An official website of the United States government
Equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) quantifies the amount of warming resulting from a doubling of the atmospheric CO2 forcing. Despite recent advancements in climate simulation capabilities and global observations, there remains large uncertainty on the degree of future warming. To help alleviate this uncertainty, past climates provide a valuable insight into how the Earth will respond to elevated atmospheric CO2. However, there is evidence to suggest that ECS is dependent on background climate warmth, which may interfere with the direct utilization of paleo-ECS to understand present-day ECS. Thus, it is important that a range of different climate states are considered to better understand the factors modulating the relationship between CO2 and temperature. In this study, we focus on three time intervals: the mid-Pliocene Warm Period (3.3 – 3.0 Ma), the mid-Miocene (16.75 – 14.5 Ma), and the early Eocene (~50 Ma), in order to sample ECS from Cenozoic coolhouse to hothouse climates. Here, we combine the Bayesian framework of constraining the ECS and its uncertainty with several published methods to estimate the global mean surface temperature (GMST) from sparse proxy records. This framework utilizes an emergent constraint between the simulated GMST changes and climate sensitivities across the model ensemble. For each time interval, we employ a combination of parametric and non-parametric functions, coupled with a probabilistic approach to derive a refined estimate. Preliminary results for the Pliocene indicate a GMST reconstruction of approximately 19.3°C, which is higher than previous estimates that were derived using only marine records. Using this estimate, we calculate an ECS that is also higher than previously published values, especially due to the inclusion of high-latitude terrestrial temperature records into our estimates. Intriguingly, using the consistent methodology, our calculated ECS for the early Eocene is lower than that of the mid-Pliocene. This result does not support an amplified ECS in hothouse climate, and points to a potentially important role of ice albedo feedback in amplifying the ECS in coolhouse climate. Ongoing work will apply the same methodology to the mid-Miocene and further investigate the source for the estimated ECS state dependency between these climate intervals.
more »
« less
Opportunities and Challenges in Paleo-CO2 Reconstruction and Implications for Advancing our Understanding the Paleo-Earth System
Paleo-CO2 reconstructions are integral to understanding the evolution of Earth system processes and their interactions given that atmospheric-CO2 concentrations are intrinsically linked to planetary function. In this talk, we use several case studies, spanning the 3 Phanerozoic Eras, to illustrate the potential of paleo-CO2 records to constrain the magnitude and state-dependency of equilibrium climate sensitivity, to advance our understanding of global biogeochemical cycles, to test the sensitivity of Earth System modeled atmospheric and oceanic circulation to PCO2 over a range of climate states, and to interrogate ecosystem—CO2—climate linkages and physiological responses to CO2. Further advances in these areas, however, are dependent on how well we ‘know’ paleo-CO2 estimates. CO2 estimates exist for much of the past half-billion years, but the degree to which the accuracy and precision of these estimates are constrained is quite variable, leading to substantial uncertainty and inconsistency in paleo-CO2 estimates. Potential sources of this uncertainty and inconsistency include an incomplete understanding of how environmental and ecophysiological conditions and processes imprint the CO2 proxy signals we measure, of the sensitivity of the CO2 estimates to this uncertainty, and differences in approaches to assigning uncertainties to CO2 estimates, among other factors. Application of newly established screening criteria, defined as part of an effort to improve our understanding of how atmospheric CO2 has varied through the Cenozoic, illustrates how the majority of pre-Cenozoic estimates are unreliable in their current form. To address these issues and to advance paleo-CO2 reconstruction, we introduce CO2PIP, a new community-scale project that takes a two-step approach to building the next generation Phanerozoic-CO2 record. Collective efforts are modernizing existing terrestrial-based CO2 estimates through additional analyses, measurements and proxy system modeling to constrain critical parameters used to estimate paleo-CO2. A set of forward proxy system models being developed in collaboration with the CO2 community, will provide a quantified representation of proxy sensitivities to environmental and ecophysiological conditions and processes that govern the CO2 signals. Ultimately, statistical inversion analysis of the simulated and modernized proxy datasets will be used to revise individual CO2 records and to build a new integrated model-data-constrained CO2 record for the Phanerozoic.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2121594
- PAR ID:
- 10337026
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Annual VM Goldschmidt Conference
- ISSN:
- 1945-7022
