties in modern military conflicts. Computational models are an important tool in understanding the underlying biomechanics of TBI but are highly dependent on the mechanical properties of soft tissue to produce accurate results. Reported material properties of brain tissue can vary by several orders of magnitude between studies, and no published set of material parameters exists for porcine brain tissue at strain rates relevant to blast. In this work, brain tissue from the brainstem, cerebellum, and cerebrum of freshly euthanized adolescent male Göttingen minipigs was tested in simple shear and unconfined compression at strain rates ranging from quasi-static (QS) to 300 s−1. Brain tissue showed significant strain rate stiffening in both shear and compression. Minimal differences were seen between different regions of the brain. Both hyperelastic and hyper-viscoelastic constitutive models were fit to experimental stress, considering data from either a single loading mode (unidirectional) or two loading modes together (bidirectional). The unidirectional hyper-viscoelastic models with an Ogden hyperelastic representation and a one-term Prony series best captured the response of brain tissue in all regions and rates. The bidirectional models were generally able to capture the response of the tissue in high-rate shear and all compression modes, but not the QS shear. Our constitutive models describe the first set of material parameters for porcine brain tissue relevant to loading modes and rates seen in blast injury.
more »
« less
Hyperelastic material properties of axonal fibers in brain white matter
Accurate characterization of the mechanical properties of the human brain at both microscopic and macroscopic length scales is a critical requirement for modeling of traumatic brain injury and brain folding. To date, most experimental studies that employ classical tension/compression/shear tests report the mechanical properties of the brain averaged over both the gray and white matter within the macroscopic regions of interest. As a result, there is a missing correlation between the independent mechanical properties of the microscopic constituent elements and the composite bulk macroscopic mechanical properties of the tissue. This microstructural computational study aims to inversely predict the hyperelastic mechanical properties of the axonal fibers and their surrounding extracellular matrix (ECM) from the bulk tissue's mechanical properties. We develop a representative volume element (RVE) model of the bulk tissue consisting of axonal fibers and ECM with the embedded element technique. A multiobjective optimization technique is implemented to calibrate the model and establish the independent mechanical properties of axonal fibers and ECM based on seven previously reported experimental mechanical tests for bulk white matter tissue from the corpus callosum. The result of the study shows that the discrepancy between the reported values for the elastic behavior of white matter in literature stems from the anisotropy of the tissue at the microscale. The shear modulus of the axonal fiber is seven times larger than the ECM, with axonal fibers that also show greater nonlinearity, contrary to the common assumption that both components exhibit identical nonlinear characteristics.
Statement of significance
The reported mechanical properties of white matter microstructure used in traumatic brain injury or brain mechanics studies vary widely, in some cases by up to two orders of magnitude. Currently, the material parameters of the white matter microstructure are identified by a single loading mode or ultimately two modes of the bulk tissue. The presented material models only define the response of the bulk and homogenized white matter at a macroscopic scale and cannot explicitly capture the connection between the material properties of microstructure and bulk structure. To fill this knowledge gap, our study characterizes the hyperelastic material properties of axonal fibers and ECM using microscale computational modeling and multiobjective optimization. The hyperelastic material properties for axonal fibers and ECM presented in this study are more accurate than previously proposed because they have been optimized using seven or six loading modes of the bulk tissue, which were previously limited to only two of the seven possible loading modes. As such, the predicted values with high accuracy could be used in various computational modeling studies. The systematic characterization of the material properties of the human brain tissue at both macro- and microscales will lead to more accurate computational predictions, which will enable a better understanding of injury criteria, and has a positive impact on the improved development of smart protection systems, and more accurate prediction of brain development and disease progression.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2123061
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10324993
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Brain multiphysics
- Volume:
- 2
- ISSN:
- 2666-5220
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)Abstract Background The pia arachnoid complex (PAC) is a cerebrospinal fluid-filled tissue conglomerate that surrounds the brain and spinal cord. Pia mater adheres directly to the surface of the brain while the arachnoid mater adheres to the deep surface of the dura mater. Collagen fibers, known as subarachnoid trabeculae (SAT) fibers, and microvascular structure lie intermediately to the pia and arachnoid meninges. Due to its structural role, alterations to the biomechanical properties of the PAC may change surface stress loading in traumatic brain injury (TBI) caused by sub-concussive hits. The aim of this study was to quantify the mechanical and morphological properties of ovine PAC. Methods Ovine brain samples (n = 10) were removed from the skull and tissue was harvested within 30 min post-mortem. To access the PAC, ovine skulls were split medially from the occipital region down the nasal bone on the superior and inferior aspects of the skull. A template was used to remove arachnoid samples from the left and right sides of the frontal and occipital regions of the brain. 10 ex-vivo samples were tested with uniaxial tension at 2 mm s −1 , average strain rate of 0.59 s −1 , until failure at < 5 h post extraction. The force and displacement data were acquired at 100 Hz. PAC tissue collagen fiber microstructure was characterized using second-harmonic generation (SHG) imaging on a subset of n = 4 stained tissue samples. To differentiate transverse blood vessels from SAT by visualization of cell nuclei and endothelial cells, samples were stained with DAPI and anti-von Willebrand Factor, respectively. The Mooney-Rivlin model for average stress–strain curve fit was used to model PAC material properties. Results The elastic modulus, ultimate stress, and ultimate strain were found to be 7.7 ± 3.0, 2.7 ± 0.76 MPa, and 0.60 ± 0.13, respectively. No statistical significance was found across brain dissection locations in terms of biomechanical properties. SHG images were post-processed to obtain average SAT fiber intersection density, concentration, porosity, tortuosity, segment length, orientation, radial counts, and diameter as 0.23, 26.14, 73.86%, 1.07 ± 0.28, 17.33 ± 15.25 µm, 84.66 ± 49.18°, 8.15%, 3.46 ± 1.62 µm, respectively. Conclusion For the sizes, strain, and strain rates tested, our results suggest that ovine PAC mechanical behavior is isotropic, and that the Mooney-Rivlin model is an appropriate curve-fitting constitutive equation for obtaining material parameters of PAC tissues.more » « less
