skip to main content


Title: The latitudinal temperature gradient and its climate dependence as inferred from foraminiferal δ 18 O over the past 95 million years
The latitudinal temperature gradient is a fundamental state parameter of the climate system tied to the dynamics of heat transport and radiative transfer. Thus, it is a primary target for temperature proxy reconstructions and global climate models. However, reconstructing the latitudinal temperature gradient in past climates remains challenging due to the scarcity of appropriate proxy records and large proxy–model disagreements. Here, we develop methods leveraging an extensive compilation of planktonic foraminifera δ 18 O to reconstruct a continuous record of the latitudinal sea-surface temperature (SST) gradient over the last 95 million years (My). We find that latitudinal SST gradients ranged from 26.5 to 15.3 °C over a mean global SST range of 15.3 to 32.5 °C, with the highest gradients during the coldest intervals of time. From this relationship, we calculate a polar amplification factor (PAF; the ratio of change in >60° S SST to change in global mean SST) of 1.44 ± 0.15. Our results are closer to model predictions than previous proxy-based estimates, primarily because δ 18 O-based high-latitude SST estimates more closely track benthic temperatures, yielding higher gradients. The consistent covariance of δ 18 O values in low- and high-latitude planktonic foraminifera and in benthic foraminifera, across numerous climate states, suggests a fundamental constraint on multiple aspects of the climate system, linking deep-sea temperatures, the latitudinal SST gradient, and global mean SSTs across large changes in atmospheric CO 2 , continental configuration, oceanic gateways, and the extent of continental ice sheets. This implies an important underlying, internally driven predictability of the climate system in vastly different background states.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1702851 1602557
NSF-PAR ID:
10333429
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Volume:
119
Issue:
11
ISSN:
0027-8424
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The early Eocene Climatic Optimum (EECO; ~ 53.3 to 49.1 Ma) was a period of the warmest sustained temperatures of the Cenozoic caused by perturbations to the global carbon cycle. Deep sea sediment cores and the microfossils preserved within them are the primary sources of information for these changes in climate and global carbon cycling but are subject to diagenetic alteration after deposition. One of the great challenges in paleoclimate research is determining how to accurately interpreting the proxy record by identifying the amount of chemical alteration of the isotopic and elemental compositions locked within microfossils such as foraminifera. The planktic foraminifera record has been biased by digenesis, provoking questions about the strength of the latitudinal temperature gradient throughout the EECO, specifically with respect to mismatches between proxy data and climate model simulations that remain unresolved. To investigate this question, we selected three deep sea sites that span across the Pacific Ocean, ODP Sites 865, 1209 and DSDP Site 207. From these sediments we extracted carefully screened planktic foraminifera and conducted analysis by two independent approaches on splits of the same individual foraminiferal shells. We measured the δ18O composition by conventional analysis (gas source mass spectrometry), and Mg/Ca ratios on fragments of the same shells by LA-ICP-MS that allows for a careful diagenetic screening. We then independently estimate sea surface temperatures and compare records to quantify the extent of bias in the planktonic foraminifera record. This approach helps to reassess the latitudinal temperature gradients across the EECO. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Efforts to estimate past global mean temperature and latitudinal gradients must contend with spatial heterogeneity in sea surface temperatures (SSTs). Here, we use modern SSTs to show that the environments from which most paleoclimatic data are drawn, shallow epeiric seas and continental margins, are systematically offset from zonal mean temperatures. Epeiric seas are warmer and more seasonal than open‐ocean values from the same latitudes, while continental margins exhibit consistent and predictable deviations related to gyre circulation. Warm temperatures inferred from Paleozoic proxy data may largely reflect that these data derive almost entirely from epeiric seas. Moreover, pseudoproxy analysis using Paleogene sampling localities demonstrates how undersampling of the full range of dynamical environments associated with gyre circulation can generate spurious estimates of latitudinal temperature gradients. Recognition of these global patterns permits a predictive framework within which to more robustly interpret proxy data, improve Earth system models, and reconstruct ancient dynamic regimes.