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract The evolution of the spatial pattern of ocean surface warming affects global radiative feedback, yet different climate models provide varying estimates of future patterns. Paleoclimate data, especially from past warm periods, can help constrain future equilibrium warming patterns. By analyzing marine temperature records spanning the past 10 million years with a regression‐based technique that removes temporal dimensions, we extract long‐term ocean warming patterns and quantify relative sea surface temperature changes across the global ocean. This analysis revealed a distinct pattern of amplified warming that aligns with equilibrated model simulations under high CO2conditions, yet differs from the transient warming pattern observed over the past 160 years. This paleodata‐model comparison allows us to identify models that better capture fundamental aspects of Earth's warming response, while suggesting how ocean heat uptake and circulation changes modify the development of warming patterns over time. By combining this paleo‐ocean warming pattern with equilibrated model simulations, we characterized the likely evolution of global ocean warming as the climate system approaches equilibrium.more » « less
-
Abstract. Paleoclimate reconstructions of the Early Eocene provide important data constraints on the climate and hydrologic cycle under extreme warm conditions. Available terrestrial water isotope records have been primarily interpreted to signal an enhanced hydrologic cycle in the Early Eocene associated with large-scale warming induced by high atmospheric CO2. However, orbital-scale variations in these isotope records have been difficult to quantify and largely overlooked, even though orbitally driven changes in solar irradiance can impact temperature and the hydrologic cycle. In this study, we fill this gap using water isotope–climate simulations to investigate the orbital sensitivity of Earth's hydrologic cycle under different CO2 background states. We analyze the relative difference between climatic changes resulting from CO2 and orbital changes and find that the seasonal climate responses to orbital changes are larger than CO2-driven changes in several regions. Using terrestrial δ18O and δ2H records from the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), we compare our modeled isotopic seasonal range to fossil evidence and find approximate agreement between empirical and simulated isotopic compositions. The limitations surrounding the equilibrated snapshot simulations of this transient event and empirical data include timing and time interval discrepancies between model and data, the preservation state of the proxy, analytical uncertainty, the relationship between δ18O or δ2H and environmental context, and vegetation uncertainties within the simulations. In spite of the limitations, this study illustrates the utility of fully coupled, isotope-enabled climate models when comparing climatic changes and interpreting proxy records in times of extreme warmth.more » « less
-
A long-term record of global mean surface temperature (GMST) provides critical insight into the dynamical limits of Earth’s climate and the complex feedbacks between temperature and the broader Earth system. Here, we present PhanDA, a reconstruction of GMST over the past 485 million years, generated by statistically integrating proxy data with climate model simulations. PhanDA exhibits a large range of GMST, spanning 11° to 36°C. Partitioning the reconstruction into climate states indicates that more time was spent in warmer rather than colder climates and reveals consistent latitudinal temperature gradients within each state. There is a strong correlation between atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations and GMST, identifying CO2as the dominant control on variations in Phanerozoic global climate and suggesting an apparent Earth system sensitivity of ~8°C.more » « less
-
Abstract. The last deglaciation, which occurred from 18 000 to 11 000 years ago,is the most recent large natural climatic variation of global extent. Withaccurately dated paleoclimate records, we can investigate the timings ofrelated variables in the climate system during this major transition. Here,we use an accurate relative chronology to compare temperature proxy data andglobal atmospheric CO2 as recorded in Antarctic ice cores. In addition tofive regional records, we compare a δ18O stack, representingAntarctic climate variations with the high-resolution robustly dated WAISDivide CO2 record (West Antarctic Ice Sheet). We assess the CO2 and Antarctic temperature phaserelationship using a stochastic method to accurately identify the probabletimings of changes in their trends. Four coherent changes are identified forthe two series, and synchrony between CO2 and temperature is within the95 % uncertainty range for all of the changes except the end of glacial termination 1 (T1). During the onset of the last deglaciation at 18 ka and the deglaciationend at 11.5 ka, Antarctic temperature most likely led CO2 by several centuries (by 570 years, within a range of 127 to 751 years, 68 %probability, at the T1 onset; and by 532 years, within a range of 337 to 629years, 68 % probability, at the deglaciation end). At 14.4 ka, the onsetof the Antarctic Cold Reversal (ACR) period, our results do not show a clearlead or lag (Antarctic temperature leads by 50 years, within a range of−137 to 376 years, 68 % probability). The same is true at the end of the ACR(CO2 leads by 65 years, within a range of 211 to 117 years, 68 %probability). However, the timings of changes in trends for the individualproxy records show variations from the stack, indicating regional differencesin the pattern of temperature change, particularly in the WAIS Divide recordat the onset of the deglaciation; the Dome Fuji record at the deglaciationend; and the EDML record after 16 ka (EPICA Dronning Maud Land, where EPICA is the European Project for Ice Coring in Antarctica). In addition, two changes – one at 16 ka in the CO2 record and one after the ACR onset in three of theisotopic temperature records – do not have high-probability counterparts in the other record. The likely-variable phasing we identify testify to thecomplex nature of the mechanisms driving the carbon cycle and Antarctictemperature during the deglaciation.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