-
A new finite element approach is proposed to study the propagation of stress in axons in the central nervous system (CNS) white matter. The axons are embedded in an extra cellular matrix (ECM) and are subjected to tensile loads under purely non-affine kinematic boundary conditions. The axons and the ECM are described by the Ogden hyperelastic material model. The effect of tethering of the axons by oligodendrocytes is investigated using the finite element model. Glial cells are often thought of as the “glue” that hold the axons together. More specifically, oligodendrocytes bond multiple axons to each other and create a myelin sheath that insulates and supports axons in the brainstem. The glial cells create a scaffold that supports the axons and can potentially bind 80 axons to a single oligodendrocyte.more » « less
In this study, the microstructure of the oligodendrocyte connections to axons is modeled using a spring-dashpot approximation. The model allows for the oligodendrocytes to wrap around the outer diameter of the axons at various locations, parameterizing the number of connections, distance between connection points, and the stiffness of the connection hubs. The parameterization followed the distribution of axon-oligodendrocyte connections provided by literature data in which the values were acquired through microtome of CNS white matter. We develop two models: 1) multiple oligodendrocytes arbitrarily tethered to the nearest axons, and 2) a single oligodendrocyte tethered to all the axons at various locations. The results depict stiffening of the axons, which indicates that the oligodendrocytes do aid in the redistribution of stress. We also observe the appearance of bending stresses at inflections points along the tortuous path of the axons when subjected to tensile loading. The bending stresses appear to exhibit a cyclic variation along the length of the undulated axons. This makes the axons more susceptible to damage accumulation and fatigue. Finally, the effect of multiple axon-myelin connections in the central nervous system and the effect of the distribution of these connections in the brain tissue is further investigated at present.
-
Material properties of brain white matter (BWM) show high anisotropy due to the complicated internal three-dimensional microstructure and variant interaction between heterogeneous brain-tissue (axon, myelin, and glia). From our previous study, finite element methods were used to merge micro-scale Representative Volume Elements (RVE) with orthotropic frequency domain viscoelasticity to an integral macro-scale BWM. Quantification of the micro-scale RVE with anisotropic frequency domain viscoelasticity is the core challenge in this study.more » « less
The RVE behavior is expressed by a viscoelastic constitutive material model, in which the frequency-related viscoelastic properties are imparted as storage modulus and loss modulus for the composite comprised of axonal fibers and extracellular glia. Using finite elements to build RVEs with anisotropic frequency domain viscoelastic material properties is computationally very consuming and resource-draining. Additionally, it is very challenging to build every single RVE using finite elements since the architecture of each RVE is arbitrary in an infinite data set. The architecture information encoded in the voxelized location is employed as input data and is consequently incorporated into a deep 3D convolution neural network (CNN) model that cross-references the RVEs’ material properties (output data). The output data (RVEs’ material properties) is calculated in parallel using an in-house developed finite element method, which models RVE samples of axon-myelin-glia composites. This novel combination of the CNN-RVE method achieved a dramatic reduction in the computation time compared with directly using finite element methods currently present in the literature.
-
Finite element analysis is used to study brain axonal injury and develop Brain White Matter (BWM) models while accounting for both the strain magnitude and the strain rate. These models are becoming more sophisticated and complicated due to the complex nature of the BMW composite structure with different material properties for each constituent phase. State-of-the-art studies focus on employing techniques that combine information about the local axonal directionality in different areas of the brain with diagnostic tools such as Diffusion-Weighted Magnetic Resonance Imaging (Diffusion-MRI). The diffusion-MRI data offers localization and orientation information of axonal tracks which are analyzed in finite element models to simulate virtual loading scenarios. Here, a BMW biphasic material model comprised of axons and neuroglia is considered. The model’s architectural anisotropy represented by a multitude of axonal orientations, that depend on specific brain regions, adds to its complexity. During this effort, we develop a finite element method to merge micro-scale Representative Volume Elements (RVEs) with orthotropic frequency domain viscoelasticity to an integrated macro-scale BWM finite element model, which incorporates local axonal orientation. Previous studies of this group focused on building RVEs that combined different volume fractions of axons and neuroglia and simulating their anisotropic viscoelastic properties. Via the proposed model, we can assign material properties and local architecture on each element based on the information from the orientation of the axonal traces. Consecutively, a BWM finite element model is derived with fully defined both material properties and material orientation. The frequency-domain dynamic response of the BMW model is analyzed to simulate larger scale diagnostic modalities such as MRI and MRE.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brain.2021.100035