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Southern Ocean sea ice plays a central role in the oceanic meridional overturning circulation, transforming globally prevalent watermasses through surface buoyancy loss and gain. Buoyancy loss due to surface cooling and sea ice growth promotes the formation of bottom water that flows into the Atlantic, Indian, and Pacific basins, while buoyancy gain due to sea ice melt helps transform the returning deep flow into intermediate and mode waters. Because northward expansion of Southern Ocean sea ice during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM; 19–23 kyr BP) may have enhanced deep ocean stratification and contributed to lower atmospheric CO2levels, reconstructions of sea ice extent are critical to understanding the LGM climate state. Here, we present a new sea ice proxy based on the18O/16O ratio of foraminifera (δ18Oc). In the seasonal sea ice zone, sea ice formation during austral winter creates a cold surface mixed layer that persists in the sub‐surface during spring and summer. The cold sub‐surface layer, known as winter water, sits above relatively warm deep water, creating an inverted temperature profile. The unique surface‐to‐deep temperature contrast is reflected in estimates of equilibrium δ18Oc, implying that paired analysis of planktonic and benthic foraminifera can be used to infer sea ice extent. To demonstrate the feasibility of the δ18Ocmethod, we present a compilation ofN. pachydermaandCibicidoidesspp. results from the Atlantic sector that yields an estimate of winter sea ice extent consistent with modern observations.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    We reconstruct sea surface temperatures (SSTs) at Deep Sea Drilling Project Site 608 (42.836°N, 23.087°), north of the Azores Front, and Ocean Drilling Program Site 982 (57.516°N, 15.866°), under the North Atlantic Current, in order to track Miocene (23.1–5.3 Ma) development of North Atlantic surface waters. Mean annual SSTs from TEX86and UK′37proxy estimates at both sites were 10–15 °C higher than modern through the Miocene Climatic Optimum (17–14.5 Ma). During the global cooling of the Middle Miocene Climate Transition (~14.5–12.5 Ma), SSTs at midlatitude Site 608 cooled by ~6 °C, whereas high‐latitude Site 982 cooled by only ~2 °C, resulting in an ~4 Myr collapse of the SST gradient between the two sites. This regional pattern is inconsistent with an increased latitudinal surface temperature gradient, as generally associated with global cooling episodes linked to decreasingpCO2levels. Instead, the pattern is best explained by enhanced ocean heat transport into the high‐latitude North Atlantic superimposed on the global cooling trend, probably due to enhanced Atlantic meridional overturning circulation and/or a stronger North Atlantic Current. During global late Miocene cooling (~8–7 Ma), surface waters cooled by ~6 °C at Site 982 while minimal change occurred at Site 608, reestablishing the North Atlantic SST gradient. The collapse and reemergence of the SST gradient between the middle‐ and high‐latitude North Atlantic suggests that interaction between changes in regional ocean circulation and the global response to changes in greenhouse gas concentration was important in Miocene climate evolution.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Lacustrine δ2H and δ18O isotope proxies are powerful tools for reconstructing past climate and precipitation changes in the Arctic. However, robust paleoclimate record interpretations depend on site‐specific lake water isotope systematics, which are poorly described in the eastern Canadian Arctic due to insufficient modern lake water isotope data. We use modern lake water isotopes (δ18O and δ2H) collected between 1994–1997 and 2017–2021 from a transect of sites spanning a Québec‐to‐Ellesmere Island gradient to evaluate the effects of inflow seasonality and evaporative enrichment on the δ2H and δ18O composition of lake water. Four lakes near Iqaluit, Nunavut sampled biweekly through three ice‐free seasons reflect mean annual precipitation isotopes with slight evaporative enrichment. In a 23° latitudinal transect of 181 lakes, through‐flowing lake water δ2H and δ18O fall along local meteoric water lines. Despite variability within each region, we observe a latitudinal pattern: southern lakes reflect mean annual precipitation isotopes, whereas northern lakes reflect summer‐biased precipitation isotopes. This pattern suggests that northern lakes are more fully flushed with summer precipitation, and we hypothesize that this occurs because the ratio of runoff to precipitation increases with latitude as vegetation cover decreases. Therefore, proxy records from through‐flowing lakes in this region should reflect precipitation isotopes with minimal influence of evaporation, but vegetation changes in lake catchments across a latitudinal transect and through geologic time may influence the seasonality of lake water isotopic compositions. Thus, we recommend that future lake water isotope proxy records are considered in context with temperature and ecological proxy records.

     
    more » « less